Pornography, the Online Safety Act 2023 and the need for further reform

Clare McGlynn,Lorna Woods,Alexandros Antoniou,Clare McGlynn Lorna Woods Alexandros Antoniou a Durham Law School,Durham University,Durham,UKb Essex Law School,Essex University,Colchester,UKClare McGlynn KC (Hon) is a Professor of Law,Durham University with over twenty years' experience working closely with politicians,policy-makers and the voluntary sector to improve the regulation of image-based sexual abuse,extreme pornography and cyberflashing. Her research has been instrumental to the adoption of new criminal laws tackling online abuse and she has advised governments,human rights organisations and policy-makers across the world,as well as working with platforms such as Facebook,Google and Bumble to improve online safety. Her research on the sexually violent nature of mainstream porn (with Vera-Gray) in the British Journal of Criminology is the largest study to date of online porn. She is a co-author the recently published books Cyberflashing: recognising harms,reforming laws (2021) and Image-Based Sexual Abuse: a study on the causes and consequences of non-consensual nude or sexual imagery (2021).Lorna Woods,OBE is Professor of Internet Law at the University of Essex and a member of the Human Rights Centre. She has worked in the field of media and communications regulation for more than thirty years,publishing on both domestic and European law. From 2018 to 2023 she worked with Carnegie UK Trust on a project on the reduction of harm in social media and is now a consultation to the Online Safety Act network. She is an affiliate fellow at the Minderoo Centre for Technology and Democracy at Cambridge University as well as a member of the policy network at the Centre for Science and Policy there.Alexandros Antoniou is a Senior Lecturer in Media Law at the University of Essex. He researches communications law and intellectual property asset management. His work in these areas has been published in leading journals such as The Journal of Media Law,Communications Law,Entertainment Law Review and the Journal of Intellectual Property Law and Practice. He is a legal correspondent for the European Audiovisual Observatory.

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/17577632.2024.2357421

2024-06-07

Journal of Media Law

Abstract:The UK's Online Safety Act 2023 regulates pornography in a range of new ways which could radically alter both how pornography is accessed and the nature of the content available. However, while the Act ostensibly represents a new form of regulation focusing on the systems and processes of online platforms, in practice it is content-based. Our analysis reveals that the Act generates eight new classifications of pornography, each associated with a distinct legal framework, thereby creating a confusing and unnecessarily complex regulatory regime. Accordingly, we recommend further reforms to fortify and clarify the regulatory regime, as well as a more comprehensive review of pornography regulation in general, with the overall aim of reducing the harms of pornography.