"Astronomy" or "astrology": a brief history of an apparent confusion

A. Losev
DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1006.5209
2010-12-29
Abstract:The modern usage of the words astronomy and astrology is traced back to distinctions, largely ignored in recent scholarship. Three interpretations of celestial phenomena (in a geometric, a substantialist and a prognostic versions) coexisted during the Hellenistic period. From Plato to Isidore of Seville, semantic changes are evidenced and their later development is sketched.
History and Philosophy of Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper attempts to address the issue of the conceptual distinction between astronomy and astrology and their historical evolution. The author explores how these two terms were used and understood from ancient Greek times to the Middle Ages, and points out that although these concepts are easily distinguishable in modern culture, the boundaries between them were not always so clear historically. The paper also discusses the views of different philosophers such as Plato and Aristotle on these two fields, and analyzes the influence of Babylon on astronomy and how Ptolemy reconfigured this knowledge. Additionally, the paper emphasizes the different understandings and applications of these concepts from the Middle Ages to the Renaissance. Through these analyses, the paper aims to clarify the complex relationship between astronomy and astrology throughout history.