Topological analysis of the power grid and mitigation strategies against cascading failures

Sakshi Pahwa,Amelia Hodges,Caterina Scoglio,Sean Wood

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/SYSTEMS.2010.5482329

2010-06-24

Abstract:This paper presents a complex systems overview of a power grid network. In recent years, concerns about the robustness of the power grid have grown because of several cascading outages in different parts of the world. In this paper, cascading effect has been simulated on three different networks, the IEEE 300 bus test system, the IEEE 118 bus test system, and the WSCC 179 bus equivalent model, using the DC Power Flow Model. Power Degradation has been discussed as a measure to estimate the damage to the network, in terms of load loss and node loss. A network generator has been developed to generate graphs with characteristics similar to the IEEE standard networks and the generated graphs are then compared with the standard networks to show the effect of topology in determining the robustness of a power grid. Three mitigation strategies, Homogeneous Load Reduction, Targeted Range-Based Load Reduction, and Use of Distributed Renewable Sources in combination with Islanding, have been suggested. The Homogeneous Load Reduction is the simplest to implement but the Targeted Range-Based Load Reduction is the most effective strategy.

Adaptation and Self-Organizing Systems,Networking and Internet Architecture

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the robustness of power networks, especially the analysis and mitigation strategies for cascading failures. Specifically, the paper focuses on how to evaluate the vulnerability of power networks in the face of cascading failures through topological analysis and propose effective mitigation measures to reduce the impact of such failures on the power grid.

### Main research contents:
1. **Topological analysis**: The paper first gives a complex system overview of the power network. By simulating three different standard test systems (IEEE 300 - node system, IEEE 118 - node system and WSCC 179 - node equivalent model), it analyzes the influence of the network's topological structure on robustness.
2. **Cascading effect simulation**: It studies the propagation mechanism of cascading failures in different networks. The degree of network damage is quantified by the index of Power Degradation, including load loss and node loss.
3. **Network generator**: A network generator is developed to generate random graphs with similar characteristics to the standard networks, and then the robustness differences between these generated graphs and the standard networks are compared.
4. **Mitigation strategies**: Three strategies for mitigating cascading failures are proposed:
- **Homogeneous Load Reduction**: It is simple and easy to implement, but the effect is limited.
- **Targeted Range - Based Load Reduction**: It is more effective, but requires more complex calculations.
- **Use of Distributed Renewable Sources in Combination with Islanding**: By disconnecting some node clusters and using distributed renewable energy to supply power, the load of the main power grid is reduced.

### Research background:
In recent years, there have been multiple large - scale cascading blackout events in many regions around the world. These events not only affected the lives of millions of people, but also exposed the deficiencies in the robustness of existing power networks. Therefore, studying the topological structure of power networks and its impact on cascading failures is of great significance for improving the security of power systems.

### Conclusions and future work:
- **Conclusions**: The generated random networks show higher robustness due to their shorter characteristic path lengths. However, the clustering coefficients of these networks are lower, indicating poor local connectivity.
- **Future work**: Further study the feasibility of achieving shorter characteristic path lengths in actual power networks and use optimization techniques to determine the optimal points for islanding disconnection.

Through these studies, the paper provides theoretical basis and practical suggestions for improving the robustness of power networks.