Letter to the editor: was tuberculosis present in Homo erectus in Turkey?

C. Roberts,L. Pfister,S. Mays

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/ajpa.21056

2009-07-01

American Journal of Physical Anthropology

Abstract:In a recent contribution to the American Journal of Physical Anthropology, Kappelman et al. (2008) describe the first Homo erectus finding from Turkey, which consists of a partial and fragmentary calvaria from the site of Kocabas. The authors discuss peculiar and numerous granular impressions on the endocranial surface of the frontal bone and, based on the characteristics and locations of these lesions, they propose that the individual suffered from Leptomeningitis tuberculosa. In what follows we provide the basis for the diagnosis of tuberculosis (TB) in skeletal material as well as typical autopsy findings of meningitis tuberculosa cases to argue against Kappelman et al.’s interpretation. Furthermore, we provide what we believe are more plausible explanations for their findings. Early hominin remains are rare and are usually fragmentary and incomplete, thus limiting potential information that can be generated. The evidence for disease is rare in these remains, and we are not usually in a position to diagnose specific disease because of the poorly preserved nature of the remains and the impossibility of exploring distribution patterns of pathological lesions (as described in Ortner, 2003). It is therefore of particular interest that Kappelman et al.’s study reports an apparently very early example of TB.