What Type of Price Transparency Do We Need in Health Care?
Austin Frakt,Ateev Mehrotra
DOI: https://doi.org/10.7326/m19-0534
IF: 39.2
2019-04-02
Annals of Internal Medicine
Abstract:Under new U.S. Department of Health and Human Services rules, hospitals must post prices for all of their services as of 1 January 2019. This federal mandate is just the latest government foray in price transparency. More than one half of states has passed some form of price transparency legislation (1). The growing bipartisan demand for price transparency taps into frustration with high health care prices in the United States, the confusing way prices are communicated, and exorbitant "surprise bills" when a patient inadvertently sees an out-of-network provider. One hope is that communicating prices will cause patients to shop for lower ones, putting downward pressure on price growth.Under new U.S. Department of Health and Human Services rules, hospitals must post prices for all of their services as of 1 January 2019. This federal mandate is just the latest government foray in price transparency. More than one half of states has passed some form of price transparency legislation (1). The growing bipartisan demand for price transparency taps into frustration with high health care prices in the United States, the confusing way prices are communicated, and exorbitant "surprise bills" when a patient inadvertently sees an out-of-network provider. One hope is that communicating prices will cause patients to shop for lower ones, putting downward pressure on price growth.Are transparency efforts working, and will the Trump administration's new hospital price disclosure rule help? In a word, no. However, this problem has more to do with how these efforts are being implemented than with the idea of price transparency itself. The new rule mandates that hospitals report their chargemaster prices, but a vast gulf unfortunately remains between these prices and what insurers or patients actually pay. On average, Medicare pays 31% of charges (2). Furthermore, patients do not care what insurers pay—they care about their out-of-pocket payment based on their insurance benefit design.Are transparency efforts working, and will the Trump administration's new hospital price disclosure rule help? In a word, no. However, this problem has more to do with how these efforts are being implemented than with the idea of price transparency itself. The new rule mandates that hospitals report their chargemaster prices, but a vast gulf unfortunately remains between these prices and what insurers or patients actually pay. On average, Medicare pays 31% of charges (2). Furthermore, patients do not care what insurers pay—they care about their out-of-pocket payment based on their insurance benefit design.Another problem with chargemaster price disclosure is that it takes place at the individual service and supply level. Even if patients were motivated to shop for the lowest price, they typically would not shop separately for each bandage, scan, or laboratory test. These costs...Another problem with chargemaster price disclosure is that it takes place at the individual service and supply level. Even if patients were motivated to shop for the lowest price, they typically would not shop separately for each bandage, scan, or laboratory test. These costs...
medicine, general & internal