Developing a Standardised Model for Internal Control Evaluation

Conor O'Leary
2005-12-01
Abstract:This study develops an internal control evaluation (ICE) model - a prototype matrix model -which addresses limitations noted in previous studies. 94 auditors from 5 firms evaluated the internal control structure of a fictitious entity using their current firm methodology and the ICE model, and compared methods. For "overall usefulness" and three factors, "cost"; "logical development"; and "time to complete", auditors ranked the ICE model as good as current evaluation methods. For one factor "completeness", two firms considered it less beneficial. Results indicate attempts to develop a standardised evaluation model are worthwhile. Such a model may benefit the auditing profession, as standardisation may support the stance for self-regulation.
Engineering,Medicine,Business,Law
What problem does this paper attempt to address?