Abstract:Satellite imagery has been widely used to map urbanization processes. To address the urgent need for urban landscape mapping that goes beyond urban footprint analysis, the local climate zone (LCZ) scheme has been increasingly used to reveal the urban forms and functions important to urban heat islands and micro-climates across the globe. As with most supervised classification strategies, proper application of training data is critical for the success of LCZ classification models. However, the collection and application of LCZ training areas brings with it two challenges that may affect mapping success. First, because digitizing training areas is a time-consuming task, there is a broad effort in the LCZ mapping community to create a crowdsourced data collection among different experts. However, this strategy likely leads to inconsistencies in labels that could weaken models. Second, the LCZ labeling process typically involves the delineation of large zones from which multiple training samples are drawn, but those samples are likely spatially autocorrelated and lead to overly optimistic estimates of model accuracy. Although both effects -- inconsistent labeling and spatial autocorrelation -- are theoretically possible, it is unknown whether they substantially affect accuracy. We investigated both issues, specifically asking: (i) how do the discrepancies of LCZ labeling by different experts impact broad-scale LCZ mapping? (ii) to what extent does spatial correlation affect model prediction power? We used two classifiers (Random Forests and ResNets) to map eight metropolitan areas in the US into LCZs, comparing training areas drawn by different or consistent interpreters, and data splitting strategy using rules that allow or reduce spatial autocorrelation. We found large discrepancies among results built from crowdsourced training areas digitized by different experts; improving the consistency of labels can lead to substantial improvements in LCZ classification accuracy. Second, we found that spatial autocorrelation can boost the apparent accuracy of the classifier by 16% to 21%, leading to erroneous interpretation of mapping results. The two effects interplay as well: spatial autocorrelation in the raw data can lead to an underestimation of the model's predictive error when modeling with crowdsourced training areas of high inconsistency. Due to the uncertainty in the labeling process and spatial autocorrelation in derived training data, broad-scale LCZ mapping results should be interpreted with caution.

Exploring How Street-Level Images Help Enhance Remote-Sensing-Based Local Climate Zone Mapping

Local climate zone mapping using remote sensing: a synergetic use of daytime multi-view Ziyuan-3 stereo imageries and Luojia-1 nighttime light data

Towards Better Exploiting Object-Based Image Analysis Paradigm for Local Climate Zones Mapping

Local Climate Zone Classification by Seasonal and Diurnal Satellite Observations: An Integration of Daytime Thermal Infrared Multispectral Imageries and High-Resolution Night-Time Light Data

Comparing Object-Based and Pixel-Based Methods for Local Climate Zones Mapping with Multi-Source Data.

A Co-Training Approach to the Classification of Local Climate Zones with Multi-Source Data.

Local Climate Zone Mapping by Coupling Multilevel Features With Prior Knowledge Based on Remote Sensing Images

Advances of Local Climate Zone Mapping and Its Practice Using Object-Based Image Analysis

Application of training data affects success in broad-scale local climate zone mapping

Local Climate Zones Mapping Using Object-Based Image Analysis and Validation of Its Effectiveness Through Urban Surface Temperature Analysis in China

Mapping local climate zones for cities: A large review

Assessment of Local Climate Zone Classification Maps of Cities in China and Feasible Refinements

Mapping and analyzing the local climate zones in China’s 32 major cities using Landsat imagery based on a novel convolutional neural network

Applications of Local Climate Zone Classification Scheme to Improve Urban Sustainability: A Bibliometric Review

The urban morphology classification under local climate zone scheme based on the improved method - A case study of Changsha, China

Predicting Neighborhood-Level Residential Carbon Emissions from Street View Images Using Computer Vision and Machine Learning

Mapping Local Climate Zones Using ArcGIS-Based Method and Exploring Land Surface Temperature Characteristics in Chenzhou, China

Assessment of Local Climate Zone Products via Simplified Classification Rule with 3D Building Maps

SAR and Multi-Spectral Data Fusion for Local Climate Zone Classification with Multi-Branch Convolutional Neural Network

AutoLCZ: Towards Automatized Local Climate Zone Mapping from Rule-Based Remote Sensing

Urban Perception Evaluation and Street Refinement Governance Supported by Street View Visual Elements Analysis