Leading climate scientist Mann wins $1m in defamation lawsuit

Gareth Iacobucci
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q401
2024-02-15
BMJ
Abstract:The climate scientist Michael Mann has been awarded $1m (£0.8m; €0.9m) in a defamation lawsuit against two writers who compared his scientific work to that of a former football coach who was convicted of child molestation.In a statement posted on Mann's X account,1 one of his legal team, Pete Fontaine, said, "Today's verdict vindicates Mike Mann's good name and reputation. It also is a big victory for truth and scientists everywhere who dedicate their lives answering vital scientific questions impacting human health and the planet."The lawsuit, first brought in 2012, centred on articles by Rand Simberg, a former scholar for the Competitive Enterprise Institute think tank, and Mark Steyn, a Canadian writer and presenter who was writing for the National Review at the time. Their criticisms related to Mann's renowned "hockey stick" graph, first published in Nature in 1998, which illustrated the sharp rise in average global temperature in the...
medicine, general & internal
What problem does this paper attempt to address?