Abstract:This paper presents a comparison study of three control design approaches for humanoid balancing based on the Center of Mass (CoM) stabilization and body posture adjustment. The comparison was carried out under controlled circumstances allowing other researchers to replicate and compare our results with their own. The feedback control from state space design is based on simple models and provides sufficient robustness to control complex and high Degrees of Freedom (DoFs) systems, such as humanoids. The implemented strategies allow compliant behavior of the robot in reaction to impulsive or periodical disturbances, resulting in a smooth and human-like response while considering constraints. In this respect, we implemented two balancing strategies to compensate for the CoM deviation. The first one uses the robot’s capture point as a stability principle and the second one uses the Force/Torque sensors at the ankles to define a CoM reference that stabilizes the robot. In addition, was implemented a third strategy based on upper body orientation to absorb external disturbances and counterbalance them. Even though the balancing strategies are implemented independently, they can be merged to further increase balancing performance. The proposed strategies were previously applied on different humanoid bipedal platforms, however, their performance could not be properly benchmarked before. With this concern, this paper focuses on benchmarking in controlled scenarios to help the community in comparing different balance techniques. The key performance indicators (KPIs) used in our comparison are the CoM deviation, the settling time, the maximum measured orientation, passive gait measure, measured ankles torques, and reconstructed Center of Pressure (CoP). The benchmarking experiments were carried out in simulations and using the facility at Istituto Italiano di Tecnologia on the REEM-C humanoid robot provided by PAL robotics inside the EU H2020 project EUROBENCH framework.

Automatic gain tuning of a momentum based balancing controller for humanoid robots

Resolved-momentum-based real-time balance control for high-speed arm manipulation of humanoid robot

Balance maintenance in high-speed motion of humanoid robot arm-based on the 6D constraints of momentum change rate.

Momentum Control of Humanoid Robots with Series Elastic Actuators

Balance motion generation for a humanoid robot playing table tennis.

Optimal Momentum Compensation with Waist Joint for Online Biped Gait Generating of Humanoid Robot

Compliance Control for Standing Maintenance of Humanoid Robots under Unknown External Disturbances.

A momentum-based balance controller for humanoid robots on non-level and non-stationary ground

Momentum Control of an Underactuated Flying Humanoid Robot

Benchmarking Dynamic Balancing Controllers for Humanoid Robots

Automatic Gain Tuning for Humanoid Robots Walking Architectures Using Gradient-Free Optimization Techniques

Momentum control for stable whole body motion of humanoid robots

Balancing experiments on a torque-controlled humanoid with hierarchical inverse dynamics

Momentum control for balance

Direct Centroidal Control for Balanced Humanoid Locomotion

Balance control strategy of humanoid robot based on stiffness control

Uneven Terrain Walking with Linear and Angular Momentum Allocation

Torque and velocity controllers to perform jumps with a humanoid robot: theory and implementation on the iCub robot

Implementation of a trajectory library approach to controlling humanoid standing balance

Adaptive Non-linear Centroidal MPC with Stability Guarantees for Robust Locomotion of Legged Robots

A Predictive Momentum-Based Whole-Body Torque Controller: Theory and Simulations for the iCub Stepping