No sex differences in oxygen uptake or extraction kinetics in the moderate or heavy exercise intensity domains

Maria Solleiro Pons,Lina Bernert,Emily Hume,Luke Hughes,Zander Williams,Mark Burnley,Paul Ansdell

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1152/japplphysiol.00429.2023

2024-01-12

Journal of Applied Physiology

Abstract:The integrative response to exercise differs between sexes, with oxidative energy contribution purported as a potential mechanism. The present study investigated whether this difference was evident in the kinetics of oxygen uptake (V̇O 2 ) and extraction (HHb+Mb) during exercise. Sixteen adults (8 males, 8 females, age: 27±5 years) completed three experimental visits. Incremental exercise testing was performed to obtain lactate threshold and V̇O 2peak . Subsequent visits involved three six-minute cycling bouts at 80% of lactate threshold and one 30-minute bout at a work rate 30% between the lactate threshold and power at V̇O 2peak . Pulmonary gas exchange and near-infrared spectroscopy of the vastus lateralis were used to continuously sample V̇O 2 and HHb+Mb, respectively. The phase II V̇O 2 kinetics were quantified using mono-exponential curves during moderate and heavy exercise. Slow component amplitudes were also quantified for the heavy intensity domain. Relative V̇O 2peak values were not different between sexes ( p=0.111). Males achieved ~30% greater power outputs ( p=0.002). In the moderate and heavy intensity domains, the relative amplitude of the phase II transition was not different between sexes for V̇O 2 (~24 and ~40% V̇O 2peak , p≥0.179) and HHb+Mb (~20 and ~32% ischemia, p≥0.193). Similarly, there were no sex differences in the time constants for V̇O 2 (~28 s, p≥0.385) or HHb+Mb (~10s, p≥0.274). In the heavy intensity domain, neither V̇O 2 ( p≥0.686) or HHb+Mb ( p≥0.432) slow component amplitudes were different between sexes. The oxidative response to moderate and heavy intensity exercise did not differ between males and females, suggesting similar dynamic responses of oxidative metabolism during intensity-matched exercise.

physiology,sport sciences

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The study aimed to investigate whether there are differences in oxygen uptake (VO₂) and extraction kinetics between males and females during moderate and high-intensity exercise. Specifically, the research focused on how quickly the body increases oxygen supply at the onset of exercise to meet energy demands and whether this response differs by gender.

The study design included:
1. **Participants**: A total of 16 adults participated in the experiment (8 males, 8 females), with an average age of 27 years.
2. **Experimental Steps**:
- Conduct incremental load exercise tests to determine the lactate threshold (LT) and peak oxygen uptake (VO₂peak).
- Complete three 6-minute cycling exercises at an intensity of 80% of the lactate threshold, and one 30-minute cycling exercise at a work rate between the lactate threshold and peak oxygen uptake (30%∆).
- Continuously collect VO₂ and HHb+Mb (deoxyhemoglobin + myoglobin) data using pulmonary function measurements and near-infrared spectroscopy (NIRS).
3. **Data Analysis**:
- Analyze VO₂ kinetics, including kinetic parameters at different stages such as time constant (τ) and amplitude.
- Perform similar analysis on HHb+Mb kinetics.

Key findings include:
- Absolute peak oxygen uptake (VO₂peak) was higher in males than in females, but there was no significant difference in relative peak oxygen uptake (standardized by body weight) between the sexes.
- In the moderate and high-intensity exercise domains, there were no significant differences in Phase II kinetic parameters (such as time constant τ and relative amplitude) of VO₂ and HHb+Mb between males and females.
- There was also no significant gender difference in the amplitude of the slow component within the intensity domain.

In summary, the study did not find significant differences in oxidative metabolic dynamic responses between males and females during moderate and high-intensity exercise, indicating that the oxidative metabolic responses of both sexes are similar at the same exercise intensity.