Abstract:Above is the title of the talk that Professor Ravindra Kulkarni asked me to give. It is a tall order as I am not a professionally trained historian, although I like to read history in my leisure. Naturally, I am more familiar with the mathematical achievements of China than of other countries. In reading through some of the writings by Western historians on mathematics, I am often surprised by the somewhat biased discussions towards the mathematical achievements of Asia. There is no question that the ancient Greeks made numerous fundamental contributions to mathematics, as we can see many of them in use in our present day. However, many of the Greek manuscripts were partially destroyed during the early centuries, and therefore, it takes great efforts to identify the form of the original manuscripts. The Romans, the Byzantines, the Arabs and the Moors all spent much efforts to translate and circulate the classic Greek manuscripts. Often, great ancient books incorporate a collection of many people’s works and were sometimes edited by a number of authors. Commenting on the Euclid’s Elements (believed to be written around 300 BC), the Greek mathematician Proclus of fifth century AD wrote: “Euclid, who put together the Elements, collecting many of Eudoxus’ theorems, perfecting many of Theaetetus’, and also bringing to irrefragable demonstration the things which were only somewhat loosely proved by his predecessors.” There are copies of Euclid’s Elements in Greek that are in the Vatican Library of the Holy See and the Bodleian Library of Oxford University. However, they are not complete and of variable quality. (See a fragment of the Elements from around 100 AD in Figure 1. Many hypotheses have been put forth on the contents of the original text based on translations and originals. Similarly, the origins of ancient Chinese books of mathematics such as the Nine Chapters on the Mathematical Art are difficult to know for sure. Most likely, the Nine Chapters is an accumulation of works of many generations and was updated by many people. The recent discovery of an old book dated around 186 BC showed some form of the preliminary version of the Nine Chapters. There are several outstanding contributions in mathematics that appeared in different cultures. The most notable is the Pythagorean theorem. Pythagoras is believed to be born between 580 to 568 BC. This is not much later than the time when the Egyptian papyrus was introduced into Greece around 650 BC. It was said that he traveled to Egypt, Babylon and perhaps even India. Since there are ancient records of the Pythagorean triples in all these countries besides China, it is likely that Pythagoras learned the statement of his theorem from these countries. On the other hand, his great contribution is that he is the first one who proved the theorem. In fact, the concept of a proof based on formal logic found in Greek mathematics is rather unique as compared with other countries. It may be a mystery that countries far apart discovered the same theorem at different levels of depth.

Comparison of Chinese and Western Ancient Mathematical Values

Mathematical Character Between the Instrument and Culture: the Exploration of Mathematical Significance from the Concept of Patterned Mathematical Ontology

Jewish culture, Chinese culture, and mathematics education

Differences Between Ideas of Confucius and Plato

On Mathematical Symbols in China

Comparison of Chinese High School Math Education Objectives in the Traditional Chinese Education System and International Education System

A Comparative Study on the Training of Talents of Mathematics in China and in Japan from 1868 (the Meiji Restoration in Japan) to the Second World War

Comparative Study of Chinese and Western Literature

On Mathematics Culture

The comparison of the wisdom view in Chinese and Western cultures

Thinking Pattern and Culture Difference

Western Mathematics in China from the 16th to the 20th Century

Comparative Analysis on Chinese and Canadian Primary School Mathematics Estimation Education Differences

Study on the Difference between China and the U.S.Indicator System from Cultural Background

Study on the Logical Ideas in Chinese Ancient Mathematics from “Liu Hui’s Commentary of the Chiu Chang Suan Shu” (Research of the Relations between Calculation and Proof, Arithmetic and Logic)

The Past, Present and Future of Mathematics in China and India

A Study of Dr. Joseph Needham's Comparison of Chinese Philosophy and Western Philosophy

Mathematical traditions in Ancient Greece and Rome

How are mathematicians as part of mathematics history represented in contemporary Chinese school mathematics textbooks?

A Brief Comparison of the U.S. and Chinese Middle School Mathematics Programs

The Value of Harmony Thinking and the Cultural Character of Chinese Traditional Military Science