Abstract:Analysis of Brightness-mode ultrasound-captured fascicle angle (FA) and fascicle length (FL) can be completed manually with computer-based programs or by automated programs. Insufficient data exists regarding reliability and accuracy of automated tools. Therefore, the purpose of this study was to determine the test-retest reliability of automatic and manual ultrasound analyses, while determining accuracy of the automatic tool against the manual equivalent. Twenty-three participants (mean ± SD; age = 24 ± 4 years; height = 172.2 ± 10.5 cm; body mass = 73.1 ± 16.1 kg) completed one laboratory visit consisting of two trials where vastus lateralis muscle architecture was assessed with ultrasound. Images were taken at both lower (10 MHz) and higher frequency (12 MHz). Images were analyzed manually in an open-source imaging program and automatically using a separate open-source macro function. Test-retest reliability statistics were calculated for automatic and manual analyses. Accuracy was determined with validity statistics and were calculated for automatic analyses. The results show that manual ultrasound analyses for FA and FL for both lower and higher frequency displayed good reliability (ICC2,1 = 0.75–0.86). However, automatic ultrasound analyses for FA and FL revealed moderate reliability (ICC2,1 = 0.61–0.72) for the lower frequency images and poor reliability (ICC2,1 = 0.16–0.27) for higher frequency images. When assessed against manual techniques, automatic analyses presented greater total error (TE) and standard error of the estimate (SEE) for FA at lower frequency (constant error (CE) = −3.91°, TE = 5.57°, SEE = 3.45°) than higher (CE = −2.78°, TE = −4.54°, SEE = 2.45°). For FL, the higher frequency error (CE = 0.92 cm, TE = 2.12 cm, SEE = 1.15 cm) was similar to lower frequency error (CE = 1.98 cm, TE = 3.66 cm, SEE = 1.57 cm). The findings overall show that manual analyses had good reliability and low absolute error, while demonstrating the automated counterpart had poor to moderate reliability and large errors in analyses. These findings may be impactful as they highlight the good reliability and low error associated with manually analyzed ultrasound images and validate a novel automatic tool for analyzing ultrasound images. Future work should focus on improving reliability and decreasing error in automated image analysis tools. Automated tools are promising for the field as they eliminate biases between analysts and may be more time efficient than manual techniques.

Application of Artificial Intelligence to Automate the Reconstruction of Muscle Cross-Sectional Area Obtained by Ultrasound

Validation of an Artificial Intelligence-Based Ultrasound Imaging System for Quantifying Muscle Architecture Parameters of the Rectus Femoris in Disease-Related Malnutrition (DRM)

Reliability and Validity of Muscle Size and Quality Analysis Techniques

Validation of Panoramic Ultrasound Measurement of the Cross-Sectional Area of the Vastus Medialis

Muscle Cross-Sectional Area Segmentation in Transverse Ultrasound Images Using Vision Transformers

A comparative study of two automated solutions for cross-sectional skeletal muscle measurement from abdominal computed tomography images

Reliability and accuracy of ultrasound image analyses completed manually versus an automated tool

Semi-automatic 3-D Reconstruction Measurement of Muscle Volume with Magnetic Resonance Imaging

Application of Deep Learning for Real-Time Ablation Zone Measurement in Ultrasound Imaging

Deep learning-based automatic pipeline for quantitative assessment of thigh muscle morphology and fatty infiltration

Validation of an Automatic Method for Reconstruction, Delineation, and Measurement of Levator Hiatus in Clinical Practice.

Feasibility of artificial intelligence assisted quantitative muscle ultrasound in carpal tunnel syndrome

Validation of a novel AI-based automated multimodal image registration of CBCT and intraoral scan aiding presurgical implant planning

Reliability and Validity of Abdominal Skeletal Muscle Area Measurement Using Magnetic Resonance Imaging

The feasibility and preliminary application of deltoid muscle volume measurement using MR volume of interest method

Evaluation of the reliability of measuring lower back muscles cross-sectional area based on manual segmentation within multi-level MRI images

Reliability of Rehabilitative Musculoskeletal Sonography for Measuring the Visible Cross-Sectional Area of Suboccipital Muscles

Towards Autonomous Atlas-based Ultrasound Acquisitions in Presence of Articulated Motion

Automatic three-dimensional reconstruction and characterization of articular cartilage from high-resolution ultrasound acquisitions

Deep learning segmentation of transverse musculoskeletal ultrasound images for neuromuscular disease assessment

Artificial intelligence-aided CT segmentation for body composition analysis: a validation study