Abstract:Aromatics is an important chemical material with a greatly increasing demand across the world. However, its production normally depends on the conventional oil-based naphtha to aromatics (OBNTA) route, resulting in difficulty for oil-shortage countries to meet local demand. The coal-based methanol to aromatics (CBMTA) route is considered a promising alternative to diversify the production of the aromatic whereas its industrial competitiveness relative to the OBNTA route has been not fully assessed at a resource-environment-economy level. This study proposes a comprehensive assessment framework that integrates the life cycle assessment, technical-economic analysis, and entropy weight method to quantify and compare the resource consumption, environmental emission, and economic benefit of the CBMTA and OBNTA routes. The operating data for the industrialized plants, economic data of China's market, and background data from the LCA database are taken as the input of the assessment framework. The sensitivity to operating and economic data and uncertainty caused by original data, allocation procedures, and feedstock sources are considered. The assessment shows that the CBMTA route scores worse comprehensive competitiveness than the OBNTA route due to its higher resource consumption and environmental emission. However, it performs well in economic benefit at Chinese current prices, which may attract more attention from investors. Based on the assessment, a SWOT analysis is carried out to further address resource-environment-economy tradeoffs. The analysis shows a considerable prospect of the CBMTA route thanks to all kinds of external opportunities, which however need to vigorously promote cleaner production policies and specific investment strategies tailored to local resource-environment-economy conditions. The current work can help policymakers, stakeholders, and investors better understand the multi-dimensional tradeoffs and make decisions.

Comparative resource-environment-economy assessment of coal- and oil-based aromatics production

Comparative Technoeconomic Analysis and Life Cycle Assessment of Aromatics Production from Methanol and Naphtha

Emergy Evaluation of Aromatics Production from Methanol and Naphtha

Multi-objective optimization of aromatic extraction process

Comprehensive competitiveness assessment of four coal-to-liquid routes and conventional oil refining route in China

Techno-economic Analysis and Life Cycle Assessment of Coal-to-aromatics Process with Integration of Renewable Energy-Based Hydrogen Generation Technology

Process Design and Analysis of Aromatics Production from Coal Via Methanol with a High Yield

Comprehensive analysis of environmental impacts and energy consumption of biomass-to-methanol and coal-to-methanol via life cycle assessment

Comparison of Light Olefins Production Routes in China: Combining Techno-Economics and Security Analysis

Comparative Life Cycle Environmental, Exergteic, and Economic Assessment of Three Hydrocarbon-Based Ethylene Production Routes

Aromatics Production from Methanol and Pentane: Conceptual Process Design, Comparative Energy and Techno-Economic Analysis

A Comparison Between Coal-to-olefins and Oil-Based Ethylene in China: an Economic and Environmental Prospective

Comparative environmental assessment of methanol production technologies: A cradle-to-gate life cycle analysis

Life cycle assessment and techno-economic analysis of ethanol production via coal and its competitors: A comparative study

Analysis of China's Olefin Industry with a System Optimization Model – with Different Scenarios of Dynamic Oil and Coal Prices

Techno-economic analysis and comparison of coal-based chemical technologies with consideration of water resources scarcity

Technical alternatives for coke oven gas utilization in China: A comparative analysis of environment-economic-strategic perspectives

Emergy Evaluation of Methanol and Naphtha to Aromatics Systems Combined with Renewable Power Generation

Dynamic material flow analysis of Chinese ethylene production processes and optimal pathway exploration with potential environmental-economic impacts

An economic analysis of twenty light olefin production pathways

Integration of Methanol Aromatization with Light Hydrocarbon Aromatization Toward Increasing Aromatic Yields: Conceptual Process Designs and Comparative Analysis