Abstract:This study presents an open source method for detecting 3D printing anomalies by comparing images of printed layers from a stationary monocular camera with G-code-based reference images of an ideal process generated with Blender, an open source free physics rendering engine. Recognition of visual deviations was accomplished by analyzing the similarity of histograms of oriented gradients (HOG) of local image areas. The developed technique requires preliminary modeling of the working environment to achieve the best match for orientation, color rendering, lighting, and other parameters of the printed part. The output of the algorithm is a level of mismatch between printed and synthetic reference layers. Twelve similarity and distance measures were implemented and compared for their effectiveness at detecting 3D printing errors on six different representative failure types (local infill defects, presence of a foreign body in the layer, spaghetti problem, separation and shift of the printing part from the working surface, defects in thin walls, and layer shift) and their control error-free print images. The results show that although Kendall's tau, Jaccard, and Sorensen similarities are the most sensitive, Pearson's r, Spearman's rho, cosine, and Dice similarities produce the more distinguishable results. This open source method allows the program to notice critical errors in the early stages of their occurrence and either pause manufacturing processes for further investigation by an operator or in the future intelligent automatic error correction. The implementation of this novel method does not require preliminary data for training, and the greatest efficiency can be achieved with the mass production of parts by either additive or subtractive manufacturing of the same geometric shape. This open-source method has the potential means of enabling smart distributed recycling for additive manufacturing in challenging environments.

Defect monitoring in additive manufacturing through OpenCV-based remote video access

In situ monitoring for numerical controlled manufacturing of large conceptual prototype based on multi-view stitching fusion

Visual Detection of Surface Defects Based on Self-Feature Comparison in Robot 3-D Printing

Online Quality Monitoring in Material Extrusion Additive Manufacturing Processes Based on Laser Scanning Technology

Multi-view Online Vision Detection Based on Robot Fused Deposit Modeling 3D Printing Technology

In-Situ Defect Detection of Metal Additive Manufacturing: An Integrated Framework

A CNN-Based Adaptive Surface Monitoring System for Fused Deposition Modeling

Towards smart monitored AM: Open source in-situ layer-wise 3D printing image anomaly detection using histograms of oriented gradients and a physics-based rendering engine

A Real-Time Defect Detection Strategy for Additive Manufacturing Processes Based on Deep Learning and Machine Vision Technologies

Measurement of additively manufactured part dimensions using OpenCV for process monitoring

An In-Situ Deep Learning-Based Defect Detection Technology for Additive Manufacturing Process

Surface Fault Detection in 3D Printed Objects Using Deep Learning

Generalizable process monitoring for FFF 3D printing with machine vision

Defect Localization Using Region of Interest and Histogram-Based Enhancement Approaches in 3D-Printing

Real-Time 3D Printing Remote Defect Detection (Stringing) with Computer Vision and Artificial Intelligence

Multi-Axis 3D Printing Defect Detecting by Machine Vision with Convolutional Neural Networks

Machine Vision-Based Surface Defect Detection Study for Ceramic 3D Printing

In situ real time defect detection of 3D printed parts

Machine learning and sensor-based approach for defect detection in MEX additive manufacturing process- A Review

Semi-Siamese Network for Robust Change Detection Across Different Domains with Applications to 3D Printing

3D Printing Fault Detection Based on Process Data