Abstract:Current optical flow-based neural networks for Particle Image Velocimetry (PIV) are largely trained on synthetic datasets emulating real-world scenarios. While synthetic datasets provide greater control and variation than what can be achieved using experimental datasets for supervised learning, it requires a deeper understanding of how or what factors dictate the learning behaviors of deep neural networks for PIV. In this study, we investigate the performance of the Recurrent All-Pairs Field Transforms (RAFT-PIV) network, the current state-of-the-art deep learning architecture for PIV, by testing it on unseen experimentally generated datasets. The results from RAFT-PIV are compared with a conventional cross-correlation-based method, Adaptive PIV. The experimental PIV datasets were generated for a typical scenario of flow past a circular cylinder in a rectangular channel. These test datasets encompassed variations in particle diameters, particle seeding densities, and flow speeds, all falling within the parameter range used for training RAFT-PIV. We also explore how different image pre-processing techniques can impact and potentially enhance the performance of RAFT-PIV on real-world datasets. Thorough testing with real-world experimental PIV datasets reveals the resilience of the optical flow-based method's variations to PIV hyperparameters, in contrast to the conventional PIV technique. The ensemble-averaged Root Mean Squared Errors (RMSE) between the RAFT-PIV and Adaptive PIV estimations generally range between 0.5 to 2 [px] and show a slight reduction as particle densities increase or Reynolds numbers decrease. Furthermore, findings indicate that employing image pre-processing techniques to enhance input particle image quality doesn't improve RAFT-PIV predictions; instead, it incurs higher computational costs and impacts estimations of small-scale structures.

Challenges of deep unsupervised optical flow estimation for particle-image velocimetry data

Unsupervised Learning on Particle Image Velocimetry with Embedded Cross‐correlation and Divergence‐free Constraint

Particle Image Velocimetry Based on a Deep Learning Motion Estimator.

Generalization of deep recurrent optical flow estimation for particle-image velocimetry data

Deep-PIV: a new framework of PIV using deep learning techniques

Particle image velocimetry based on a deep neural network

Unsupervised Learning of Scene Flow Estimation Fusing with Local Rigidity.

DeepPTV: Particle Tracking Velocimetry for Complex Flow Motion via Deep Neural Networks

Recurrent Graph Optimal Transport for Learning 3D Flow Motion in Particle Tracking

A Dense Optical Flow Registration Algorithm Based on Deep Learning

Dense Motion Estimation of Particle Images Via a Convolutional Neural Network

Real-time and On-site Aerodynamics using Stereoscopic PIV and Deep Optical Flow Learning

Learning By Analogy: Reliable Supervision From Transformations For Unsupervised Optical Flow Estimation

Experimental dataset investigation of deep recurrent optical flow learning for particle image velocimetry: Flow past a circular cylinder

Survey on Unsupervised Learning Methods for Optical Flow Estimation

Unsupervised Deep Learning for Optical Flow Estimation.

Unsupervised Optical Flow Estimation Based on Improved Feature Pyramid

An Unsupervised Optical Flow Estimation For LiDAR Image Sequences

Unsupervised Learning Optical Flow in Multi-frame Dynamic Environment Using Temporal Dynamic Modeling

STFlow: Self-Taught Optical Flow Estimation Using Pseudo Labels

MRDFlow: Unsupervised Optical Flow Estimation Network With Multi-Scale Recurrent Decoder