Abstract:Both seed predators and herbivores can have profound effects on individual plant growth, reproduction and survival, but their population‐level effects are less well understood. While most plants interact with a suite of seed predators and herbivores over their life cycle, few studies incorporate the effects of multiple interacting partners and multiple life stages on plant population growth. We constructed a matrix model using 6 years of data from a rare, seed‐producing population of American chestnut (Castanea dentata). We combined field demographic data with published experimental results on the effects of pre‐dispersal seed predators (weevils) and post‐dispersal seed predators (scatter‐hoarding vertebrates) and incorporated the effect of vertebrate herbivores estimated from the field data. We explored the impact of these three different animal interactions for short‐term (transient) and long‐term (asymptotic) tree population growth. In addition, we used the model to explore the conditions under which scatter hoarding would function as a mutualism. Seed predators had greater effect on both short‐ and long‐term population growth than herbivores. Although weevil infestation can greatly reduce the probability of germination, pre‐dispersal seed predators had smaller effects on both short‐ or long‐term population growth than post‐dispersal predators. The elasticities of weevil‐related parameters were also small. The effect of browsers on both the short‐ and long‐term population growth rate were the smallest of the effects studied. Post‐dispersal seed predation affected population growth the most in the interactions studied. The probability of seed removal was among the largest elasticities, similar in magnitude to survival of large trees. Synthesis. Our results indicate that neither weevils nor the intensity of browse damage observed at our study site are likely to hinder tree regeneration or reintroduction, although both reduced population growth. Although researchers and forest managers often assume that seeds are unimportant for long‐lived tree populations, our test of this assumption shows that scatterhoarders and other post‐dispersal seed consumers can significantly limit natural regeneration. Forest management that alters scatterhoarder behaviour could have significant effects on tree population dynamics that are largely unexplored. Our results indicate that neither weevils nor the intensity of browse damage observed at our study site are likely to hinder tree regeneration or reintroduction, although both reduced population growth. Although researchers and forest managers often assume that seeds are unimportant for long‐lived tree populations, our test of this assumption shows that scatterhoarders and other post‐dispersal seed consumers can significantly limit natural regeneration. Forest management that alters scatterhoarder behaviour could have significant effects on tree population dynamics that are largely unexplored.

Bold rats (Niviventer confucianus) are more effective in seed dispersal: evidence both under enclosure conditions and in the field

Rodent Abundance Triggered Switch Between the Relative Mutualism and Predation in a Rodent-Seed System of the Subtropical Island Forest.

Behaviour, body mass and sex: How intraspecific variation influences seed dispersal by a scatter‐hoarding rodent

Scatter-hoarding rodents are important seed dispersers in pine plantations

Seed traits and burial state affect plant seed secondary dispersal mediated by rodents

Cascading effects of forested area and isolation on seed dispersal effectiveness of rodents on subtropical islands

Trait-mediated seed predation, dispersal and survival among frugivore-dispersed plants in a fragmented subtropical forest, Southwest China

Pilfering personalities: Effects of small mammal personality on cache pilferage

Individual behaviour shapes patterns of bird‐mediated seed dispersal

Size-related Seed Use by Rodents on Early Recruitment of Quercus Serrata in a Subtropical Island Forest

Conflicting selection pressures on seed size and germination caused by carnivorous seed dispersers

Effects of Seed Size and Frequency on Seed Dispersal and Predation by Small Mammals

Physical seed damage, not rodent's saliva, accelerates seed germination of trees in a subtropical forest

Effects of Seed Traits on the Cache Size of a Scatter-Hoarding Rodent, Leopoldamys Edwardsi

Evolutionary and ecological patterns of scatter‐ and larder‐hoarding behaviours in rodents

Effects of Seed Size and Cache Density on the Seed Fate of Quercus wutaishanica Mediated by Rodents

Group effects of desert rodent communities on plant seed dispersal

The Effects of Seed Detectability and Seed Traits on Hoarding Preference of Two Rodent Species.

Discrimination Behavior Mediates Foraging Quality Versus Quantity Trade-Offs: Nut Choice in Wild Rodents

Boldness suppresses hoarding behavior in food hoarding season and reduces over‐wintering survival in a social rodent

Scatterhoarders drive long‐ and short‐term population dynamics of a nut‐producing tree, while pre‐dispersal seed predators and herbivores have little effect