Towards a Multi-Scale Effect of Land Mixed Use on Resident Population—A Novel Explanatory Framework of Interactive Spatial Factors

Liu Liu,Huang Huang,Jiaxin Qi
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/land13030331
IF: 3.905
2024-03-06
Land
Abstract:Starting from Jane Jacobs' critiques and largely promoted and emphasized by New Urbanism, land mixed use (LMU) has become prevalent worldwide. It is believed to be an efficient approach to shaping a higher level of vitality in the economy, equality in society, and quality in the environment. To reveal the differences of this effect at distinct spatial scales, this study selected the two most related outcomes of LMU—resident population distribution and changes—to investigate the LMU impacts. A novel framework is developed to quantify the interactive impact of pairwise LMU-related factors at multiple scales, and the geographical detector is applied to identify the relationship between resident population distribution/changes and LMU. Taking the Jiading District of Shanghai as a pilot case, the framework was applied and tested. The results showed LMU affected resident population distribution distinctively from 600 m to 3000 m grid scales. The grid scale of 1800 m, approximately ten blocks, is revealed to be the optimal scale for discussing LMU with the selected factors. Also, these factors play different roles at different spatial scales. Some factors strongly affect the resident population distribution only when working with other factors. The study emphasized the crucial role of scale in LMU and suggested an open framework to support the decision making and policy making in planning for a better performance of smart growth and sustainability via LMU. It can help researchers obtain the optimal scale for the LMU plans with different sets of factors and identify the key factors in various contexts. Thus, this framework also contributes to supporting other practices of land mixed use beyond our study region.
environmental studies
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The core problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore the multi - scale effects of land - mix - use (LMU) on the distribution and change of the resident population at different spatial scales. Specifically, the study aims to reveal how land - mix - use affects the distribution and change of the resident population at different spatial scales and develop a new explanatory framework to quantify the interactive effects of paired LMU - related factors. ### Main Research Questions 1. **Differences in the Effects of Land - mix - use at Different Spatial Scales**: - The study attempts to reveal whether there are significant differences in the effects of land - mix - use on the distribution and change of the resident population at different spatial scales (such as the 600 - meter to 3,000 - meter grid scale). 2. **Determination of the Optimal Spatial Scale**: - Through analysis, the study hopes to find the best spatial scale when discussing land - mix - use. For example, the study found that the 1,800 - meter grid scale, which is approximately equivalent to ten blocks, is the optimal scale for discussing the relationship between LMU and selected factors. 3. **Interactions between Factors**: - The study also focuses on the interactions between different factors at different spatial scales. Some factors will have a significant impact on the distribution of the resident population only when they act in combination with other factors. ### Methodological Framework To verify the above hypotheses, the study adopted the following methods: - **Geographical Detector (GD)**: It is used to identify the relationship between the distribution and change of the resident population and land - mix - use. GD can detect possible causal relationships between variables and evaluate the explanatory power of factors by calculating the q - value. - **Multi - scale Analysis**: By conducting analysis at different grid scales (600 meters to 3,000 meters), the study considered the Modifiable Areal Unit Problem (MAUP) to ensure the accuracy of the results. ### Significance of the Study This study emphasizes the importance of spatial scale in land - mix - use and proposes an open framework to support planning decisions and policy - making for more intelligent growth and sustainable development. Through this framework, researchers can find the optimal spatial scale applicable to different combinations of factors and identify key factors, thus providing a scientific basis for urban planning. ### Conclusions The research results show that the impact of land - mix - use on the distribution of the resident population is significantly different at different spatial scales, and there is an optimal spatial scale (about 1,800 meters). In addition, the roles of different factors at different scales are also different, and some factors only show significant impacts when they act in synergy with other factors. These findings are helpful for better understanding the complex impacts of land - mix - use on urban development and provide valuable references for future urban planning.