Abstract:Background: Numerous publications on natural resource valuations consider contexts where environmental assets at risk are significant to Indigenous Peoples and their estates. In the last two decades alone, many applied studies have aimed at investigating the 'value' of socio-environmental outcomes from the perspectives of the general populations including Indigenous Peoples. The term 'value' is often invoked in varying contexts ranging from empirical research to Natural Resource Management (NRM) strategies and policies. Underpinning all valuation exercises is a conceptual approach to defining and analyzing value, which is contextual given that different philosophies and worldviews consider nature's 'value' differently. Our objective was to understand value philosophies underpinning diverse NRM 'value' paradigms and to evaluate compatibility with Indigenous Peoples' value attribution. Method: We conducted a systematic search for publications on nature studies from multiple databases using a Boolean strategy. The processes for literature identification and selection are presented in a PRISMA flowchart. The study then critically reviewed and synthesized insights from the literature on the interpretations, conceptualizations, and elicitations of value, particularly in contexts where NRM influences Indigenous estates. Review results: We found that philosophical perspectives define how 'value' is conceptualized and evaluated. Most studies reviewed rested on the economic paradigm grounded in anthropocentric utilitarian value-framing, and limited studies considered a relational value lens that reflects Indigenous Peoples' value attribution for the natural environment. A relational lens sits outside of the usual 'instrumental versus intrinsic' value dichotomy and deems human-nature connections coupled, and worthy in themselves. Discussion: The paper demonstrates the commonalities and inconsistencies across diverse value conceptualizations and describes emerging pluralistic approaches consistent with Indigenous value attribution. A novel framework for understanding and bridging the different conceptual and analytical valuation lenses, particularly on water, is presented ensuring that multiple, complex, and distinct value dimensions are empirically bridged in studies involving Indigenous Peoples.

Non-market valuation and Indigenous Peoples' values: researcher constraints and policy impacts

Nature's value, philosophies, theories, and concepts: a critical review and suggestions for future indigenous research

Diverse values of nature for sustainability

Aligning Indigenous values and cultural ecosystem services for ecosystem accounting: A review

The Nature of the Beast: Wildlife Valuation from the Iconic to the Ordinary

Holistic valuation of Nature-Based Solutions accounting for human perceptions and nature benefits

Reconceptualizing 'effectiveness' in Environmental Projects: Can We Measure Values-Related Achievements?

Application of Ecosystem Service Value in Land Use Change Research: Bottlenecks and Prospects

Who Pays Attention to Indigenous Peoples in Sustainable Development and Why? Evidence From Socially Responsible Investment Mutual Funds in North America

Evolving nature-based solutions for Australia's Indigenous estate in 2024 – opportunities and challenges

Why nature matters: A systematic review of intrinsic, instrumental, and relational values

Valuing water: A global survey of the values that underpin water decisions

An Analysis of the Worldwide Research on the Socio-Cultural Valuation of Forest Ecosystem Services

Towards Making EIA More Human-Centric: Demonstration in Nepal of a Values Crystallization Approach to Capture Local Shared Values for Scoping Use

Incorporating diverse values of nature in decision-making—theory and practice

Valuing plurality: Environmental humanities approaches to ecosystem services and Nature's Contributions to People

A review of Indigenous knowledge and participation in environmental monitoring

Navigating University Openness in Research Policy Inconsistent with Indigenous Data Sovereignty: A Case Analysis

Environmental Valuation and Benefit-Cost Analysis in U.K. Policy

Investing in Nature: Assessing the Effects of Monetary and Non-Monetary Valuations on Decision-Making

Quantifying intangible benefits of water sensitive urban systems and practices: an overview of non-market valuation studies