On Bohmian trajectories in two-particle interference devices

Louis Marchildon

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.quant-ph/0101132

2001-01-29

Quantum Physics

Abstract:Claims have been made that, in two-particle interference experiments involving bosons, Bohmian trajectories may entail observable consequences incompatible with standard quantum mechanics. By general arguments and by an examination of specific instances, we show that this is not the case.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Comments on "On Bohm trajectories in two-particle interference devices" by L. Marchildon

Partha Ghose

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.quant-ph/0102131

2001-02-27

Quantum Physics

Abstract:Marchildon's arguments against my earlier work are refuted.
Bohmian trajectories for the half-line barrier

Remy Dubertrand,Jeong-Bo Shim,Ward Struyve

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1751-8121/aaa4f9

2017-12-09

Abstract:Bohmian trajectories are considered for a particle that is free (i.e. the potential energy is zero), except for a half-line barrier. On the barrier, both Dirichlet and Neumann boundary conditions are considered. The half-line barrier yields one of the simplest cases of diffraction. Using the exact time-dependent propagator found by Schulman, the trajectories are computed numerically for different initial Gaussian wave packets. In particular, it is found that different boundary conditions may lead to qualitatively different sets of trajectories. In the Dirichlet case, the particles tend to be more strongly repelled. The case of an incoming plane wave is also considered. The corresponding Bohmian trajectories are compared with the trajectories of an oil drop hopping on the surface of a vibrating bath.

Quantum Physics
Symmetries and singular behaviors with Bohmian trajectories

A. S. Sanz

2024-07-11

Abstract:Quantum mechanics is able to produce challenging behaviors even in the simplest situations. This is possible because of the important dynamical role that phase plays in the evolution of quantum systems, very similar, nonetheless, to effects observable in analogous optical systems. The present work focuses on how Bohmian mechanics proves to be a rather convenient theoretical framework to analyze phase-based phenomena, since the phase constitutes the central element in this hydrodynamical formulation of quantum mechanics. More specifically, it allows us to understand how spatial phase variations give rise to velocity fields that eventually rule the dynamical behavior of quantum systems, and that, when integrated in time locally (i.e., taking into account specific positions), they provide us with a neat local (point by point) description of the system evolution in the configuration space. Indeed, it will also be seen that this idea transcends the quantum realm and can be profitably used to describe the behavior of optical analogs with rather singular behaviors. With this purpose, two interesting phenomena that take place in free space are considered, namely, the self-acceleration and shape-invariance of Airy beams, and spontaneous self-focusing.

Quantum Physics,Optics
Interference, reduced action, and trajectories

Edward R. Floyd

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10701-007-9154-4

2007-10-14

Abstract:Instead of investigating the interference between two stationary, rectilinear wave functions in a trajectory representation by examining the two rectilinear wave functions individually, we examine a dichromatic wave function that is synthesized from the two interfering wave functions. The physics of interference is contained in the reduced action for the dichromatic wave function. As this reduced action is a generator of the motion for the dichromatic wave function, it determines the dichromatic wave function's trajectory. The quantum effective mass renders insight into the behavior of the trajectory. The trajectory in turn renders insight into quantum nonlocality.

Quantum Physics
Bohm - de Broglie Cycles

Olivier Piguet

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10955-023-03137-z

2023-07-27

Abstract:In the de Broglie-Bohm quantum theory, particles describe trajectories determined by the flux associated with their wave function. These trajectories are studied here for relativistic spin-one-half particles.Based in explicit numerical calculations for the case of a massless particle in dimension three space-time, it is shown that if the wave function is an eigenfunction of the total angular momentum, the trajectories begin as circles of slowly increasing radius until a transition time at which they tend to follow straight lines. Arrival times at some detector, as well as their probability distribution are calculated, too. The chosen energy and momentum parameters are of the orders of magnitude met in graphene's physics.

Quantum Physics,Other Condensed Matter,High Energy Physics - Theory
Experimental Nonlocal Steering of Bohmian Trajectories

Ya Xiao,Yaron Kedem,Jin-Shi Xu,Chuan-Feng Li,Guang-Can Guo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1364/oe.25.014463

IF: 3.8

2017-01-01

Optics Express

Abstract:Interpretations of quantum mechanics (QM), or proposals for underlying theories, that attempt to present a definite realist picture, such as Bohmian mechanics, require strong non-local effects. Naively, these effects would violate causality and contradict special relativity. However if the theory agrees with QM the violation cannot be observed directly. Here, we demonstrate experimentally such an effect: we steer the velocity and trajectory of a Bohmian particle using a remote measurement. We use a pair of photons and entangle the spatial transverse position of one with the polarization of the other. The first photon is sent to a double-slit-like apparatus, where its trajectory is measured using the technique of Weak Measurements. The other photon is projected to a linear polarization state. The choice of polarization state, and the result, steer the first photon in the most intuitive sense of the word. The effect is indeed shown to be dramatic, while being easy to visualize. We discuss its strength and what are the conditions for it to occur.
Interference of Quantum Trajectories

Brecht Donvil,Paolo Muratore-Ginanneschi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-022-31533-8

2022-01-07

Abstract:We extend quantum trajectory theory to encompass the evolution of a large class of open quantum systems interacting with an environment at {arbitrary coupling strength}. Specifically, we prove that general time-local quantum master equations admit an unraveling described by ordinary jump-stochastic differential equations. The sufficient condition is to weigh the state vector Monte Carlo averages by a probability pseudo-measure which we call the "influence martingale". The influence martingale satisfies a $ 1d $ stochastic differential equation enslaved to the ones governing the quantum trajectories. Our interpretation is that the influence martingale models interference effects between distinct realizations of quantum trajectories at strong system-environment coupling. Our result proves the existence of a Markovian quantum trajectory picture in the Hilbert space of the system for completely bounded divisible dynamical maps. Furthermore, our result provides a new avenue to numerically integrate systems with large numbers of degrees of freedom by naturally extending the existing theory.

Quantum Physics,Mathematical Physics
Bohm-Aharonov type effects in dissipative atomic systems

Allan I. Solomon,Sonia G. Schirmer

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.quant-ph/0512198

2005-12-23

Abstract:A state in quantum mechanics is defined as a positive operator of norm 1. For finite systems, this may be thought of as a positive matrix of trace 1. This constraint of positivity imposes severe restrictions on the allowed evolution of such a state. From the mathematical viewpoint, we describe the two forms of standard dynamical equations - global (Kraus) and local (Lindblad) - and show how each of these gives rise to a semi-group description of the evolution. We then look at specific examples from atomic systems, involving 3-level systems for simplicity, and show how these mathematical constraints give rise to non-intuitive physical phenomena, reminiscent of Bohm-Aharonov effects. In particular, we show that for a multi-level atomic system it is generally impossible to isolate the levels, and this leads to observable effects on the population relaxation and decoherence.

Quantum Physics
Quantum statistics in Bohmian trajectory gravity

Thomas Andersen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1909.12088

2019-09-21

General Physics

Abstract:The recent experimental proposals by Bose et al. and Marletto et al. (BMV) outline a way to test for the quantum nature of gravity by measuring gravitationally induced differential phase accumulation over the superposed paths of two 10^-14kg masses. These authors outline the expected outcome of these experiments for semi-classical, quantum gravity and collapse models. It is found that both semi-classical and collapse models predict a lack of entanglement in the experimental results. This work predicts the outcome of the BMV experiment in Bohmian trajectory gravity - where classical gravity is assumed to couple to the particle configuration in each Bohmian path, as opposed to semi-classical gravity where gravity couples to the expectation value of the wave function, or of quantized gravity, where the gravitational field is itself in a quantum superposition. In the case of the BMV experiment, Bohmian trajectory gravity predicts that there will be quantum entanglement. This is surprising as the gravitational field is treated classically. A discussion of how Bohmian trajectory gravity can induce quantum entanglement for a non-superposed gravitational field is put forward.
A time (anti)symmetric approach to the double solution theory

Pierre Jamet,Aurélien Drezet

2024-10-30

Abstract:In this work we present a new theoretical approach to interpreting and reproducing quantum mechanics using trajectory-guided wavelets. Inspired by the 1925 work of Louis de Broglie, we demonstrate that pulses composed of a difference between a retarded wave and an advanced wave (known as antisymmetric waves) are capable of following quantum trajectories predicted by de Broglie-Bohm theory (also known as Bohmian mechanics). Our theory reproduces the main results of orthodox quantum mechanics and, unlike Bohmian theory, is local in the Bell sense. We show that this is linked to the superdeterminism and past-future (anti)symmetry of our theory.

Quantum Physics,History and Philosophy of Physics,Optics
Interacting quantum trajectories for particles with spin 1/2

R. Lombardini,B. Poirier

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00268976.2024.2334805

2024-03-30

Molecular Physics

Abstract:In recent decades, the de Broglie-Bohm or 'pilot wave' interpretation of quantum mechanics–especially its concept of the 'quantum trajectory'–has inspired a plethora of computational methods in molecular and chemical physics. One particularly promising subclass of such methods are the 'interacting quantum trajectory' (IQT) methods, for which an ensemble of trajectories is propagated independently of–and without any recourse to–an underlying wavefunction. In this work, an IQT version of the Pauli equation is developed–enabling spin to be incorporated into IQT theories for the first time, to the authors' knowledge. The new trajectory-based dynamical equations are then used to solve two iconic quantum problems involving spin: the 'quantum spin flipper', and the Stern-Gerlach experiment.

chemistry, physical,physics, atomic, molecular & chemical
Bohmian analysis of dark solutions in interfering Bose-Einstein condensates: The dynamical role of underlying velocity fields

J. Tounli,A. S. Sanz

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rinp.2024.107859

2024-07-11

Abstract:In the last decades, the experimental research on Bose-Einstein interferometry has received much attention due to promising technological implications. This has thus motivated the development of numerical simulations aimed at solving the time-dependent Gross-Pitaevskii equation and its reduced one-dimensional version to better understand the development of interference-type features and the subsequent soliton dynamics. In this work, Bohmian mechanics is considered as an additional tool to further explore and analyze the formation and evolution in real time of the soliton arrays that follow the merging of two condensates. An alternative explanation is thus provided in terms of an underlying dynamical velocity field, directly linked to the local phase variations undergone by the condensate along its evolution. Although the reduced one-dimensional model is considered here, it still captures the essence of the phenomenon, rendering a neat picture of the full evolution without diminishing the generality of the description. To better appreciate the subtleties of free versus bound dynamics, two cases are discussed. First, the soliton dynamics exhibited by a coherent superposition of two freely released condensates is studied, discussing the peculiarities of the underlying velocity field and the corresponding flux trajectories in terms of both the peak-to-peak distance between the two initial clouds and the addition of a phase difference between them. In the latter case, an interesting correspondence with the well-known Aharonov-Bohm effect is found. Then, the recurrence dynamics displayed by the more general case of two condensates released from the two opposite turning points of a harmonic trap is considered in terms of the distance between such turning points. [...]

Quantum Physics
Monte Carlo Bohmian Dynamics from Trajectory Stability Properties

J Liu,N Makri

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1021/jp040149n

2004-01-01

Abstract:It is shown that the quantum force in the Bohmian formulation of quantum mechanics can be related to the stability properties of the given trajectory. In turn, the evolution of the stability properties is governed by higher order derivatives of the quantum potential, leading to an infinite hierarchy of coupled differential equations whose solution specifies completely all aspects of the dynamics. Neglecting derivatives of the quantum potential beyond a certain order allows truncation of the hierarchy, leading to approximate Bohmian trajectories. Use of the method in conjunction with Bohmian initial value formulations [ J. Chem. Phys. 2003, 119, 60] gives rise to simple position-space representations of observables or time correlation functions. These are analogous to approximate quasiclassical expressions based on the Wigner or Husimi phase space density but involve lower dimensional integrals with smoother integrands and avoid the costly evaluation of phase space transforms. The lowest-order version of the truncated hierarchy can capture large corrections to classical mechanical treatments and yields (with fewer trajectories) results that are somewhat more accurate than those based on quasiclassical phase space treatments.
Consequences Of A Two-Time Relativistic Bohmian Model

Giuseppe Raguní

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1572-9494/ad48fe

2024-05-10

Communications in Theoretical Physics

Abstract:Effects of a Bohmian type quantum-relativistic theory are explored. The model is obtained by introducing a new and independent time parameter whose relative motions are not directly observable and cause the quantum uncertainties of the physical observables. Unlike the usual de Broglie-Bohm theories, the Quantum Potential does not affect directly the observable motion but it determines that one relative to the new time variable. It turns out that the Zitterbewegung of a free particle, of which a more general law is obtained, is the key example of these hidden motions and, through it, it seems possible to give physical reality to the Feynman's paths. A relativistic revision of the uncertainty principle also derives from the theory.

physics, multidisciplinary
Coherent States and Modified de Broglie-Bohm Complex Quantum Trajectories

Moncy V. John,Kiran Mathew

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10701-013-9722-8

2013-09-27

Abstract:This paper examines the nature of classical correspondence in the case of coherent states at the level of quantum trajectories. We first show that for a harmonic oscillator, the coherent state complex quantum trajectories and the complex classical trajectories are identical to each other. This congruence in the complex plane, not restricted to high quantum numbers alone, illustrates that the harmonic oscillator in a coherent state executes classical motion. The quantum trajectories are those conceived in a modified de Broglie-Bohm scheme and we note that identical classical and quantum trajectories for coherent states are obtained only in the present approach. The study is extended to Gazeau-Klauder and SUSY quantum mechanics-based coherent states of a particle in an infinite potential well and that in a symmetric Poschl-Teller (PT) potential by solving for the trajectories numerically. For the coherent state of the infinite potential well, almost identical classical and quantum trajectories are obtained whereas for the PT potential, though classical trajectories are not regained, a periodic motion results as t --> \infty.

Quantum Physics,High Energy Physics - Theory,Mathematical Physics
Arrival time and Bohmian Mechanics: It is the theory which decides what we can measure

Aurélien Drezet

2024-09-16

Abstract:In this work we analyze recent proposals by Das and Dürr (DD) to measure the arrival time distributions of quantum particles within the framework of de Broglie Bohm theory (or Bohmian mechanics). We also analyze the criticisms made by Goldstein Tumulka and Zanghì (GTZ) of these same proposals, and show that each protagonist is both right and wrong. In fine, we show that DD's predictions are indeed measurable in principle, but that they will not lead to violations of the no-signalling theorem used in Bell's theorem, in contradiction with some of Das and Maudlin's hopes.

Quantum Physics,History and Philosophy of Physics
Testing trajectory-based determinism via time probability distributions

Matheus V. Scherer,Alexandre D. Ribeiro,Renato M. Angelo

2024-04-15

Abstract:It is notorious that quantum mechanics (QM) cannot predict well-defined values for all physical quantities. Less well-known, however, is the fact that QM is unable to furnish probabilistic predictions even in emblematic scenarios such as the double-slit experiment. In contrast, equipped with postulate trajectories, Bohmian mechanics (BM) has inherited more predictive power. It follows that, contrary to common belief, QM and BM are not just different interpretations but distinct theories. This work formalizes the aforementioned assertions and illustrates them through three case studies: (i) free particle, (ii) free fall under a uniform gravitational field, and (iii) the double-slit experiment. Specifically, we introduce a prescription for constructing a flight-time probability distribution within generic trajectory-equipped theories. We then apply our formalism to BM and derive probability distributions that are unreachable by QM. Our results can, in principle, be tested against real experiments, thereby assessing the validity of Bohmian trajectories.

Quantum Physics
Order in de Broglie - Bohm quantum mechanics

G. Contopoulos,N. Delis,C. Efthymiopoulos

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1751-8113/45/16/165301

2012-03-26

Abstract:A usual assumption in the so-called {\it de Broglie - Bohm} approach to quantum dynamics is that the quantum trajectories subject to typical `guiding' wavefunctions turn to be quite irregular, i.e. {\it chaotic} (in the dynamical systems' sense). In the present paper, we consider mainly cases in which the quantum trajectories are {\it ordered}, i.e. they have zero Lyapunov characteristic numbers. We use perturbative methods to establish the existence of such trajectories from a theoretical point of view, while we analyze their properties via numerical experiments. Using a 2D harmonic oscillator system, we first establish conditions under which a trajectory can be shown to avoid close encounters with a moving nodal point, thus avoiding the source of chaos in this system. We then consider series expansions for trajectories both in the interior and the exterior of the domain covered by nodal lines, probing the domain of convergence as well as how successful the series are in comparison with numerical computations or regular trajectories. We then examine a Hénon - Heiles system possessing regular trajectories, thus generalizing previous results. Finally, we explore a key issue of physical interest in the context of the de Broglie - Bohm formalism, namely the influence of order in the so-called {\it quantum relaxation} effect. We show that the existence of regular trajectories poses restrictions to the quantum relaxation process, and we give examples in which the relaxation is suppressed even when we consider initial ensembles of only chaotic trajectories, provided, however, that the system as a whole is characterized by a certain degree of order.

Quantum Physics
Probabilities and trajectories in a classical wave-particle duality

Y Couder,E Fort

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1742-6596/361/1/012001

2012-05-10

Journal of Physics: Conference Series

Abstract:Several recent experiments were devoted to walkers, structures that associate a droplet bouncing on a vibrated liquid with the surface waves it excites. They reveal that a form of wave-particle duality exists in this classical system with the emergence of quantum-like behaviours. Here we revisit the single particle diffraction experiment and show the coexistence of two waves. The measured probability distributions are ruled by the diffraction of a quantumlike probability wave. But the observation of a single walker reveals that the droplet is driven by a pilot wave of different spatial structure that determines its trajectory in real space. The existence of two waves of these types had been proposed by de Broglie in his double solution model of quantum mechanics. A difference with the latter is that the pilot-wave is, in our experiment, endowed with a path memory. When intrusive measurements are performed, this memory effect induces transient chaotic individual trajectories that generate the resulting statistical behaviour.

On Bohmian trajectories in two-particle interference devices

Comments on "On Bohm trajectories in two-particle interference devices" by L. Marchildon

Bohmian trajectories for the half-line barrier

Symmetries and singular behaviors with Bohmian trajectories

Interference, reduced action, and trajectories

Bohm - de Broglie Cycles

Experimental Nonlocal Steering of Bohmian Trajectories

Interference of Quantum Trajectories

Bohm-Aharonov type effects in dissipative atomic systems

Quantum statistics in Bohmian trajectory gravity

A time (anti)symmetric approach to the double solution theory

Interacting quantum trajectories for particles with spin 1/2

Bohmian analysis of dark solutions in interfering Bose-Einstein condensates: The dynamical role of underlying velocity fields

Monte Carlo Bohmian Dynamics from Trajectory Stability Properties

Consequences Of A Two-Time Relativistic Bohmian Model

Coherent States and Modified de Broglie-Bohm Complex Quantum Trajectories

Arrival time and Bohmian Mechanics: It is the theory which decides what we can measure

Testing trajectory-based determinism via time probability distributions

Order in de Broglie - Bohm quantum mechanics

Probabilities and trajectories in a classical wave-particle duality