Revisiting, Rewriting, Reexperiencing: Clinical Writing Today

Daria Colombo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00332828.2024.2319015

2024-04-06

The Psychoanalytic Quarterly

Abstract:Psychoanalytic writing exerts a unique allure over me. —Giuseppe Civitarese Footnote 1

psychology, psychoanalysis

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Does it Appear to 'Resemble' Reality? on the Ethics of Psychoanalytic Writing

Giuseppe Civitarese

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00332828.2024.2319642

2024-04-06

The Psychoanalytic Quarterly

Abstract:This paper explores the intricate nexus of writing and psychoanalysis by addressing a key question: In what and how many directions should analytic writing be ethical? The author structures the argument across three axes. First, in an introduction, writing's role as a psychoanalytic invariant is emphasized. Then, an exploration ensues, delving into writing as praxis, navigating complex technical choices, from micro- to macro-perspectives in clinical vignettes, their autobiographical essence, their relevance as models for theory, self-revelation, etc. Lastly, a succinct epilogue considers the relationship between aesthetics and ethics in psychoanalytic writing.

psychology, psychoanalysis
Flashes in a Moment of Danger: On the Autobiographical Essence of Psychoanalytic Writing in Adrienne Harris's Essay "You Must Remember This"

Giuseppe Civitarese

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/10481885.2024.2346442

2024-06-19

Psychoanalytic Dialogues

Abstract:The author emphasizes Adrienne Harris's skillful use of autobiographical material in his writing, an aspect that contributes to making it a remarkable essay. He also argues that any psychoanalytic writing about is invariably autobiographical, and that this is also the way, in Walter Benjamin's phrase, to move from mere chronicle to history. Nothing in a psychoanalytic essay tastes true unless it has first been immersed in the subjectivity of the narrator.

psychology, psychoanalysis
Psychology and creative writing: the role of experiential learning in the journey from fact to fiction, and the implications for therapy

Catherine Deveney

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/08893675.2020.1846864

2020-12-03

Journal of Poetry Therapy

Abstract:This qualitative research paper discusses the importance of experiential learning in the creative writing process, the cognitive processing of difficult emotions that can result from writing creatively in both the first and third person, and the implications of this in therapeutic settings. It looks at the ways experiential learning can come not just first-hand from life experience, but also through interviewing others about their experiences, and the ways Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis can then be used to interpret the material and act as a stepping stone between fact and fiction. The study is based on the writer's 20-year databank of journalistic interviews, which represents hundreds of single case studies, and also on her experience of writing four published novels. It examines the significance of the overlap between creativity, psychology, and journalism, and the therapeutic implications of that overlap for journalists, authors, and psychologists and their patients.
On the Belatedness of Psychoanalytic Clinical Writing

Sara Collins

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00332828.2024.2318587

2024-04-06

The Psychoanalytic Quarterly

Abstract:The belatedness of analytic writing and its effects on analytic processes are explored through the concepts of nachträglichkeit and thirdness . The temporal gap between being with and writing about functions as a meaningful pause filled with opportunities for investigating unconscious pathways to the analyst's countertransference. The significance of analytic narration in affecting specific psychoanalytic developments is explored. The theoretical framework utilizes the concept of après coup , which brings to light new meanings in an afterwardness of time. Aspects of analytical writing dynamics are discussed as equivalent to those of nachträglichkeit. Analysts also deploy thirdness in constructing presentations of clinical material. This could be an intrapsychic third or an external figure representing an internal introjected third. A clinical vignette demonstrates the enhanced understanding achieved by writing. It specifically assisted in exploring the analyst's enactment relating to change in the setting, the background for which was a move to online analysis. This evoked infantile anxieties and painful confusions about loss. Historically, the patient had to navigate a path through miasmic ambiguities between reality and phantasy, truths and lies. A conclusion is reached, arguing that analytic processes extend beyond the duration of sessions, and that the processes of clinical writing can provide a significant contribution.

psychology, psychoanalysis
‘I found what I had lost: myself’. Writing as a form of self-care in times of crisis

Aneta Ostaszewska

DOI: https://doi.org/10.21827/ejlw.11.38626

2022-04-21

European Journal of Life Writing

Abstract:This essay is situated within the broad area of autoethnography, particularly referring to the idea of ‘writing about writing’, which is grounded in the reflection of the process of writing and the contexts in which that writing occur. The author employs a personal narrative to reflect on the situation that she had found herself in during the Covid-19 pandemic and which can best be defined by the concept of trajectory. It is a biographical situation marked with chaos and disintegration, evoking identity changes. As a result, the trajectory set new directions for the course of the biography. In the discussion on the schemes of dealing with the trajectory of suffering, author refers to Paul Ricoeur’s narrative concept, in particular the refiguration phase, as a stage of redefining one’s own life situation. Finally, author comes to the conclusion that the process of writing this essay can be viewed as a form of self-care, which Audre Lorde defined as self-preservation.
The multiple dimensions of our contemporary psychoanalytic discourse

Marco Conci

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/0803706X.2022.2133302

2022-11-14

International Forum of Psychoanalysis

Abstract:In July 2019 I published a book with the title Freud, Sullivan, Mitchell, Bion, and the multiple voices of international psychoanalysis , in which I connected the clinical approach of the abovementioned authors and their psychoanalytic perspective to their most important life experiences and to the scientific and interpersonal contexts in which their contributions developed, including the main partners accompanying their professional evolution. I thus tried to demonstrate not only the importance of the history of psychoanalysis for the practicing clinician, but also its relevance as a key to the pluralistic and international character of contemporary psychoanalysis.
Writing Technique Across Psychotherapies—From Traditional Expressive Writing to New Positive Psychology Interventions: A Narrative Review

Chiara Ruini,Cristina C. Mortara

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10879-021-09520-9

2021-09-14

Journal of Contemporary Psychotherapy

Abstract:Abstract Writing Therapy (WT) is defined as a process of investigation about personal thoughts and feelings using the act of writing as an instrument, with the aim of promoting self-healing and personal growth. WT has been integrated in specific psychotherapies with the aim of treating specific mental disorders (PTSD, depression, etc.). More recently, WT has been included in several Positive Interventions (PI) as a useful tool to promote psychological well-being. This narrative review was conducted by searching on scientific databases and analyzing essential studies, academic books and journal articles where writing therapy was applied. The aim of this review is to describe and summarize the use of WT across various psychotherapies, from the traditional applications as expressive writing, or guided autobiography, to the phenomenological-existential approach (Logotherapy) and, more recently, to the use of WT within Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT). Finally, the novel applications of writing techniques from a positive psychology perspective will be analyzed. Accordingly, the applications of WT for promoting forgiveness, gratitude, wisdom and other positive dimensions will be illustrated. The results of this review show that WT yield therapeutic effects on symptoms and distress, but it also promotes psychological well-being. The use of writing can be a standalone treatment or it can be easily integrated as supplement in other therapeutic approaches. This review might help clinician and counsellors to apply the simple instrument of writing to promote insight, healing and well-being in clients, according to their specific clinical needs and therapeutic goals.
Autotheory, Critical and Clinical

Gila Ashtor

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/10481885.2024.2346511

2024-06-19

Psychoanalytic Dialogues

Abstract:It is in the spirit of viewing autotheory as an unsettled genre that dramatizes the mind's own unsettlement, that I want to experiment with the implications for clinical writing. In this paper, I include a clinical case that I wrote in two channels – one is a straightforward clinical style, while the other is a series of more personal reflections. I italicized the personal voice in order to experiment with rhythms and tones that would have been lost if the piece had to cohere in a stylistically continuous way. After my experiment with clinical writing, I will offer some thoughts on Lyndon's own contributions to this emerging genre.

psychology, psychoanalysis
Stirred by Kafka's A Country Doctor: An Exploration of Psychoanalysts' Styles, Vulnerabilities, and Surrealistic Journeys.

A. Karbelnig

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1521/prev.2016.103.1.69

2016-02-09

Psychoanalytic Review

Abstract:Using Kafka's short story A Country Doctor and clinical examples as vehicles, the author demonstrates the centrality of psychoanalysts' styles and life experiences to the psychoanalytic process. Albeit charged with a distinct facilitative task, psychoanalysts inevitably bring their qualities as "fellow sufferers" (to use D. M. Orange's term) into their sessions. They experience pressures placed upon them as the "subject presumed to know," as Lacan describes. They encounter the ubiquity of self-deception, facing many unknown and unpredictable elements as they surrealistically travel through time with their patients. While understandably wanting to take refuge from their vulnerability, psychoanalysts cannot escape the influence of their individualistic and idiosyncratic natures on the transformational encounters they facilitate.

Medicine,Psychology
"No Mortal Can Keep a Secret": Reading Freud's Cases as Preparation for Candidates' First Efforts to Write About Their Patients

Jennifer Stuart

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/07351690.2024.2306106

2024-03-17

Psychoanalytic Inquiry

Abstract:Clinical writing is sometimes viewed cynically, as a way to ensure progression – through training and beyond – by demonstrating one's allegiance to received views. For candidates and faculty alike, this belief may defend against awareness of an even more troubling truth: that in writing about one's patients, one inevitably reveals a great deal about oneself. As Freud's remark on Dora's chattering fingertips implies, even writers who aspire to stay within the bounds of received wisdom may betray themselves. In this paper, I present a way of teaching Freud's first two major cases ("Dora" and "Hans") as prelude to a clinical case writing sequence at my institute. When teaching Freud, I encourage candidates to read his writing as we might hope for others to read ours: both critically and sympathetically. With perspective provided by knowledge of Freud's personal history and era, we discuss the implicit personal and political motivations that are now possible to discern between the lines of his texts. When teaching clinical writing courses, I remind candidates of our earlier, shared encounter with Freud; in writing about their patients, they too will reveal more than they can know in advance. I encourage candidates to embrace this feature of case writing, and to regard their peers and instructors as companions in a quest to understand their patients and themselves. Though I recommend including some study of Freud's cases in candidates' writing instruction, I also argue the importance of finding one's own, unique approach to teaching the practice of clinical writing, which is – for every clinician – deeply personal.

psychology, psychoanalysis
Creative writing in medical ethics: reflections on reflective practice

William Roberts

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3399/bjgp24x738357

2024-06-01

British Journal of General Practice

Abstract:Reflecting on and learning from experiences is an essential part of developing clinical practice. There exists, however, a tension between the reflections one may wish to make on a learning event and what it may or may not be appropriate to write in the recorded portfolio. Following the Bawa-Garba case,1 and the attendant worry about being summatively judged by our disclosures, my student colleagues and I are sometimes invited to consider having two reflective practices: one shared with educational supervisors; and one private, in which one can explore experiences they may not wish to be more formally noted. In my opinion, this detracts from the process of reflection and transforms it into a tick-box exercise in which the practitioner completes a superficial review of an experience for discussion with a supervisor. The real learning is then left to be undertaken unsupported. Having fallen foul of this trap myself and having been 'critiqued' for writing in too-detached a ...

medicine, general & internal,primary health care
Letter from Florence*

Benedetta Guerrini Degl’Innocenti,Chiara Matteini

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00207578.2023.2266928

2024-03-14

The International Journal of Psychoanalysis

Abstract:It is a fascinating decision to hold a conference on identifications in Florence. Now identified for more than five centuries with a brief portion of its millennial story, it sometimes seems imprisoned in its apparently timeless beauty, which is in fact extremely fragile and precarious. In this alternation of isolation and openness Florence is undoubtedly an ideal representation of Italian history. In the end, the characteristics of the development of psychoanalysis in Italy could also be summed up in the oxymoronic pairing of Isolation and Openness. It is thanks to this evolutionary niche that linguistic isolation has been transformed from a difficulty into an advantage. Italian psychoanalysis is a blend of different psychoanalytic traditions interpreted and retranslated into an autonomous psychoanalytic language. If we wish to trace a common feature in Italian psychoanalysis we could point to the concept of relationship as one of its most important transformations, with a shift of focus onto the work of the analytic couple. "Psyche is extended, knows nothing about it", the later Freud's most enigmatic legacy, seems to be one of the compasses for contemporary psychoanalytic research in Italy, one that spins around extensions of practice and the widening of technique.

psychology, psychoanalysis
Revisiting Fromm's passions as presaging contemporary views of affect and dissociation

Valentina Harrell

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1521/jaap.30.2.277.21950

Abstract:Fromm viewed intrapsychic dynamic processes as having their origin in a generalized organic life force that gets transformed into psychic energy called passions. He is acknowledged as one of the most original, creative writers of the mid-20th century whose fertile mind and humanistic sensibilities synthesized the domains of psychoanalysis, social philosophy, and politics. His unyielding belief that the development of the individual psyche is inseparable from its two-way interaction with a lived relational and cultural context presaged the evolution of the relational perspective in psychoanalysis, and his concept of passions foreshadowed contemporary neuroscientific theories of affect and its role in intrapsychic life and self-identity formation. Damasio's theory of emotions is reviewed as a specific example of the current revamping of psychoanalytic theory as bottom-up information processing, that is, the integrating and synthesizing of affective experience and memory (preverbal mentalization) as fueling the creation of a narrative self. Fromm's discussions of dissociation are linked both to Damasio's core self experiences and to Bromberg's conceptualization of psychoanalysis of dissociative experience as a process of "standing in the spaces." And finally, Fromm's descriptions of psychoanalysis as an art are linked to Schon's action-oriented theory of practical knowledge.
Psychoanalysis in the time of coronavirus: From an onboard logbook during the pandemic

Anna Maria Loiacono

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/0803706x.2023.2259646

2023-11-10

International Forum of Psychoanalysis

Abstract:During the lockdown, we, as analysts, had to face new situations, which disrupted our habitual mode of working and challenged our ability to adapt. I discovered that having a supportive relationship among colleagues became more important than ever. I will discuss the influence that the transition from in-presence sessions to the online modality during the pandemic has had on the therapeutic process and setting. The adoption of new relational working procedures instead of the usual in-person session has revived the centrality of those themes having to do with the body and sensoriality in psychoanalysis, including the possibility of recognizing and integrating dissociated embodied traumatic experiences, ones that are non-verbalized, and not able to be verbalized. I will outline a clinical case to detail the difficulties encountered in my clinical practice, in which the contingency strategy, based on working remotely, continued to guarantee that sense of security necessary to enable the possibility of dreaming together and freely exploring – introducing, however, within the relationship, aspects of Ferenczi and Rank's "active technique," which would not have occurred in person, and which certainly impacted the process in a different way, while always permitting the identification and assimilation of dissociated experiences.
Psychoanalysis as "Studio Practice"

Patricia Ticineto Clough

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/10481885.2024.2329333

2024-04-24

Psychoanalytic Dialogues

Abstract:In their essays, Kathleen Miller and Katie Gentile show us ways of writing, thinking, and practicing psychoanalysis that address the onto-epistemological and social implications of taking account of the more-than-human. In their reach beyond human centrism, Miller and Gentile model experimentation and invention as well as invite us to consider what I discuss as psychoanalysis as a studio practice.

psychology, psychoanalysis
Review of Reading with Muriel Dimen/Writing with Muriel Dimen: Experiments in Theorizing a Field

Arthur Fox

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00107530.2024.2315010

IF: 0.256

2024-03-31

Contemporary Psychoanalysis

Abstract:Arthur Fox, Ph.D., teaches in the Contemporary Freudian Track at NYU Postdoctoral Institute for Psychotherapy and Psychoanalysis. Arthur.Fox@nyu.edu

psychiatry,psychology, psychoanalysis
Après Coup of "You Must Remember This"

Adrienne Harris,Lauren Levine,Amy Schwartz Cooney,Jack Foehl,Stephen Hartman

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/10481885.2024.2346435

2024-06-19

Psychoanalytic Dialogues

Abstract:With the republication of Adrienne Harris' classic essay, "You must remember this" (Harris, 2009), Psychoanalytic Dialogues continues our new feature, Après Coup. By putting a paper from the early years of the journal in conversation with contemporary readers and writers, we hope to dive into the ways in which psychoanalysts forge relationality in spaces of complexity and contradiction over time, as our experiences- collective, dyadic, or solitary – are always nonlinear and multiply configured. This Apres Coup includes commentaries by Cleonie White, Ph.D. Ken Corbett, Ph.D. Shubha Herlekar, Psy.D. MFT, Victor Donas, M.D. Donnel Stern, Ph.D. and Giuseppe Civitarese, M.D. Ph.D.

psychology, psychoanalysis
The digital age and psychoanalysis: New frontiers of the setting and therapeutic challenges

Serena Previdi,Anna Buzzi,Mariagiovanna Cozza,Serena PrevidiAnna BuzziMariagiovanna CozzaSerena Previdi graduated with a double degree in clinical psychology from the Alma Mater Studiorum,University of Bologna,Italy,and Universidad del Rosario,Bogotà,Colombia. In 2016 she undertook a postgraduate internship at the Clinica Santo Thomas in Bogotà,taking charge of patients suffering from psychosis and began her first personal analysis,with clinical psychologist Dr Mario Guerrero. Serena Previdi has been a member of the order of psychologists of the Emilia-Romagna,and at the Erich Fromm Institute of Psychoanalytic Psychotherapy in Bologna. Starting that same year,she began her second personal analysis with psychoanalyst and SPI associate member Dr. Fava Ramona.Since 2021 she has been a resident at the Clinical Psychology Service,and Pathological Addiction Service,AUSL Modena.Anna Buzzi graduated in clinical psychology from Carlo Bo University,Urbino,Italy,with a thesis entitled "Prison Police: Organization,Professional Mission and Psychosocial Risks" as a continuation of the interest that had already developed in this area from a three-year thesis where attention was placed on the social reintegration of prisoners. She subsequently undertook a postgraduate internship in a therapeutic community,for people with pathological addictions and a double diagnosis and in alternative measures to prison.Anna Buzzi is enrolled in the order of psychologists of Emilia Romagna and is currently attending the Erich Fromm Institute of Neo-Freudian Psycho- analysis specialization school,carrying out a specialization internship at the Child Neuropsychiatry and Centre for Adult Eating Disorders,AUSL Bologna.Mariagiovanna Cozza graduated in 2012 in medicine and surgery from the University of Perugia. and obtained her specialization in geriatrics in 2017 from the same University. From 2020 she has worked at AUSL Bologna,mainly with psychogeriatric outpatient activities aimed at the classification of mood disorders and cognitive deficits in elderly individuals.From 2021 she started attending the Erich Fromm Institute of Neo-Freudian Psychoanalysis specialization school in Bologna. From 2022 she started her personal analysand therapy,carrying out the sessions in mixed mode (sometimes online,sometimes in person) with Dr. Davide Corradetti,a Full Member psychoanalyst of the IFPS.

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/0803706x.2023.2248429

2023-10-31

International Forum of Psychoanalysis

Abstract:We reflect on the concept of the setting in psychoanalysis, and how it has been radically reconsidered given the impact of the SARS-CoV-19 pandemic on human interactions and moving from face-to-face to online sessions. The rapidity of going from seeking interaction to a fear of possible contagion led some professionals to adopt a sudden change of setting. Although the concept of setting seems to come from the classical Freudian method, Freud never spoke about it explicitly, although it was subsequently developed from his writings. Only in the 1960s and 70s was the setting perceived as the very object of psychoanalytic exploration. Since the psyche in psychoanalysis is conceived as a spatially extended entity, this paper discusses the concepts of space and time (external setting) and the mental state of both the patient and analyst (internal setting). We investigate how these aspects have changed as a result of the use of technology. What changes have taken place at the perceptual level in the patient and analyst? What differences are there with respect to the presence/absence of the other's body? We use our own reflections of our personal experiences of undergoing face-to-face and online sessions to reveal the differences between them.
Clinical narrative and the painful side of conscious experience

Jesús Ramírez-Bermúdez,Ximena González-Grandón,Rosa Aurora Chávez

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/09515089.2024.2366417

2024-06-16

Philosophical Psychology

Abstract:This article explores a literary tradition situated at the intersection of scientific reports, memoirs, and creative writing, termed "clinical narrative." This genre offers a profound approach to the painful aspects of conscious experience, particularly the phenomenological states associated with mental illness and brain disease, seen as unsettling landscapes of phenomenal experience. Through case studies providing multifaceted viewpoints – first-person, second-person, and third-person perspectives – we argue that clinical narratives are valuable resources for a transepistemic study of consciousness. By examining clinical conundrums such as somatic and nihilistic delusions, and anosognosia, we highlight the importance of detailed phenomenological, hermeneutic, and narrative accounts while acknowledging the significance of subpersonal, mechanistic models from cognitive and affective neuroscience. The tradition embodies the tension between the diverse perspectives in the field of mental health, including stories that directly challenge the medical discourse. However, the narrative arts can act as mediators or even peacemakers, by fostering an understanding between the opposing views. Stories are open to multiple interpretations, preserving the diversity of discourses on human meaning and avoiding the imposition of monolithic versions of our humanness.

psychology, multidisciplinary,ethics
Topography of depressive experiences. A dialectic approach

Guilherme Messas,Francesca Brencio

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jad.2024.10.064

2025-01-15

Abstract:This article aims to offer clinical descriptions and philosophical interpretations of the ontological nature of depressive experiences trying to address issues related to the contemporary diagnostic paradigm and values-based practices which shape clinical decisions. At the core of this contribution there is the idea that the variety of depressive experiences might be understood acknowledging the qualitative difference in the ontology underlying each form of depression. We argue that there is a fundamental difference between melancholia as a disease and those melancholic traits which characterizes human existence as such: while the former indicates a qualitative alteration of the global human experience, constituting psychopathological experience, the latter describes a style of disproportion of existence not pathological per se at all. Moreover, we defend the hypothesis that melancholia (in a medical sense) is a distinct unity of mental alteration, and should not be conflated with the multivarious kind of experiences merged under the name of depression, the variety of which may be understood as disorders of the personal development. It is in this context that the leading element of anthropological disproportions impact the role of pre-reflective and transcendental structures, polarizing the self and the world in a three-way topography: 1. depression as an excessive symmetric proportion between self and world; 2. depression as a disproportion between the self and the world (detriment of the self); 3. depressions as impoverishment of the transcendental value of the world.

Revisiting, Rewriting, Reexperiencing: Clinical Writing Today

Does it Appear to 'Resemble' Reality? on the Ethics of Psychoanalytic Writing

Flashes in a Moment of Danger: On the Autobiographical Essence of Psychoanalytic Writing in Adrienne Harris's Essay "You Must Remember This"

Psychology and creative writing: the role of experiential learning in the journey from fact to fiction, and the implications for therapy

On the Belatedness of Psychoanalytic Clinical Writing

‘I found what I had lost: myself’. Writing as a form of self-care in times of crisis

The multiple dimensions of our contemporary psychoanalytic discourse

Writing Technique Across Psychotherapies—From Traditional Expressive Writing to New Positive Psychology Interventions: A Narrative Review

Autotheory, Critical and Clinical

Stirred by Kafka's A Country Doctor: An Exploration of Psychoanalysts' Styles, Vulnerabilities, and Surrealistic Journeys.

"No Mortal Can Keep a Secret": Reading Freud's Cases as Preparation for Candidates' First Efforts to Write About Their Patients

Creative writing in medical ethics: reflections on reflective practice

Letter from Florence*

Revisiting Fromm's passions as presaging contemporary views of affect and dissociation

Psychoanalysis in the time of coronavirus: From an onboard logbook during the pandemic

Psychoanalysis as "Studio Practice"

Review of Reading with Muriel Dimen/Writing with Muriel Dimen: Experiments in Theorizing a Field

Après Coup of "You Must Remember This"

The digital age and psychoanalysis: New frontiers of the setting and therapeutic challenges

Clinical narrative and the painful side of conscious experience

Topography of depressive experiences. A dialectic approach