Abstract:Community detection, which involves partitioning nodes within a network, has widespread applications across computational sciences. Modularity-based algorithms identify communities by attempting to maximize the modularity function across network node partitions. Our study assesses the performance of various modularity-based algorithms in obtaining optimal partitions. Our analysis utilizes 104 networks, including both real-world instances from diverse contexts and modular graphs from two families of synthetic benchmarks. We analyze ten inexact modularity-based algorithms against the exact integer programming baseline that globally optimizes modularity. Our comparative analysis includes eight heuristics, two variants of a graph neural network algorithm, and nine variations of the Bayan approximation algorithm. Our findings reveal that the average modularity-based heuristic yields optimal partitions in only 43.9% of the 104 networks analyzed. Graph neural networks and approximate Bayan, on average, achieve optimality on 68.7% and 82.3% of the networks respectively. Additionally, our analysis of three partition similarity metrics exposes substantial dissimilarities between high-modularity sub-optimal partitions and any optimal partition of the networks. We observe that near-optimal partitions are often disproportionately dissimilar to any optimal partition. Taken together, our analysis points to a crucial limitation of the commonly used modularity-based methods: they rarely produce an optimal partition or a partition resembling an optimal partition even on networks with modular structures. If modularity is to be used for detecting communities, we recommend approximate optimization algorithms for a more methodologically sound usage of modularity within its applicability limits.

Network Clustering via Maximizing Modularity: Approximation Algorithms and Theoretical Limits

Analyzing Modularity Maximization in Approximation, Heuristic, and Graph Neural Network Algorithms for Community Detection

Maximizing Modularity is hard

Module Detection in Complex Networks Using Integer Optimisation

Modularity-Maximizing Network Communities via Mathematical Programming

Heuristic Modularity Maximization Algorithms for Community Detection Rarely Return an Optimal Partition or Anything Similar

Clustering via Hypergraph Modularity

Multiple Resolution Community Structure Analysis

Community Detection via Maximization of Modularity and Its Variants

A Study on Modularity Density Maximization: Column Generation Acceleration and Computational Complexity Analysis

The Bayan Algorithm: Detecting Communities in Networks Through Exact and Approximate Optimization of Modularity

Network community detection using modularity density measures

Bayan Algorithm: Detecting Communities in Networks Through Exact and Approximate Optimization of Modularity

Constant Approximation for Normalized Modularity and Associations Clustering

Searching Graph Communities by Modularity Maximization Via Convex Optimization.

Optimizing Modularity with Nonnegative Matrix Factorization

A Novel Clustering Algorithm for Graphs

On approximate equivalence of modularity, D and non-negative matrix factorization

From clusters to queries: exploiting uncertainty in the modularity landscape of complex networks

Modularity Maximization and Tree Clustering: Novel Ways to Determine Effective Geographic Borders

Scalable Community Discovery of Large Networks