[Promoting recovery of schizophrenic patients: discrepancy between routine practice and evidence. The SIEP-DIRECT'S Project]
Domenico Semisa,Massimo Casacchia,Walter Di Munzio,Giovanni Neri,Giacinto Buscaglia,Lorenzo Burti,Cristina Pucci,Giuseppe Corlito,Maurizio Bacigalupi,Roberto Parravani,Rita Roncone,Doriana Cristofalo,Antonio Lora,Mirella Ruggeri,Gruppo SIEP-DIRECT'S,Fabrizio Asioli,Andrea Balbi,Casacchia Buscaglia,Giuseppe Carrà,Arcadio Erlicher,Antonio Lasalvia,Alessandra Marinoni,Maurizio Miceli,Carla Morganti,Pierluigi Morosini,Davide Iacchetti,Marco Pegoraro,Vincenzo Scavo,Marussia Alderighi,Paolo Lorenzo,Fabio Lecci,Andrea Tanini,Teresa Cefalì,Andrea Caneschi,Rossana Ottanelli,Nadia Magnani,Francesco Bardicchia,Rita Pescosolido,Liliana Allevi,Jessica Ferrigno,Giovanna Giusto,Paola Rolando,RosaBruna Dall'Agnola,Sarah Bissoli,Anna Maria Cassano,Gabriella Ciampolillo,Patrizia Fracchiolla,Sergio Lupoi,Enrico Visani,Carmin Pasquale Pismataro,Luisa Mari,Maria Fiorella Gazale,Ivonne Bianchi,Maria Carmela Milano,Felice Amideo,Filomena Basile,Sonia Santelia,Michele Vanetti,Lidia Carnevale,Cristina Debernardi,Letizia Fiorica,Rocco Pollice,Alessandra Cavicchio,Rosaria Pioli,Giusi Cicolella,Eleonora Riva,Carmine Pasquale Pismataro,Gillian Leng,Itzhack Levav,Tommaso Losavio,Mario Maj,Steve Pilling,Shekhar Saxena,Michele Tansella
Abstract:Aims: The aim of this work is to present the main discrepancies, as evidenced by the SIEP-DIRECT'S Project, between the evidence-based NICE guidelines for schizophrenia and the usual practices of the Italian mental health services in order to promote the recovery of patients with schizophrenia. Methods: Starting from the main NICE recommendations on recovery promotion, 41 indicators were developed. These were experimented in 19 participating Italian Mental Health Departments (MHD) or Psychiatric Services through self-evaluation of the activities carried out to promote patient recovery with the aim of assessing the level of adherence to the recommendations. The data required by most of the indicators were obtained from the psychiatric informative system or from the Direction of the MHD. Moreover, specific research was carried out on the clinical records and on representative patient samples. Furthermore, for 14 indicators, there was requested an assessment by the part of "multidisciplinary" or "specialistic" focus groups who then attributed a score according to a defined "ad hoc" scale. Results: According to the data obtained, although the mental health services seem to care about the physical condition of their patients, they do not routinely examine principle parameters such as blood pressure, glycaemia etc., and collaboration with general practitioners is often complex or not uniformly practiced. Most psychiatrists and psychologists possess the basic communication skills but not enough competences in cognitive-behavioural treatments; such treatments, and every other form of structured individual psychotherapy, are seldom carried out and seem to have become marginal activities within the Services. Also family psycho-educational interventions are under-used. The Services are very active in the care of multi-problem schizophrenia patients, who make up a large percentage (almost a quarter, on average) of the patients in their care. These patients are offered specific and integrated treatment plans with the involvement of other health services and social agencies operating in the territory. The strategies adopted by the services for the pharmacological treatment in the prevention of relapses and for patients with frequent crises or with treatment-resistant schizophrenia are all in line with the NICE recommendations. Finally, the Services promote activities of vocational training and supported employment, but the outcomes of these are often unsatisfactory. Conclusions: The results of the study show a picture of the Italian mental health services with bright yet also dark areas as regards recovery promotion activities. The Services seem to guarantee adequate pharmacological evidence-based treatments, an integrated assistance and good management of multi-problem patients. They have difficulty, however, with respect to the monitoring of the physical health of the patients, psychotherapeutic activities, including those for families, and the promotion of supported employment. Moreover, they still show problems regarding the structuring and formalizing of care processes. To improve this situation, they should make greater use of professional guidelines, protocols and written procedures.