FINDING A WOMAN'S PLACE: GASKELL AND AUTHORITY

J. Lowder,S. Holstein,E. Gaskell
Abstract:position and the position of "mother as servant to patriliny."1 What space, then, does Gaskell occupy (and more importantly, where are her characters) in relation to authority? The accommodating and balancing stance that most readers find in Gaskell is a function both of her life as a Victorian woman, adapting to the demands ofthat status, and of her preoccupation with concerns that range beyond the perimeters of that status. That is, while Gaskell was required continually to accommodate to others in her daily life as a mother, wife, charity worker, and "lady," as a writer she focused on the larger accommodations life demands, adaptations that have less to do with being a sub-dominant member of the patriarchy than they do with the price life exacts from every individual. She did not write within the "mother as patrilineal servant model" because the patriarchy was not her defining reality, and it was subject to the same demands of change and loss as its daughters. Indeed, Gaskell's position in relation to patriarchal power, both from within and from without her texts, has been difficult for critics to assess. Commentators on Gaskell's biography have frequently focused on one striking event: her husband William ' s pocketing of the twenty-pound note Elizabeth received for an early story, "Lizzie Leigh."2 Some have seen this incident as evidence of William Gaskell's economic and emotional domination of his wife: Judith Lowder Newton assumes from this transaction that Gaskell turned all her money over to her husband and that therefore the writer upheld a conservative ideology. Newton ' s reading of North and South, for example, and her subsequent judgment of Gaskell's deficiencies in comparison to Charlotte Bronte and George Eliot are somewhat predicated on her assumption of Gaskell's utter dependence on her husband.3 A careful examination of Gaskell's letters, however, reveals that the
History,Sociology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?