Assessing treatment integrity in personalized CBT: the inventory of therapeutic interventions and skills

Kaitlyn Boyle,Anne-Katharina Deisenhofer,Julian A. Rubel,Björn Bennemann,Birgit Weinmann-Lutz,Wolfgang Lutz
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/16506073.2019.1625945
2019-07-02
Cognitive Behaviour Therapy
Abstract:The third wave of cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) has increased the heterogeneity of today's CBT practice, while developments in patient-focused research are paving the road to the empirical personalization of CBT. This paper presents the development and psychometric properties of a therapy video rating instrument, which was designed to adequately assess the treatment integrity (adherence and competence) of modern, personalized CBT. The <i>Inventory of Therapeutic Interventions and Skills</i> (ITIS) was developed based on two existing CBT adherence and competence scales and augmented with third wave content and overarching therapeutic strategies. The instrument was then applied by graduate students and post-graduate clinicians to rate <i>N</i> = 185 therapy videos from <i>N</i> = 70 patients treated at a university outpatient clinic. Descriptive results, inter-rater reliability, item structure, and associations with session outcome and alliance were examined. Average inter-rater reliability was excellent for <i>Interventions</i> items and good for <i>Skills</i> items. Intercorrelations were low between <i>Interventions</i> items, but higher and significant between <i>Skills</i> items, which loaded on a single factor. Several ITIS items were shown to be predictive of session outcome and alliance, even after controlling for the nested data structure. Implications of these results for future research and clinical training are discussed.
psychology, clinical
What problem does this paper attempt to address?