Abstract:Purpose: The purpose of this paper is to argue the importance of contemporary analysis of the modern social construction of chronicity--encapsulating the world views of the chronically ill, and the medical and health system constructions of chronic disease, through the nature of care for chronic conditions. It is argued that chronic diseases are themselves, socially constructed, despite widely accepted disease classification systems. Thus, there is a need to examine how different ideas have permeated our clinical and health system developments and their social context and vice versa. Methods: We examine historical ideas, theory and evidence about the tensions in social construction of chronic illness by those afflicted and the responses of society, the medical and health professions and increasingly the public and private institutions that shape health care. This is with the background of major differences in the two cultures that create knowledge: those based upon argument and intellectual logic--hermeneutic, and those based upon 'objectivist' empirical science, often called heuristic. Evidence-based medicine (EBM) is the flagship of disease management, increasingly narrative-based medicine and other similar genres are becoming the pragmatic face of social constructions, yet sit in juxtaposition without synthesis. A third culture has emerged of scientific intellectuals who straddle these cultures and in health care their public face is 'mixed methods'. Findings: Recent cases of modern ideas about improving chronic care were reviewed. We found that despite developments of social theory, the world view of the chronically ill exerts small influence in health system redesign, apparently dominated by chronic disease models. Confusion remains within health system reforms as to the social construction of chronicity--chronic disease, chronic condition or chronic illness and chronic care transformations. The role of Primary Care remains ambiguous straddling disease and illness. Radical redesign of health systems is taking place without an understanding and discourse about the nature of their construction. Ad hoc eclectism with unquestioning adoption of the dominant EBM paradigm is driving a new health culture based on disease-based performance incentives, which is intrusive beyond the medical model and pays little attention to narratives of illness and even less to the whole social reconstruction of illness and wellness. Conclusions: Health care systems cannot afford to avoid, and should actively embrace the critiques of social theory and analyses in the transformations of health systems to improve chronic care. Creative tensions between empirical and intellectual critique, and a synthetic middle ground are likely to lead to more realistic and innovative approaches spanning the nature of chronicity and the transformation of Primary Care.

Why Did This Happen to Me? Causal Attributions of Illness and Cultural Health Capital

Who Deserves Health Care? The Effects of Causal Attributions and Group Cues on Public Attitudes About Responsibility for Health Care Costs

Fostering Participant Health Knowledge and Attitudes: An Econometric Study of a Chronic Disease-Focused Online Health Community

See Me and Believe Me: Causality and Intersectionality in Testimonial Injustice in Healthcare

Examining illness perceptions over time: an exploratory prospective analysis of causal attributions in individuals with depressive symptoms

Causes, Coping, and Culture: A Comparative Survey Study on Representation of Back Pain in Three Swiss Language Regions

A test of a cultural model of patients' motivation for verbal communication in patient‐doctor interactions

Patients' beliefs about the causes of heart disease: relationships with risk factors, sex and socio-economic status

"Cultural and conceptual knowledge": Reformulation and conceptual analysis of a key component of the health literacy model

Confirmatory Factor Analysis Of The Causal Illness Attribution Scale In Chinese Patients With Multiple Somatic Symptoms

Cultural Differences in Access to Care

Negotiating substance use stigma: the role of cultural health capital in provider-patient interactions

The social construction of chronicity--a key to understanding chronic care transformations

A Causal Model of Health Status and Satisfaction With Medical Care

Symptom Characteristics, Perceived Causal Attributions, and Contextual Factors influencing Self-Care Behaviors: An Ecological Daily Assessment Study of Adults with Chronic Illness

Chronic Illness Management in Culturally and Linguistically Diverse Patients: Exploring the Needs, Access, and Understanding of Information

Towards the idea of 'clinical capital': A longitudinal study exploring nurses' dispositions and workplace manifestations in an Australian intensive care unit

Causal attributions of doctor and patients in a diabetes clinic

Is Mental Illness like Any Other Medical Illness? Causal Attributions, Supportive Communication and the Social Withdrawal Inclination of People with Chronic Mental Illnesses in China

Cultural competence in healthcare in the community: A concept analysis

To talk or not to talk: exploring culturally diverse patients' health information communication choices