Abstract:Sound environments in large public buildings are likely to be different from those of performance spaces, as well as those not specifically designed for acoustic “performance”, but where sounds still play an important role because of the function they can promote (or disrupt). The aim of this study was identifying common strategies and empirical approaches researchers have been implementing for these acoustically complex enclosures and to provide some methodological indications for future studies on the topic. Studies conducted in three building types for crowd transit, such as museums/exhibition spaces, shopping malls, and transportation hubs/stations, which were collecting data about either physical outcomes or individual responses for such sound environments, were selected. The Scopus databases were searched for peer-reviewed journal papers published in English without time limitations. An additional manual search was performed on the reference lists of the retrieved items. The general consideration on inclusion was to meet the requirement that the case belonged to the three building types, and then the specific inclusion criteria were: (1) including at least an objective acoustic measure of the space; or (2) including at least a subjective measure of the space. The search returned 1060 results; after removing duplicates, two authors screened titles and abstracts and selected 117 papers for further analysis. Twenty-six studies were eventually included. Due to the limited number of items and differences in measures across studies, a quantitative meta-analysis could not be performed, and a qualitative approach was adopted instead. The most commonly used objective measures were SPL, and more specifically often considered as LAeq, and T. The intervals across studies were currently of inconsistency, and the selection is recommended to take space scale factor into account. The used subjective measures can be classified into four categories as annoyance, affective quality, room-acoustic quality, and acoustic spatiality. Four basic perceptual assessments concerning dynamic contents are accordingly suggested as “annoying-not annoying”, “crowded-uncrowded”, “long-short (reverberation)”, and “far awaynearby”. The other descriptors can be project-specific. The methodologies involve measurement, questionnaire/interview, listening test, and software simulation. It is necessary for the former two to consider temporal and spatial features of such spaces, and the adoption of the latter two will lead to better understanding of users’ exposure in such spaces, e.g., acoustic sequences and user amount. The outputs of investigations inform that background noise level, e.g., 90 dB in museum/exhibition spaces, and sound reverberation, e.g., 4.0 to 5.0 s in shopping malls and transportation hubs/station, are of fundamental importance to the design of such spaces. Sufficient acoustic comfort can be achieved with integrated design of indoor soundscape.

Investigation of the Acoustic Comfort of an Academic Library: Case Study at the Technical University of Crete

Relationships Between Objective Acoustic Indices and Acoustic Comfort Evaluation in Nonacoustic Spaces

Analysing Sound Environment and Architectural Characteristics of Libraries Through Indoor Soundscape Framework

A comparative case study of indoor soundscape approach on objective analyses and subjective evaluations of libraries

Acoustic Quality in Non-Acoustic Public Buildings

Assessment of acoustical comfort in educational atriums of closed central and linear typologies: Reverberation perception and preference

Integrating Indoor Soundscape Approach into IEQ Research: Acoustic Comfort in Naturally Ventilated Residential Buildings

Sound Environments in Large Public Buildings for Crowd Transit: A Systematic Review

Acoustic Comfort Evaluation in Urban Open Public Spaces

Quiet in the Library: An Evidence-Based Approach to Improving the Student Experience

Improved acoustics for semi-enclosed spaces in the proximity of residential buildings

Acoustics for architects: A potpourri of undergraduate and graduate level teaching styles, tools and in-course projects

The combined influence of thermal and acoustic environment on overall comfort and Productivity in naturally ventilated university classrooms in India

Towards an Acoustically Accessible Campus: A Case Study of the Acoustic Conditions of an Australian University

Investigating the Potential of Transparent Parallel-Arranged Micro-Perforated Panels (MPPs) as Sound Absorbers in Classrooms

Architectural acoustic environment, music and dining experience

Case study of acoustics in two very large atriums

Acoustic Comfort in Large Dining Spaces

The effect of the acoustic environment of learning spaces on students' learning efficiency: A review

Acoustical design challenges of public interiors: cultural centers and terminal buildings

Acoustic Design Criteria in Naturally Ventilated Residential Buildings: New Research Perspectives by Applying the Indoor Soundscape Approach