Abstract:The field of argument analysis has become a crucial component in the advancement of natural language processing, which holds the potential to reveal unprecedented insights from complex data and enable more efficient, cost-effective solutions for enhancing human initiatives. Despite its importance, current technologies face significant challenges, including (1) low interpretability, (2) lack of precision and robustness, particularly in specialized fields like finance, and (3) the inability to deploy effectively on lightweight devices. To address these challenges, we introduce a framework uniquely designed to process and analyze massive volumes of argument data efficiently and accurately. This framework employs a text-to-text Transformer generation model as its backbone, utilizing multiple prompt engineering methods to fine-tune the model. These methods include Causal Inference from ChatGPT, which addresses the interpretability problem, and Prefix Instruction Fine-tuning as well as in-domain further pre-training, which tackle the issues of low robustness and accuracy. Ultimately, the proposed framework generates conditional outputs for specific tasks using different decoders, enabling deployment on consumer-grade devices. After conducting extensive experiments, our method achieves high accuracy, robustness, and interpretability across various tasks, including the highest F1 scores in the NTCIR-17 FinArg-1 tasks.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily addresses the issues present in financial argument analysis by proposing a new framework. Specifically, the study aims to tackle the following key problems: 1. **Low Interpretability**: Current technologies often struggle to provide clear and intuitive result interpretations when handling financial data. 2. **Lack of Precision and Robustness**: Especially in specialized fields like finance, existing methods often fail to achieve sufficient accuracy and exhibit instability when faced with new data or complex situations. 3. **Deployment Challenges on Lightweight Devices**: Many advanced models are difficult to run on resource-constrained devices. To address these challenges, the authors propose a method called the "Prefix Prompt Engineering Framework" (PPEF), which is based on text generation models and fine-tuned through various prompt engineering strategies. These strategies include causal inference, prefix instruction fine-tuning, and further pre-training in specific domains. Through these methods, the model not only achieves high accuracy in specific tasks but also maintains good robustness and interpretability, especially excelling in handling imbalanced datasets. Additionally, the paper details the specific components of the proposed framework, including: - **Prefix Instruction Fine-Tuning**: Guiding the model to generate responses in a specified format by designing specific task instructions. - **Further Pre-Training in Specific Domains**: Enhancing the model's domain knowledge by pre-training it with additional finance-related data. - **Causal Inference**: Utilizing ChatGPT to generate causal reasoning explanations, making the model output more persuasive and interpretable. Experimental results show that this framework achieves significant performance in multiple financial argument analysis sub-tasks, particularly attaining the highest F1 score in the NTCIR-17 FinArg-1 task. Through this approach, the research team not only improved model performance but also enhanced the model's reliability and interpretability in practical applications.

Causal Inference and Prefix Prompt Engineering Based on Text Generation Models for Financial Argument Analysis

FinGen: A Dataset for Argument Generation in Finance

Performance analysis of large language models in the domain of legal argument mining

Can ChatGPT Overcome Behavioral Biases in the Financial Sector? Classify-and-Rethink: Multi-Step Zero-Shot Reasoning in the Gold Investment

Empowering Language Understanding with Counterfactual Reasoning

Everything Has a Cause: Leveraging Causal Inference in Legal Text Analysis

Generating Plausible Counterfactual Explanations for Deep Transformers in Financial Text Classification

KACE: Generating Knowledge-Aware Contrastive Explanations for Natural Language Inference

Unveiling AI-Generated Financial Text: A Computational Approach Using Natural Language Processing and Generative Artificial Intelligence

GPT-3 Models are Few-Shot Financial Reasoners

AntCritic: Argument Mining for Free-Form and Visually-Rich Financial Comments

Large Language Models and Generative AI in Finance: An Analysis of ChatGPT, Bard, and Bing AI

Mechanistic interpretability of large language models with applications to the financial services industry

A Generative Approach for Financial Causality Extraction

Prove Your Point!: Bringing Proof-Enhancement Principles to Argumentative Essay Generation

Reasoning Beyond Bias: A Study on Counterfactual Prompting and Chain of Thought Reasoning

A Framework to Construct Financial Causality Knowledge Graph from Text

A Joint Framework for Argumentative Text Analysis Incorporating Domain Knowledge

Decoding Report Generators: A Cyclic Vision-Language Adapter for Counterfactual Explanations

DeepA2: A Modular Framework for Deep Argument Analysis with Pretrained Neural Text2Text Language Models