Weak Kleene Algebra is Sound and (Possibly) Complete for Simulation

Ernie Cohen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.0910.1028

2009-10-06

Abstract:We show that the axioms of Weak Kleene Algebra (WKA) are sound and complete for the theory of regular expressions modulo simulation equivalence, assuming their completeness for monodic trees (as conjectured by Takai and Furusawa).

Logic in Computer Science,Programming Languages

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Completeness Theorems for Kleene algebra with tests and top

Damien Pous,Jana Wagemaker

DOI: https://doi.org/10.46298/lmcs-20(3:27)2024

2024-10-02

Logical Methods in Computer Science

Abstract:We prove two completeness results for Kleene algebra with tests and a top element, with respect to guarded string languages and binary relations. While the equational theories of those two classes of models coincide over the signature of Kleene algebra, this is no longer the case when we consider an additional constant ``top'' for the full element. Indeed, the full relation satisfies more laws than the full language, and we show that those additional laws can all be derived from a single additional axiom. We recover that the two equational theories coincide if we slightly generalise the notion of relational model, allowing sub-algebras of relations where top is a greatest element but not necessarily the full relation. We use models of closed languages and reductions in order to prove our completeness results, which are relative to any axiomatisation of the algebra of regular events. For one of our constructions, we extend the concept of finite monoid recognisability to guarded-string languages; this device makes it possible to obtain a PSpace algorithm for the equational theory of binary relations.

computer science, theory & methods,logic
An Elementary Proof of the FMP for Kleene Algebra

Tobias Kappé

2024-08-11

Abstract:Kleene Algebra (KA) is a useful tool for proving that two programs are equivalent. Because KA's equational theory is decidable, it integrates well with interactive theorem provers. This raises the question: which equations can we (not) prove using the laws of KA? Moreover, which models of KA are complete, in the sense that they satisfy exactly the provable equations? Kozen (1994) answered these questions by characterizing KA in terms of its language model. Concretely, equivalences provable in KA are exactly those that hold for regular expressions. Pratt (1980) observed that KA is complete w.r.t. relational models, i.e., that its provable equations are those that hold for any relational interpretation. A less known result due to Palka (2005) says that finite models are complete for KA, i.e., that provable equivalences coincide with equations satisfied by all finite KAs. Phrased contrapositively, the latter is a finite model property (FMP): any unprovable equation is falsified by a finite KA. Both results can be argued using Kozen's theorem, but the implication is mutual: given that KA is complete w.r.t. finite (resp. relational) models, Palka's (resp. Pratt's) arguments show that it is complete w.r.t. the language model. We embark on a study of the different complete models of KA, and the connections between them. This yields a novel result subsuming those of Palka and Pratt, namely that KA is complete w.r.t. finite relational models. Next, we put an algebraic spin on Palka's techniques, which yield a new elementary proof of the finite model property, and by extension, of Kozen's and Pratt's theorems. In contrast with earlier approaches, this proof relies not on minimality or bisimilarity of automata, but rather on representing the regular expressions involved in terms of transformation automata.

Formal Languages and Automata Theory,Logic in Computer Science
Sound and complete axiomatizations of coalgebraic language equivalence

Marcello M. Bonsangue,Stefan Milius,Alexandra Silva

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1145/2422085.2422092

2017-03-17

Abstract:Coalgebras provide a uniform framework to study dynamical systems, including several types of automata. In this paper, we make use of the coalgebraic view on systems to investigate, in a uniform way, under which conditions calculi that are sound and complete with respect to behavioral equivalence can be extended to a coarser coalgebraic language equivalence, which arises from a generalised powerset construction that determinises coalgebras. We show that soundness and completeness are established by proving that expressions modulo axioms of a calculus form the rational fixpoint of the given type functor. Our main result is that the rational fixpoint of the functor $FT$, where $T$ is a monad describing the branching of the systems (e.g. non-determinism, weights, probability etc.), has as a quotient the rational fixpoint of the "determinised" type functor $\bar F$, a lifting of $F$ to the category of $T$-algebras. We apply our framework to the concrete example of weighted automata, for which we present a new sound and complete calculus for weighted language equivalence. As a special case, we obtain non-deterministic automata, where we recover Rabinovich's sound and complete calculus for language equivalence.

Logic in Computer Science,Category Theory
Completeness of Finitely Weighted Kleene Algebra With Tests

Igor Sedlár

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-62687-6_14

2024-07-10

Abstract:Building on Ésik and Kuich's completeness result for finitely weighted Kleene algebra, we establish relational and language completeness results for finitely weighted Kleene algebra with tests. Similarly as Ésik and Kuich, we assume that the finite semiring of weights is commutative, partially ordered and zero-bounded, but we also assume that it is integral. We argue that finitely weighted Kleene algebra with tests is a natural framework for equational reasoning about weighted programs in cases where an upper bound on admissible weights is assumed.

Logic in Computer Science
On Tools for Completeness of Kleene Algebra with Hypotheses

Damien Pous,Jurriaan Rot,Jana Wagemaker

2024-05-15

Abstract:In the literature on Kleene algebra, a number of variants have been proposed which impose additional structure specified by a theory, such as Kleene algebra with tests (KAT) and the recent Kleene algebra with observations (KAO), or make specific assumptions about certain constants, as for instance in NetKAT. Many of these variants fit within the unifying perspective offered by Kleene algebra with hypotheses, which comes with a canonical language model constructed from a given set of hypotheses. For the case of KAT, this model corresponds to the familiar interpretation of expressions as languages of guarded strings. A relevant question therefore is whether Kleene algebra together with a given set of hypotheses is complete with respect to its canonical language model. In this paper, we revisit, combine and extend existing results on this question to obtain tools for proving completeness in a modular way. We showcase these tools by giving new and modular proofs of completeness for KAT, KAO and NetKAT, and we prove completeness for new variants of KAT: KAT extended with a constant for the full relation, KAT extended with a converse operation, and a version of KAT where the collection of tests only forms a distributive lattice.

Logic in Computer Science
An isomorphism theorem for models of weak König’s lemma without primitive recursion

Marta Fiori-Carones,Leszek Aleksander Kołodziejczyk,Tin Lok Wong,Keita Yokoyama

DOI: https://doi.org/10.4171/jems/1522

2024-09-20

Journal of the European Mathematical Society

Abstract:We prove that if (M,\mathcal{X}) and (M,\mathcal{Y}) are countable models of the theory \mathrm{WKL}^{*}_{0} such that \mathrm{I}\Sigma_{1}(A) fails for some A \in \mathcal{X}\cap \mathcal{Y} , then (M,\mathcal{X}) and (M,\mathcal{Y}) are isomorphic. As a consequence, the analytic hierarchy collapses to \Delta^{1}_{1} provably in \mathrm{WKL}^{*}_{0} + \neg \mathrm{I}\Sigma^{0}_{1} , and \mathrm{WKL} is the strongest \Pi^{1}_{2} statement that is \Pi^{1}_{1} -conservative over \mathrm{RCA}^{*}_{0} + \neg \mathrm{I}\Sigma^{0}_{1} . Applying our results to the \Delta^{0}_{n} -definable sets in models of \mathrm{RCA}^{*}_{0} + \mathrm{B}\Sigma^{0}_{n} + \neg \mathrm{I}\Sigma^{0}_{n} that also satisfy an appropriate relativization of weak König’s lemma, we prove that for each n \ge 1 , the set of \Pi^{1}_{2} sentences that are \Pi^{1}_{1} -conservative over \mathrm{RCA}^{*}_{0} + \mathrm{B}\Sigma^{0}_{n} + \neg \mathrm{I}\Sigma^{0}_{n} is computably enumerable. In contrast, we prove that the set of \Pi^{1}_{2} sentences that are \Pi^{1}_{1} -conservative over \mathrm{RCA}^{*}_{0} + \mathrm{B}\Sigma^{0}_{n} is \Pi_{2} -complete. This answers a question of Towsner. We also show that \mathrm{RCA}_{0} + \mathrm{RT}^{2}_{2} is \Pi^{1}_{1} -conservative over \mathrm{B}\Sigma^{0}_{2} if and only if it is conservative over \mathrm{B}\Sigma^{0}_{2} with respect to \forall \Pi^{0}_{5} sentences.

mathematics, applied
Modal weak Kleene logics: axiomatizations and relational semantics

Stefano Bonzio,Nicolò Zamperlin

2024-07-23

Abstract:Weak Kleene logics are three-valued logics characterized by the presence of an infectious truth-value. In their external versions, as they were originally introduced by Bochvar and Hallden, these systems are equipped with an additional connective capable of expressing whether a formula is classically true. In this paper we further expand the expressive power of external weak Kleen logics by modalizing them with a unary operator. The addition of an alethic modality gives rise to the two systems $\B^{\square}$ and $MPWK$, which have two different readings of the modal operator. We provide these logics with a complete and decidable Hilbert-style axiomatization w.r.t. a three-valued possible worlds semantics. The starting point of these calculi are new axiomatizations for the non-modal bases B and PWKe, which we provide using the recent algebraization results about these two logics. In particular, we prove the algebraizability of $\PWKe$. Finally some standard extensions of the basic modal systems are provided with their completeness results w.r.t. special classes of frames.

Logic
On finite alphabets and infinite bases II: completed and ready simulation

Taolue Chen,Wan Fokkink,Sumit Nain

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/11690634_1

2006-01-01

Abstract:We prove that the equational theory of the process algebra BCCSP modulo completed simulation equivalence does not have a finite basis. Furhermore, we prove that with a finite alphabet of actions, the equational theory of BCCSP modulo ready simulation equivalence does not have a finite basis. In contrast, with an infinite alphabet, the latter equational theory does have a finite basis.
Symbolic Automata: $ω$-Regularity Modulo Theories

Margus Veanes,Thomas Ball,Gabriel Ebner,Olli Saarikivi

2023-10-04

Abstract:Symbolic automata are finite state automata that support potentially infinite alphabets, such as the set of rational numbers, generally applied to regular expressions/languages over finite words. In symbolic automata (or automata modulo theories), an alphabet is represented by an effective Boolean algebra, supported by a decision procedure for satisfiability. Regular languages over infinite words (so called $\omega$-regular languages) have a rich history paralleling that of regular languages over finite words, with well known applications to model checking via Büchi automata and temporal logics. We generalize symbolic automata to support $\omega$-regular languages via symbolic transition terms and symbolic derivatives, bringing together a variety of classic automata and logics in a unified framework that provides all the necessary ingredients to support symbolic model checking modulo $A$, $NBW_A$. In particular, we define: (1) alternating Büchi automata modulo $A$, $ABW_A$ as well (non-alternating) non-deterministic Büchi automata modulo $A$, $NBW_A$; (2) an alternation elimination algorithm that incrementally constructs an $NBW_A$ from an $ABW_A$, and can also be used for constructing the product of two $NBW_A$'s; (3) a definition of linear temporal logic (LTL) modulo $A$ that generalizes Vardi's construction of alternating Büchi automata from LTL, using (2) to go from LTL modulo $A$ to $NBW_A$ via $ABW_A$. Finally, we present a combination of LTL modulo $A$ with extended regular expressions modulo $A$ that generalizes the Property Specification Language (PSL). Our combination allows regex complement, that is not supported in PSL but can be supported naturally by using symbolic transition terms.

Formal Languages and Automata Theory,Data Structures and Algorithms
Normal Forms for Elements of ${}^*$-Continuous Kleene Algebras Representing the Context-Free Languages

Mark Hopkins,Hans Leiß

2024-09-15

Abstract:Within the tensor product $K \mathop{\otimes_{\cal R}} C_2'$ of any ${}^*$-continuous Kleene algebra $K$ with the polycyclic ${}^*$-continuous Kleene algebra $C_2'$ over two bracket pairs there is a copy of the fixed-point closure of $K$: the centralizer of $C_2'$ in $K \mathop{\otimes_{\cal R}} C_2'$. Using an automata-theoretic representation of elements of $K\mathop{\otimes_{\cal R}} C_2'$ à la Kleene, with the aid of normal form theorems that restrict the occurrences of brackets on paths through the automata, we develop a foundation for a calculus of context-free expressions without variable binders. We also give some results on the bra-ket ${}^*$-continuous Kleene algebra $C_2$, motivate the ``completeness equation'' that distinguishes $C_2$ from $C_2'$, and show that $C_2'$ already validates a relativized form of this equation.

Formal Languages and Automata Theory
Axiomatizing Lüttgen & Vogler's Ready Simulation for Finite Processes in CLLR

Yan Zhang,Zhaohui Zhu,Jinjin Zhang,Yong Zhou

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jal.2015.06.005

2015-01-01

Abstract:In the framework of logic labelled transition systems, a variant of weak ready simulation has been presented by Lüttgen and Vogler. It has been shown that such behavioural preorder is the largest precongruence w.r.t. parallel and conjunction composition satisfying some desirable properties. This paper offers a ground-complete axiomatization for this precongruence over processes containing no recursion in the calculus CLL R . Compared with the usual inference systems for process calculi, in addition to axioms about process operators, such system contains a number of axioms to characterize the interaction between process operators and logical operators.
On the Axiomatizability of Impossible Futures

Taolue Chen,Wan Fokkink,Robert J. van Glabbeek

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2168/lmcs-11(3:17)2015

2015-01-01

Logical Methods in Computer Science

Abstract:A general method is established to derive a ground-complete axiomatization for a weak semantics from such an axiomatization for its concrete counterpart, in the context of the process algebra BCCS. This transformation moreover preserves omega-completeness. It is applicable to semantics at least as coarse as impossible futures semantics. As an application, ground- and omega-complete axiomatizations are derived for weak failures, completed trace and trace semantics. We then present a finite, sound, ground-complete axiomatization for the concrete impossible futures preorder, which implies a finite, sound, ground-complete axiomatization for the weak impossible futures preorder. In contrast, we prove that no finite, sound axiomatization for BCCS modulo concrete and weak impossible futures equivalence is ground-complete. If the alphabet of actions is infinite, then the aforementioned ground-complete axiomatizations are shown to be omega-complete. If the alphabet is finite, we prove that the inequational theories of BCCS modulo the concrete and weak impossible futures preorder lack such a finite basis.
Algebras of Binary Formulas for Weakly Circularly Minimal Theories with Trivial Definable Closure

B. Sh. Kulpeshov

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1134/s0037446624020071

2024-03-27

Siberian Mathematical Journal

Abstract:We describe the algebras of binary formulas for countably categorical weakly circularly minimal theories with 1-transitive nonprimitive automorphism group and trivial definable closure having convexity rank 1. We find some criterion for commutativity of the algebras.

mathematics
Words-to-Letters Valuations for Language Kleene Algebras with Variable and Constant Complements

Yoshiki Nakamura,Ryoma Sin'ya

2024-11-25

Abstract:We investigate the equational theory for Kleene algebra terms with variable complements and constant complements -- (language) complement where it applies only to variables or constants -- w.r.t. languages. While the equational theory w.r.t. languages coincides with the language equivalence (under the standard language valuation) for Kleene algebra terms, this coincidence is broken if we extend the terms with complements. In this paper, we prove the decidability of some fragments of the equational theory: the universality problem is coNP-complete, and the inequational theory $t \le s$ is coNP-complete when $t$ does not contain Kleene-star. To this end, we introduce words-to-letters valuations; they are sufficient valuations for the equational theory and ease us in investigating the equational theory w.r.t. languages. Additionally, we show a completeness theorem of the equational theory for words with variable complements and the non-empty constant.

Logic in Computer Science
Expressiveness modulo Bisimilarity of Regular Expressions with Parallel Composition (Extended Abstract)

Jos C. M. Baeten,Bas Luttik,Tim Muller,Paul van Tilburg

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/S0960129514000309

2010-11-30

Abstract:The languages accepted by finite automata are precisely the languages denoted by regular expressions. In contrast, finite automata may exhibit behaviours that cannot be described by regular expressions up to bisimilarity. In this paper, we consider extensions of the theory of regular expressions with various forms of parallel composition and study the effect on expressiveness. First we prove that adding pure interleaving to the theory of regular expressions strictly increases its expressiveness up to bisimilarity. Then, we prove that replacing the operation for pure interleaving by ACP-style parallel composition gives a further increase in expressiveness. Finally, we prove that the theory of regular expressions with ACP-style parallel composition and encapsulation is expressive enough to express all finite automata up to bisimilarity. Our results extend the expressiveness results obtained by Bergstra, Bethke and Ponse for process algebras with (the binary variant of) Kleene's star operation.

Logic in Computer Science,Formal Languages and Automata Theory
On Finite Alphabets and Infinite Bases

Taolue Chen,Wan Fokkink,Bas Luttik,Sumit Nain

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ic.2007.09.003

IF: 1.24

2008-01-01

Information and Computation

Abstract:Van Glabbeek presented the linear time-branching time spectrum of behavioral semantics. He studied these semantics in the setting of the basic process algebra BCCSP, and gave finite, sound and ground-complete, axiomatizations for most of these semantics. Groote proved for some of van Glabbeek's axiomatizations that they are @w-complete, meaning that an equation can be derived if (and only if) all of its closed instantiations can be derived. In this paper, we settle the remaining open questions for all the semantics in the linear time-branching time spectrum, either positively by giving a finite sound and ground-complete axiomatization that is @w-complete, or negatively by proving that such a finite basis for the equational theory does not exist. We prove that in case of a finite alphabet with at least two actions, failure semantics affords a finite basis, while for ready simulation, completed simulation, simulation, possible worlds, ready trace, failure trace and ready semantics, such a finite basis does not exist. Completed simulation semantics also lacks a finite basis in case of an infinite alphabet of actions.
Kleene Algebra With Tests for Weighted Programs

Igor Sedlár

2023-03-01

Abstract:Weighted programs generalize probabilistic programs and offer a framework for specifying and encoding mathematical models by means of an algorithmic representation. Kleene algebra with tests is an algebraic formalism based on regular expressions with applications in proving program equivalence. We extend the language of Kleene algebra with tests so that it is sufficient to formalize reasoning about a simplified version weighted programs. We introduce relational semantics for the extended language, and we generalize the relational semantics to an appropriate extension of Kleene algebra with tests, called Kleene algebra with weights and tests. We demonstrate by means of an example that Kleene algebra with weights and tests offers a simple algebraic framework for reasoning about equivalence and optimal runs of weighted programs.

Logic in Computer Science
Completeness of Flat Coalgebraic Fixpoint Logics

Lutz Schröder,Yde Venema

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-15375-4_36

2016-06-09

Abstract:Modal fixpoint logics traditionally play a central role in computer science, in particular in artificial intelligence and concurrency. The mu-calculus and its relatives are among the most expressive logics of this type. However, popular fixpoint logics tend to trade expressivity for simplicity and readability, and in fact often live within the single variable fragment of the mu-calculus. The family of such flat fixpoint logics includes, e.g., LTL, CTL, and the logic of common knowledge. Extending this notion to the generic semantic framework of coalgebraic logic enables covering a wide range of logics beyond the standard mu-calculus including, e.g., flat fragments of the graded mu-calculus and the alternating-time mu-calculus (such as alternating-time temporal logic ATL), as well as probabilistic and monotone fixpoint logics. We give a generic proof of completeness of the Kozen-Park axiomatization for such flat coalgebraic fixpoint logics.

Logic in Computer Science
Algorithmic complexity for theories of commutative Kleene algebras

Stepan Lvovich Kuznetsov

DOI: https://doi.org/10.4213/im9480e

2024-04-05

Izvestiya Mathematics

Abstract:Kleene algebras are structures with addition, multiplication and constants and , which form an idempotent semiring, and the Kleene iteration operation. In the particular case of -continuous Kleene algebras, Kleene iteration is defined, in an infinitary way, as the supremum of powers of an element. We obtain results on algorithmic complexity for Horn theories (semantic entailment from finite sets of hypotheses) of commutative -continuous Kleene algebras. Namely, -completeness for the Horn theory and -completeness for its fragment, where iteration cannot be used in hypotheses, is proved. These results are commutative counterparts of the corresponding theorems of D. Kozen (2002) for the general (non-commutative) case. Several accompanying results are also obtained.

mathematics

Weak Kleene Algebra is Sound and (Possibly) Complete for Simulation

Completeness Theorems for Kleene algebra with tests and top

An Elementary Proof of the FMP for Kleene Algebra

Sound and complete axiomatizations of coalgebraic language equivalence

Completeness of Finitely Weighted Kleene Algebra With Tests

On Tools for Completeness of Kleene Algebra with Hypotheses

An isomorphism theorem for models of weak König’s lemma without primitive recursion

Modal weak Kleene logics: axiomatizations and relational semantics

On finite alphabets and infinite bases II: completed and ready simulation

Symbolic Automata: $ω$-Regularity Modulo Theories

Normal Forms for Elements of ${}^*$-Continuous Kleene Algebras Representing the Context-Free Languages

Axiomatizing Lüttgen & Vogler's Ready Simulation for Finite Processes in CLLR

On the Axiomatizability of Impossible Futures

Algebras of Binary Formulas for Weakly Circularly Minimal Theories with Trivial Definable Closure

Words-to-Letters Valuations for Language Kleene Algebras with Variable and Constant Complements

Expressiveness modulo Bisimilarity of Regular Expressions with Parallel Composition (Extended Abstract)

On Finite Alphabets and Infinite Bases

Kleene Algebra With Tests for Weighted Programs

Completeness of Flat Coalgebraic Fixpoint Logics

Algorithmic complexity for theories of commutative Kleene algebras