A.A. Coley
Abstract:The averaging problem in cosmology is of considerable importance for the correct interpretation of cosmological data. A rigorous mathematical definition of averaging in a cosmological model is necessary. In general, a spacetime is completely characterized by its scalar curvature invariants, and this suggests a particular spacetime averaging scheme based entirely on scalars. We clearly identify the problems of averaging in a cosmological model. We then present a precise definition of a cosmological model, and based upon this definition, we propose an averaging scheme in terms of scalar curvature invariants. This scheme is illustrated in a simple static spherically symmetric perfect fluid cosmological spacetime, where the averaging scales are clearly identified.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to solve the averaging problem in cosmology. Specifically, cosmological observations are usually based on the assumption of the spatially homogeneous and isotropic Friedmann - Lemaître - Robertson - Walker (FLRW) model plus small perturbations. These observational data are often interpreted as implying the existence of dark energy, that the spatial geometry is flat, and that there is currently an accelerated expansion, which has led to the so - called ΛCDM concordance model. Although this model is very remarkable, it does not convincingly explain all the data. If the basic cosmological model is not a perturbation of an exact flat FLRW solution, then the conventional data analysis and its interpretation may not be valid.
For example, in the presence of back - reaction effects, the standard analysis of type Ia supernovae (SNIa) and cosmic microwave background (CMB) data in the FLRW model cannot be directly applied because the dynamic behavior of the spatial curvature is different at this time. In fact, it has been proven that in inhomogeneous models, supernova data can be explained without dark energy, where all the effects of general relativity (GR) come into play. For example, the Lemaître - Tolman - Bondi (LTB) solution can be used to fit the observational data without the need for dark energy, but it is required to place the observer at the center of a large - scale under - density region.
Therefore, the averaging problem in cosmology is the key to correctly interpreting cosmological data. In order to obtain the correct governing equations on the cosmic scale, it is necessary to average the Einstein field equations (EFE) of GR (plus the photon propagation theory, that is, the information of the trajectories followed by actual particles). By assuming the homogeneity and isotropy of space on the largest scale, inhomogeneities affect the dynamics through correction (back - reaction) terms, which may lead to qualitatively and quantitatively different behaviors from the FLRW model.
In the paper, a definition of a cosmological model based on scalar curvature invariants is proposed, and accordingly an averaging scheme is proposed. This scheme is illustrated in a simple static spherically symmetric perfect - fluid cosmological space - time model, where the averaging scale is clearly defined. This method takes advantage of the fact that the integral of scalar quantities over space - time regions is always well - defined, thus providing a space - time averaging scheme completely described by scalars. This helps to more accurately understand and interpret cosmological observational data, especially when considering the large - scale structure and dynamic evolution of the universe.