Abstract:Predicting accurate protein–ligand binding affinities is an important task in drug discovery but remains a challenge even with computationally expensive biophysics-based energy scoring methods and state-of-the-art deep learning approaches. Despite the recent advances in the application of deep convolutional and graph neural network-based approaches, it remains unclear what the relative advantages of each approach are and how they compare with physics-based methodologies that have found more mainstream success in virtual screening pipelines. We present fusion models that combine features and inference from complementary representations to improve binding affinity prediction. This, to our knowledge, is the first comprehensive study that uses a common series of evaluations to directly compare the performance of three-dimensional (3D)-convolutional neural networks (3D-CNNs), spatial graph neural networks (SG-CNNs), and their fusion. We use temporal and structure-based splits to assess performance on novel protein targets. To test the practical applicability of our models, we examine their performance in cases that assume that the crystal structure is not available. In these cases, binding free energies are predicted using docking pose coordinates as the inputs to each model. In addition, we compare these deep learning approaches to predictions based on docking scores and molecular mechanic/generalized Born surface area (MM/GBSA) calculations. Our results show that the fusion models make more accurate predictions than their constituent neural network models as well as docking scoring and MM/GBSA rescoring, with the benefit of greater computational efficiency than the MM/GBSA method. Finally, we provide the code to reproduce our results and the parameter files of the trained models used in this work. The software is available as open source at <a class="extLink" href="https://github.com/llnl/fast">https://github.com/llnl/fast</a>. Model parameter files are available at <a class="extLink" href="http://ftp://gdo-bioinformatics.ucllnl.org/fast/pdbbind2016_model_checkpoints/">ftp://gdo-bioinformatics.ucllnl.org/fast/pdbbind2016_model_checkpoints/</a>.This article has not yet been cited by other publications.

A new protein binding pocket similarity measure based on comparison of 3D atom clouds: application to ligand prediction

Estimating the Similarity between Protein Pockets

Identification of Cavities on Protein Surface Using Multiple Computational Approaches for Drug Binding Site Prediction

Comparison of Different Ranking Methods in Protein-Ligand Binding Site Prediction

Large-scale Binding Ligand Prediction by Improved Patch-Based Method Patch-Surfer2.0

SGPocket: A New Graph Convolutional Neural Network for Ligand-protein Binding Site Prediction

A critical comparative assessment of predictions of protein-binding sites for biologically relevant organic compounds.

PocketAnchor: Learning Structure-based Pocket Representations for Protein-Ligand Interaction Prediction

A fast protein binding site comparison algorithm for proteome-wide protein function prediction and drug repurposing

Predicting Protein-Ligand Binding Sites Based on an Improved Geometric Algorithm

A new protein-ligand binding sites prediction method based on the integration of protein sequence conservation information

Protein Ligand-Specific Binding Residue Predictions by an Ensemble Classifier

Ligand Binding Site Similarity Identification Based on Chemical and Geometric Similarity

A Point Cloud Graph Neural Network for Protein–Ligand Binding Site Prediction

Protein pocket detection via convex hull surface evolution and associated Reeb graph

Protein-Ligand Binding Site Recognition Using Complementary Binding-Specific Substructure Comparison And Sequence Profile Alignment

PointSite: A Point Cloud Segmentation Tool for Identification of Protein Ligand Binding Atoms

Improved Protein–Ligand Binding Affinity Prediction with Structure-Based Deep Fusion Inference

A Novel Protein Descriptor for the Prediction of Drug Binding Sites

A machine learning approach to predicting protein–ligand binding affinity with applications to molecular docking