Performance of Magnetic Quantum Cellular Automata and Limitations due to Thermal Noise

Federico M. Spedalieri,Ajey P. Jacob,Dmitri Nikonov,Vwani P. Roychowdhury
DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.0906.5172
2009-06-30
Abstract:Operation parameters of magnetic quantum cellular automata are evaluated for the purposes of reliable logic operation. The dynamics of the nanomagnets is simulated via the Landau-Lifshitz-Gilbert equations with a stochastic magnetic field corresponding to thermal fluctuations. It is found that in the macrospin approximation the switching speed does not change under scaling of both size and distances between nanomagnets. Thermal fluctuations put a limitation on the size of nanomagnets, since the gate error rate becomes excessive for nanomagnets smaller than 200nm at room temperature.
Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to evaluate the operating parameters of Magnetic Quantum Cellular Automata (MQCA) in reliable logical operations and explore the limitations of its performance due to thermal noise. Specifically, the research mainly focuses on the following aspects: 1. **Bit Stability and Minimum Size**: - Study the constraints of bit stability on the size of nanomagnets in MQCA. - Analyze the energy barrier height of nanomagnets through the free - energy formula to ensure the stability of information storage. 2. **Dynamics and Speed**: - Use the Landau - Lifshitz - Gilbert (LLG) equation to simulate the dynamic behavior of nanomagnets and evaluate the speed at which signals propagate along the nanomagnet chain. - Explore the influence of material properties (such as saturation magnetization) on the switching speed. 3. **Initialization and Bit Stability**: - Discuss how to initialize the magnetization direction of nanomagnets so that they are arranged in the hard - axis direction. - Introduce biaxial anisotropy to create a local energy minimum, stabilize the initial configuration, and prevent spontaneous flips caused by thermal fluctuations. 4. **Thermal Effects and Gate Error Probability**: - Simulate the influence of thermal fluctuations on MQCA operations, especially the gate error rate due to thermal fluctuations. - Analyze the error probability under different temperatures, damping constants, and biaxial anisotropy constants, and look for the optimal parameter combination to reduce the error rate. ### Main Findings - **Bit Stability**: To ensure sufficient bit stability, the size of nanomagnets should not be less than 200 nm (at room temperature), otherwise the error rate will be too high. - **Speed**: The switching speed of MQCA is proportional to the saturation magnetization of the material, but in the simplified model, size scaling does not affect the gate time. - **Initialization**: The introduction of biaxial anisotropy can effectively stabilize the initial configuration, but its strength needs to be moderate, which can prevent spontaneous flips without affecting signal transmission. - **Thermal Effects**: Even with the introduction of biaxial anisotropy, the gate error rate at room temperature is still relatively high (about 15%). Reducing the temperature can significantly reduce the influence of thermal fluctuations and thus reduce the error rate. ### Conclusion This research shows that although MQCA has potential in some aspects, such as low power consumption and high - density integration, thermal noise and bit stability issues are the main obstacles to its practical application. Future research needs to further optimize material and structure design to improve its reliability and performance.