Abstract:Financial advisors often emphasize asset diversification as a means of limiting losses from investments that perform unexpectedly poorly over a particular time period. One might expect that this perceived wisdom could apply in another high stakes arena–professional baseball–where player salaries comprise a substantial portion of a team’s operational costs, year-to-year player performance is highly variable, and injuries can occur at any time. These attributes are particularly true in the case of the starting pitching staffs of professional baseball teams. Accordingly, this study analyzes starting pitcher performance and financial data from all Major League Baseball teams for the period 1985–2016 to determine whether the standard investment advice is applicable in this context, understanding that the time horizon for success for an investor and a baseball team may be distinct. A multiple logistic regression model of playoff qualification probability, based on realized pitcher performance, measures of luck, and starting pitcher staff salary diversification is used to address this question. A further stratification is conducted to determine whether there are differences in strategy for teams with allocated financial resources that are above or below league average. We find that teams with above average resources increase their post-season qualification probability by focusing their salary funds on a relative few starting pitchers rather than diversifying that investment across the staff. Second, we find that pitcher performance must align with that investment in order for the team to have a high qualification probability. Third, the influence of luck is not negligible, but those teams that allocate more overall funds to their pitching are more resilient to bad luck. Thus, poorly resourced teams, who are generally unable to bid for pitchers at the highest salary levels, must adopt alternative strategies to maintain their competitiveness.

Hitting Streaks Don't Obey Your Rules: Evidence That Hitting Streaks Aren't Just By-Products of Random Variations

Undestanding Baseball Team Standings and Streaks

Same-Score Streaks: A Case Study in Probability Modeling

Surprised by the Hot Hand Fallacy? A Truth in the Law of Small Numbers

Uncertainty in the Hot Hand Fallacy: Detecting Streaky Alternatives to Random Bernoulli Sequences

The Hot Hand in Actual Game Situations

Detrending career statistics in professional baseball: Accounting for the steroids era and beyond

Illusion of persistence in NBA 1995-2018 regular season data

Hot Hands, Streaks and Coin-flips: Numerical Nonsense in the New York Times

The Hot Hand and Its Effect on the NBA

Hot Streaks in Artistic, Cultural, and Scientific Careers

Alternative proof for the bias of the hot hand statistic of streak length one

Is Basketball a Game of Runs?

Predicting Baseball Home Run Records Using Exponential Frequency Distributions

The golden ratio in baseball: the influence of historical eras on winning percentages in major league baseball

Classifying batted ball outcomes from Division I collegiate baseball players

Can the hot hand phenomenon be modelled? A Bayesian hidden Markov approach

How often does the best team win? A unified approach to understanding randomness in North American sport

Does the principle of investment diversification apply to the starting pitching staffs of major league baseball teams?

The Hot Hand in the NBA 3-Point Contest: The Importance of Location, Location, Location

Test–retest Reliability for Hitting Accuracy Tennis Test