An integrated optimal-GICP design for the SPRT control chart with estimated process parameters based on the average number of observations to signal

J.W. Teoh,W.L. Teoh,Michael B.C. Khoo,K.P. Tran,M.H. Lee

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/16843703.2024.2312010

2024-02-09

Quality Technology & Quantitative Management

Abstract:As a variable-sample-size control scheme, the sequential probability ratio test (SPRT) chart is favoured due to its sensitivity and high sampling efficiency. It is frequently documented that the SPRT chart inspects only a small number of observations at each sampling stage, making the said chart extremely appealing to quality engineers. In the current literature, most developments of the SPRT chart are established based on the average run length and average time to signal metrics. However, these metrics do not consider sampling efficiency. In this paper, we develop two optimal designs of the SPRT chart, based on (i) the average value of the average number of observations to signal (AANOS) and (ii) the expected value of the AANOS, with consideration of Phase-I process parameter estimation. We develop a model that integrates the concept of optimization and the guaranteed in-control performance (GICP) framework to neutralize the adverse effects of parameter estimation. Results show that the proposed optimal-GICP design preserves satisfactory out-of-control performances for moderate and large mean shifts, while keeping the false alarm rates at reasonably low levels. Finally, we illustrate an example of the SPRT chart with estimated process parameters for monitoring loop height measurements from a wire bonding dataset.

engineering, industrial,operations research & management science,statistics & probability

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems Addressed by the Paper

The paper primarily addresses the performance optimization of Statistical Process Control (SPRT) charts in the context of estimating process parameters. Specifically:

1. **Deficiencies in Existing SPRT Chart Designs**:
- Most existing SPRT chart designs are based on Average Run Length (ARL) or Average Time to Signal (ATS), which overlook the important characteristic of sample size.
- In practical applications, process parameters are usually unknown and need to be estimated using Phase-I data.

2. **Proposed New Methods**:
- Two new optimization design methods are proposed, based on:
- Average Number of Observations to Signal (AANOS).
- Expected Average Number of Observations to Signal (EAANOS).
- These designs consider the impact of process parameter estimation on performance and ensure performance stability under different mean shifts.

3. **Optimization Goals**:
- To improve the performance of SPRT charts by minimizing AANOS and EAANOS, while ensuring that the false alarm rate remains within a reasonable range.

Through these optimized designs, the paper aims to provide a more efficient and robust method for monitoring quality changes in industrial processes.