Low versus standard calorie and protein feeding in ventilated adults with shock: a randomised, controlled, multicentre, open-label, parallel-group trial (NUTRIREA-3)
Jean Reignier,Gaetan Plantefeve,Jean-Paul Mira,Laurent Argaud,Pierre Asfar,Nadia Aissaoui,Julio Badie,Nicolae-Vlad Botoc,Laurent Brisard,Hoang-Nam Bui,Delphine Chatellier,Louis Chauvelot,Alain Combes,Christophe Cracco,Michael Darmon,Vincent Das,Matthieu Debarre,Agathe Delbove,Jérôme Devaquet,Louis-Marie Dumont,Olivier Gontier,Samuel Groyer,Laurent Guérin,Bertrand Guidet,Yannick Hourmant,Samir Jaber,Fabien Lambiotte,Christophe Leroy,Philippe Letocart,Benjamin Madeux,Julien Maizel,Olivier Martinet,Frédéric Martino,Virginie Maxime,Emmanuelle Mercier,Mai-Anh Nay,Saad Nseir,Johanna Oziel,Walter Picard,Gael Piton,Jean-Pierre Quenot,Florian Reizine,Anne Renault,Jack Richecoeur,Jean-Philippe Rigaud,Francis Schneider,Daniel Silva,Michel Sirodot,Bertrand Souweine,Fabienne Tamion,Nicolas Terzi,Didier Thévenin,Guillaume Thiery,Nathalie Thieulot-Rolin,Jean-Francois Timsit,Francois Tinturier,Patrice Tirot,Thierry Vanderlinden,Isabelle Vinatier,Christophe Vinsonneau,Sebastian Voicu,Jean-Baptiste Lascarrou,Amélie Le Gouge,NUTRIREA-3 Trial Investigators,Clinical Research in Intensive Care,Sepsis (CRICS-TRIGGERSEP)Group,Damien Contou,Olivier Pajot,Paul Jaubert,Nathalie Marin,Marie Simon,Martin Cour,Satar Mortaza,Vincent Souday,Marie Lemerle,Sylvain Malfroy,Fernando Berdaguer Ferrari,Bertrand Rozec,Didier Gruson,Charline Sazio,Suzanne Champion,Florence Boissier,Anne Veinstein,Loredana Baboi,Jean-Christophe Richard,Hodane Yonis,Loïc Le Guennec,Lucie Lefevre,Juliette Chommeloux,Guillaume Hékimian,Virginie Lemiale,Eric Mariotte,Sandrine Valade,Joanna Tirolien,Yannick Fedun,Charles Cerf,Guillaume Tachon,Jérôme Roustan,Sylvie Vimeux,Michel Bonnivard,Nadia Anguel,David Osman,Karim Asehnoune,Antoine Roquilly,Fouad Belafia,Matthieu Conseil,Moussa Cisse,Bouras Chaouki,Rémi Espenel,Christine Brasse,Sébastien Ena,Arnaud Delahaye,Jeremy Castanera,Thierry Dulac,Philippe Petua,Yoann Zerbib,Clément Brault,Djillali Annane,Rania Bounab,Nicholas Heming,Thierry Boulain,Sophie Jacquier,Grégoire Muller,Raphael Favory,Sébastien Préau,Julien Poissy,Alexandre Massri,Floriane Lissonde,Hadrien Winiszewski,Thibault Vieille,Marine Jacquier,Marie Labruyère,Pascal Andreu,Jean-Marc Tadié,Laetitia Bodenes,Danièle Combaux,David Luis,Antoine Marchalot,Jean-Etienne Herbrecht,Raphaël Clere-Jehl,David Schnell,Jérôme Aboad,David Bougon,Etienne Escudier,Elisabeth Coupez,Claire Dupuis,Zoe Demailly,Louis-Marie Galerneau,Jonathan Chelly,Franck Pourcine,Ly Van Vong,Sonia Abid,Etienne De Montmollin,Romain Sonneville,Christophe Guitton,Nicolas Chudeau,Mickaël Landais,Vincent Pages,Caroline Séjourné,Imen Rahmani,Ghada Sbouj,Bruno Megarbane,Nicolas Deye,Isabelle Malissin
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/S2213-2600(23)00092-9
Abstract:Background: The optimal calorie and protein intakes at the acute phase of severe critical illness remain unknown. We hypothesised that early calorie and protein restriction improved outcomes in these patients, compared with standard calorie and protein targets. Methods: The pragmatic, randomised, controlled, multicentre, open-label, parallel-group NUTRIREA-3 trial was performed in 61 French intensive care units (ICUs). Adults (≥18 years) receiving invasive mechanical ventilation and vasopressor support for shock were randomly assigned to early nutrition (started within 24 h after intubation) with either low or standard calorie and protein targets (6 kcal/kg per day and 0·2-0·4 g/kg per day protein vs 25 kcal/kg per day and 1·0-1·3 g/kg per day protein) during the first 7 ICU days. The two primary endpoints were time to readiness for ICU discharge and day 90 all-cause mortality. Key secondary outcomes included secondary infections, gastrointestinal events, and liver dysfunction. The trial is registered on ClinicalTrials.gov, NCT03573739, and is completed. Findings: Of 3044 patients randomly assigned between July 5, 2018, and 8 Dec 8, 2020, eight withdrew consent to participation. By day 90, 628 (41·3%) of 1521 patients in the low group and 648 (42·8%) of 1515 patients in the standard group had died (absolute difference -1·5%, 95% CI -5·0 to 2·0; p=0·41). Median time to readiness for ICU discharge was 8·0 days (IQR 5·0-14·0) in the low group and 9·0 days (5·0-17·0) in the standard group (hazard ratio [HR] 1·12, 95% CI 1·02 to 1·22; p=0·015). Proportions of patients with secondary infections did not differ between the groups (HR 0·85, 0·71 to 1·01; p=0·06). The low group had lower proportions of patients with vomiting (HR 0·77, 0·67 to 0·89; p<0·001), diarrhoea (0·83, 0·73 to 0·94; p=0·004), bowel ischaemia (0·50, 0·26 to 0·95; p=0·030), and liver dysfunction (0·92, 0·86-0·99; p=0·032). Interpretation: Compared with standard calorie and protein targets, early calorie and protein restriction did not decrease mortality but was associated with faster recovery and fewer complications. Funding: French Ministry of Health.