Concomitant Solid Separation through Electric Field Enhanced Crystallization
Wei W. Li,Norbert Radacsi,Herman J. M. Kramer
2017-01-01
Abstract:When applied to a pure component suspension in an apolar solvent, a strong inhomogeneous electric field induces particle movement and the particles are collected at the surface of one of the two electrodes. This new phenomenon was used to separately isolate two organic crystalline compounds, phenazine and caffeine, from their suspension of 1,4-dioxane. First, the crystals of both compounds were collected at different electrodes under the influence of the electric field. Subsequent cooling crystallization allowed the immobilization and growth of the particles on the electrodes, which were separately collected after the experiment with purities higher than 91%. This method can be further developed into a technique for crystal separation and recovery in complex multicomponent suspensions of industrial processes. Crystallization is an effective and efficient separation technology that can, in a single process step, recover the desired compounds from solutions as high purity (>99%) crystalline solids [1,2,3,4] . However, such highly purified product is hard to obtain from a multi-component solution by direct crystallization, such as the product stream from a type-I Multicomponent Reaction (MCR), [5,6] or a racemic mixture of chiral pharmaceutical compounds, [7] since a mixed suspension is a likely result. Further purification of the solid phase usually requires additional steps (see Figure 1 (a) for instance), which will inevitably lead to the loss of valuable products. Alternatively, a single crystallization step coupled with simultaneous particle separation could diminish the product loss while effectively recovering desired solute from the mixed solution. Particle manipulation and subsequent separation can be achieved by the application of electromagnetic fields: a magnetic field could separate polymorphs, crystalline solids with different solid-state structures, to prepare seeds for large-scale crystallization, provided that a suitable paramagnetic medium can be found. [8] Alternatively, an electric field has been used in the successful capturing or manipulation of desired nanoparticles [9] and the assembly of colloid particles for the production of, for instance, optically tunable micropatterns, biosensors, and biofuel cells. [10-12] In all of these cases, the liquid phases did not contain any dissolved particle materials. On the other hand, the electric field has been used to localize protein crystallization and control its nucleation rate from a clear solution, in absence of any seed crystals. [13,14] However, up till now, the combination of particle manipulation by an electric field with the crystallization process for the in-situ product separation and recovery has, to our knowledge, never been attempted. In the present study, the experimental proof is given for an electric field enhanced crystallization (EEC) process by which the two solutes from a multi-component solution are separately recovered, as schematically demonstrated in Figure 1 (b). Figure 1. Schematic demonstrations of solutes separation from a multicomponent solution by direct crystallization (a) and Electric Field Enhanced Crystallization (b). Subjected to an inhomogeneous electric field, particles in a suspension experience dielectrophoretic (DEP) and possibly electrophoretic (EP) forces: DEP originates from the difference in dielectric constants of the particles and the surrounding medium and drags the particles with larger dielectric constant towards the location of the electric field maxima, [15,16] while EP forces, which work only on charged particles, are directed towards the electrode with the counter charge. [17] To prevent electrochemical reactions, which would reduce the product yield, the current through a crystallizing suspension should be minimized. Meanwhile, the inhomogeneous field needs to be sufficiently strong and the dielectric constant of the solvent should be sufficiently small to ensure the effective manipulation of crystals by the DEP force. Therefore, the apolar and nonconductive solvent 1,4-dioxane was used in this study. We first applied an inhomogeneous electrostatic field to a 6 mL isonicotinamide (INA) suspension in 1,4-dioxane (ca. 18 mg solid/ml solvent), generated by a Direct Current (DC) potential difference between two parallel rod-shape electrodes roughly 6 mm apart, which were immersed into the suspension. In the [a] Prof. dr. J. H. ter Horst, EPSRC Centre for Innovative Manufacturing in Continuous Manufacturing and Crystallisation (CMAC) Strathclyde Institute of Pharmacy and Biomedical Sciences (SIPBS) Technology and Innovation Centre University of Strathclyde 99 George Street, Glasgow G1 1RD, U.K. E-mail: joop.terhorst@strath.ac.uk [b] Prof. Dr. ir. van der Heijden, Dr. ir. H. J. M. Kramer, ir. W.W. Li Pdeng, Dr. Radacsi, Department of Process and Energy Delft University of Technology Leeghwaterstraat 39, 2628 CB, Delft, the Netherlands Supporting information for this article is given via a link at the end of the document.