Dynamics of carbene formation in the reaction of methane with the tantalum cation in the gas phase

Marcel Meta,Maximilian E. Huber,Maurice Birk,Martin Wedele,Milan Ončák,Jennifer Meyer

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3fd00171g

2024-05-21

Faraday Discussions

Abstract:The controlled activation of methane has drawn significant attention throughout various disciplines over the last few decades. In gas-phase experiments, the use of model systems with reduced complexity compared to condensed-phase catalytic systems allows us to investigate the intrinsic reactivity of elementary reactions down to the atomic level. Methane is rather inert in chemical reactions, as the weakening or cleavage of a C–H bond is required to make use of methane as C 1 -building block. The simplest model system for transition-metal-based catalysts is a mono-atomic metal ion. Only a few atomic transition-metal cations activate methane at room temperature. One of the most efficient elements is tantalum, which forms a carbene and releases molecular hydrogen in the reaction with methane: Ta + + CH 4 → TaCH 2 + + H 2 . The reaction takes place at room temperature due to efficient intersystem crossing from the quintet to the triplet surface, i.e. , from the electronic ground state of the tantalum cation to the triplet ground state of the tantalum carbene. This multi-state reactivity is often seen for reactions involving transition-metal centres, but leads to their theoretical treatment being a challenge even today. Chemical reactions, or to be precise reactive collisions, are dynamic processes making their description even more of a challenge to experiment and theory alike. Experimental energy- and angle-differential cross sections allow us to probe the rearrangement of atoms during a reactive collision. By interpreting the scattering signatures, we gain insight into the atomistic mechanisms and can move beyond stationary descriptions. Here, we present a study combining collision energy dependent experimentally measured differential cross sections with ab initio calculations of the minimum energy pathway. Product ion velocity distributions were recorded using our crossed-beam velocity map imaging experiment dedicated to studying transition-metal ion molecule reactions. TaCH 2 + velocity distributions reveal a significant degree of indirect dynamics. However, the scattering distributions also show signatures of rebound dynamics. We compare the present results to the oxygen transfer reaction between Ta + and carbon dioxide, which we recently studied.

chemistry, physical

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the kinetic mechanism of the reaction between methane and tantalum ions in the gas phase. Specifically, the research aims to explore the dynamic behavior in the process of the reaction between methane and tantalum ions to generate carbene through a combination of experimental measurement and theoretical calculation. This process is of great significance for understanding the basic mechanism of transition - metal - catalyzed methane activation, especially in terms of controlling the efficient utilization of methane as a C1 building block.

### Research Background
Methane (\( \text{CH}_4 \)) is a major natural carbon source and is currently mainly used as fuel. However, as natural petroleum resources decrease in the coming decades, methane has also become an important C1 raw material in the chemical industry. However, the chemical conversion of methane faces the challenges of selective activation and chemical modification. Methane is very inert chemically. The bond dissociation energy of its C - H bond is as high as 4.5 eV, and it has no dipole moment, low quadrupole moment, low polarizability (2.593 ų), and high ionization energy (12.6 eV). These characteristics make methane hardly react in chemical reactions, so a catalyst is required to achieve cost - effective chemical conversion.

### Research Objectives
In this paper, the reaction kinetics of methane and tantalum ions (\( \text{Ta}^+ \)) in the gas phase are studied in detail through experiments and theoretical calculations. Specific objectives include:
1. **Experimental Measurement**: Use the crossed - beam three - dimensional velocity - map imaging technique to record the velocity distribution of the product ion \( \text{TaCH}_2^+ \) in order to obtain the energy and angle differential cross - sections (DCS).
2. **Theoretical Calculation**: Calculate the minimum - energy path on the reaction path by the ab initio method, considering different spin multiplicities (quintet, triplet, and singlet).
3. **Kinetic Analysis**: Analyze the experimental data to identify the dynamic features in the reaction, such as indirect kinetics and rebound kinetics, and explore the distribution of energy between translational and internal parts.

### Main Findings
1. **Reaction Path**: The reaction path includes quintet, triplet, and singlet states. Among them, the quintet - state path has an energy barrier of about 1.5 eV, while the reactions starting from the triplet or singlet states are exothermic reactions, and the energies of all transition states are lower than those of the free reactants.
2. **Dynamic Features**: The experimental results show that at low relative collision energies, the scattering of the product ion \( \text{TaCH}_2^+ \) is isotropic, indicating that the reaction mainly proceeds through an indirect kinetic mechanism. As the collision energy increases, the scattering distribution becomes asymmetric, and some events are beyond the kinetic cutoff range, indicating the existence of direct rebound kinetics.
3. **Energy Distribution**: Although the kinetic energy of the product ion is small, as the collision energy increases, the internal energy distribution is slightly shifted to higher values, indicating that part of the additional collision energy is distributed to the rotational - vibrational excitation of \( \text{TaCH}_2^+ \) or \( \text{H}_2 \).

### Conclusion
This research reveals the dynamic mechanism of the reaction between methane and tantalum ions to generate carbene through a combination of experimental and theoretical methods. The research results not only help to understand the microscopic mechanism of transition - metal - catalyzed methane activation but also provide a theoretical basis for designing more effective catalysts.