Abstract:In social animals, group dynamics profoundly influence collective behaviours, vital in processes like information sharing and predator vigilance. Disentangling the causes of individual-level variation in social behaviours is crucial for understanding the evolution of sociality. This requires unravelling the genetic and environmental basis of these behaviours, which is challenging in uncontrolled wild populations. In this study, we partitioned genetic, developmental and spatial environmental variation in repeatable social network traits derived from foraging events using a multigenerational pedigree and extensive observational social data from a long-term monitored great tit population. Animal models indicated minimal narrow-sense heritability (2-3%) in group size choice, further reduced when spatial location was considered, which itself explains a substantial 30% of the observed variation. Individual gregariousness also had a small genetic component, with a low heritability estimate for degree (<5%). Centrality showed heritability up to 10% in one of three years sampled, whereas betweenness showed none, indicating modest genetic variation in individual sociability, but not group-switching tendencies. These findings suggest a small, albeit detectable, genetic influence on individual sociality, but pronounced spatial effects. Furthermore, our study highlights the importance of common environment effects (natal origin and brood identity), which essentially negated genetic effects when explicitly accounted for. In addition, we demonstrate that phenotypic resemblance can be a result of similarities beyond shared genes; spatial proximity at birth and natal environmental similarity explained up to 8% of individual sociability. Our results thus emphasise the role of non-genetic factors, particularly developmental and spatial variation, in shaping individual social behavioural tendencies.

Model of Genetic Variation in Human Social Networks

Human Genome Variation and the concept of Genotype Networks

Are human connectomes heritable?

Genetic, Natal, and Spatial Drivers of Social Phenotypes in Wild Great Tits

Homophyly/Kinship Model: Naturally Evolving Networks

Genetic and Environmental Contributions to Functional Connectivity Architecture of the Human Brain

A Model to Represent Human Social Relationships in Social Network Graphs

How networks shape diversity for better or worse

Cooperative behavior cascades in human social networks

The Social Contagion Hypothesis: Comment on "Social Contagion Theory: Examining Dynamic Social Networks and Human Behavior"

Modeling Random Networks with Heterogeneous Reciprocity

Far-reaching consequences of trait-based social preferences for the structure and function of animal social networks

Psychological Determinants and Consequences of Complex Networks

Automatic Discovery of Families of Network Generative Processes

Kinship Is a Network Tracking Social Technology, Not an Evolutionary Phenomenon

Universal Evolution Patterns of Degree Assortativity in Social Networks

Generative models of the human connectome

Model for simulating mechanisms responsible of similarities between people connected in networks of social relations

Networks in the Understanding of Economic Behaviors

The Importance of Regulatory Network Structure for Complex Trait Heritability and Evolution