"Bubbles in Society": The Example of the United States Apollo Program

Monika Gisler,Didier Sornette
DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.0806.0273
2008-06-02
Abstract:We present an analysis of the economic, political and social factors that underlay the Apollo program, one of the most exceptional and costly projects ever undertaken by the United States in peacetime that culminated in 1969 with the first human steps on the Moon. This study suggests that the Apollo program provides a vivid illustration of a societal bubble, defined as a collective over-enthusiasm as well as unreasonable investments and efforts, derived through excessive public and/or political expectations of positive outcomes associated with a general reduction of risk aversion. We show that economic, political and social factors weaved a network of reinforcing feedbacks that led to widespread over-enthusiasm and extraordinary commitment by individuals involved in the project as well as by politicians and by the public at large. We propose the general concept of ``pro-bubbles,'' according to which bubbles are an unavoidable development in technological and social enterprise that benefits society by allowing exceptional niches of innovation to be explored.
Physics and Society,History and Philosophy of Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to explore the economic, political and social factors behind the US Apollo program and analyze it as a vivid example of a societal bubble. Specifically, the paper proposes that the Apollo program demonstrated collective over - enthusiasm as well as irrational investment and effort, which stemmed from the excessive expectations of the public and/or politicians for positive results, leading to a general reduction in risk aversion. The authors further put forward the concept of "pro - bubble", believing that bubbles are an inevitable development stage in technology and social enterprises and that they benefit society by allowing the exploration of special innovative fields. In the Apollo program, this bubble was manifested as people's willingness to take huge risks and explore new opportunities under conditions that could not be rationalized by standard cost - benefit analysis. Although many of these opportunities were irrational and hopeless, there were also occasional lucky success stories. The main purpose of the paper is to explore and test through historical analysis whether bubbles not only lead to the destruction of a large amount of value but also promote the exploration and discovery in special fields. The authors believe that bubbles play a dynamic role in the process of innovation and discovery by reducing collective risk aversion. Therefore, they attempt to learn from the Apollo program to contribute to contemporary strategic and policy thinking.