Near-Maximal Mixing of Scalar Gluonium and Quark Mesons: A Gaussian Sum-Rule Analysis

D. Harnett,R.T. Kleiv,K. Moats,T.G. Steele

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nuclphysa.2010.12.005

2011-01-08

Abstract:Gaussian QCD sum-rules are ideally suited to the study of mixed states of gluonium (glueballs) and quark ($q\bar q$) mesons because of their capability to resolve widely-separated states of comparable strength. The analysis of the Gaussian QCD sum-rules (GSRs) for all possible two-point correlation functions of gluonic and non-strange ($I=0$) quark scalar ($J^{PC}=0^{++}$) currents is discussed. For the non-diagonal sum-rule of gluonic and $q\bar q$ currents we show that perturbative and gluon condensate contributions are chirally suppressed compared to non-perturbative effects of the quark condensate, mixed condensate, and instantons, implying that the mixing of quark mesons and gluonium is of non-perturbative origin. The independent predictions of the masses and relative coupling strengths from the non-diagonal and the two diagonal GSRs are remarkably consistent with a scenario of two states with masses of approximately 1 GeV and 1.4 GeV that couple to significant mixtures of quark and gluonic currents. The mixing is nearly maximal with the heavier mixed state having a slightly larger coupling to gluonic currents than the lighter state.

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the theoretical analysis of the mixing states between scalar glueballs and quark mesons. Specifically, the author uses Gaussian Quantum Chromodynamics sum - rules (GSRs) to study these mixing states, especially their masses and coupling strengths. The core problem of the paper is to verify, through GSRs analysis, whether there are two states with masses of approximately 1 GeV and 1.4 GeV, which are significantly coupled to the mixture of quark and glueball currents.

### Background of the Paper
In strong - interaction physics, the properties of light scalar mesons are a very interesting and complex issue. There are multiple scalar (\(J^{PC} = 0^{++}\)) states below 2 GeV, and these states cannot be simply described by a quark - antiquark (\(\bar{q}q\)) nonet, indicating that there may be glueballs or tetraquark states. Glueballs are bound states composed of pure gluons, while quark mesons are bound states composed of quarks and antiquarks.

### Research Method
The author uses Gaussian Quantum Chromodynamics sum - rules (GSRs) to study the mixing between glueballs and quark mesons. GSRs are particularly suitable for studying states that are widely separated but of comparable strength. In the paper, all possible GSRs of two - point correlation functions are analyzed, and these correlation functions involve glueball and non - strange (\(I = 0\)) quark scalar (\(J^{PC} = 0^{++}\)) currents.

### Main Findings
1. **Non - perturbative Effects in Off - Diagonal GSRs**:
- The perturbative and gluon - condensate contributions in off - diagonal GSRs are chirally suppressed relative to quark - condensate, mixed - condensate and instanton effects. This means that the mixing of quark mesons and glueballs is of non - perturbative origin.

2. **Properties of Mixing States**:
- From the independent predictions of off - diagonal and two diagonal GSRs, there are two states with masses of approximately 1 GeV and 1.4 GeV respectively, which are significantly coupled to the mixture of quark and glueball currents. The mixing is almost maximal, and the heavier mixing state has a slightly stronger coupling to the glueball current than the lighter state.

3. **Importance of Off - Diagonal Correlation Functions**:
- To describe this behavior, the off - diagonal correlation functions must be large enough. However, the perturbative contribution in the off - diagonal correlation functions is small due to chiral suppression. The mixed - condensate effect and instanton effect in the off - diagonal correlation functions provide a large mixing scale.

### Conclusion
Through GSRs analysis, the paper confirms the existence of two mixing states with masses of 1 GeV and 1.4 GeV respectively, which are significantly coupled to the mixture of quark and glueball currents. This result supports the view that there is strong mixing between glueballs and quark mesons and provides a theoretical basis for further research on the properties of these mixing states.

### Formula Summary
- **Gaussian Sum - rule**:
\[
G_0(\hat{s}, \tau)=\frac{1}{\sqrt{4\pi\tau}}\int_{t_0}^{\infty}\exp\left(-\frac{(t - \hat{s})^2}{4\tau}\right)\frac{1}{\pi}\rho(t)\,dt,\quad\tau > 0
\]

- **Off - Diagonal Correlation Function**:
\[
\Pi_{gq}(Q^2)=\Pi_{\text{pert}}^{gq}(Q^2)+\Pi_{\text{cond}}^{gq}(Q^2)+\Pi_{\text{inst}}^{gq}(Q^2)
\]

- **Off - Diagonal GSRs**:
\[
G_0^{(gq)}(\hat{s}, \tau, s_0)=\frac{m_q^2}{\sqrt{4\pi\tau}}\int_0^{s_0}dt\exp\left(-\frac{(t - \hat{s})^2}{4\tau}\right)t\left(A_0 + 2A_1\log\left[\frac{t}{\sqrt{\tau}}\right]\right)