A different derivation of the acceleration of a particle in a non-inertial reference frame

Eli Lansey

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.0803.3826

2008-03-27

Abstract:A new derivation of the acceleration of a particle in a non-inertial reference frame, including the Coriolis effect, is developed using the geometry of complex numbers in the complex plane.

Classical Physics,General Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Intuitive Derivation of the Coriolis Force

Lachezar S. Simeonov

2024-09-21

Abstract:The major difficulty when one teaches about non-inertial reference frames in undergraduate courses on Classical Mechanics is to find an intuitive way to derive the Coriolis acceleration. Indeed, there is a factor of 2 in the formula for the Coriolis acceleration and this factor is shrouded in mystery. In this paper we not only show an intuitive way to derive the Coriolis acceleration but we also show why there is a factor of 2. Indeed, it turns out that the Coriolis acceleration results from two completely different reasons (and hence the factor of 2). The first reason is this - as the particle moves to a new position, it `sees` a different local velocity of the rotating frame. The second reason is purely geometrical - the velocity vector is subjected to purely geometrical rotation due to the rotation of the reference frame. Both of these contributions unite and they result in the Coriolis acceleration.

Physics Education
A COROTATIONAL UPDATED LAGRANGIAN FORMULATION FOR GEOMETRICALLY NONLINEAR ANALYSIS OF 2D FRAMES

张年文,童根树

2009-01-01

Abstract:A method is presented for geometrically nonlinear analysis of 2D frames. An updated Lagrangian (UL) formulation is used to calculate the incremental nodal displacements, and incremental nodal forces are recovered by a corotational formulation whose configuration (Cr) is derived from a rigid-body motion of the last calculated configuration (C1) in equilibrium. Firstly, the equation of virtual work is expressed in terms of incremental nodal natural deformations in Cr; then, the relations are deduced between the incremental nodal natural deformations in Cr and the incremental nodal displacement vector in C1. Adopting the relations in the equation of virtual work, the tangent stiffness matrix for incremental nodal forces is obtained for Cr, and it can pass a rigid-body test. The analysis has considered the loaded deformations which will result in an additional matrix in the tangent stiffness matrix. The numerical examples show that: with fewer elements, the presented method can achieve similar precision to UL formulation; the matrix with respect to the loaded deformation can effectively improve the efficiency, but it may result in membrane locking if the deformation is large.
Non-inertial frames that can mimic gravitational fields

Dawood Kothawala

2024-11-16

Abstract:One version of the principle of equivalence, as originally formulated by Einstein, states that ``gravity" can be mimicked locally by going to an ``accelerated frame of reference". As highlighted by Synge, the physical content of this principle remains obscure in so far as it does not refer to the Riemann tensor $R_{abcd}$, which encodes the true effects of gravity. We here give the acceleration profile of a $Born$ rigid, Rindler$esque$, frame that can mimic a gravitational field corresponding to a given $R_{abcd}$. The generalised deviation equation that yields this result also has Centrifugal and Coriolis terms appearing in a purely relational context, yielding a similar connection between angular velocity of rotating, rigid inertial frames and the Riemann tensor. We comment briefly on implications for Mach principle.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology
Maximal acceleration in a Lorentz invariant non-commutative space-time

E. Harikumar,Suman Kumar Panja,Vishnu Rajagopal

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1140/epjp/s13360-022-03195-4

2022-02-14

Abstract:In this paper, we derive the non-commutative corrections to the maximal acceleration in the Doplicher-Fredenhagen-Roberts (DFR) space-time and show that the effect of the non-commutativity is to decrease the magnitude of the value of the maximal acceleration in the commutative limit. We also obtain an upper bound on the acceleration along the non-commutative coordinates using the positivity condition on the magnitude of the maximal acceleration in the commutative space-time. From the Newtonian limit of the geodesic equation and Einstein's equation for linearised gravity, we derive the explicit form of Newton's potential in DFR space-time. By expressing the non-commutative correction term of the maximal acceleration in terms of Newton's potential and applying the positivity condition, we obtain a lower bound on the radial distance between two particles under the gravitational attraction in DFR space-time. We also derive modified uncertainty relation and commutation relation between coordinates and its conjugate, due to the existence of maximal acceleration.

High Energy Physics - Theory
The Intrinsic Rigid Reference Frame with Constant Acceleration Moving along a Straight Line

LI Fu,ZHANG Rui

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1000-0712.2000.08.003

2000-01-01

Abstract:The intrinsic rigid reference frame with constant acceleration moving along a straight line is introduced.The transformation equations for the space-time coordinates connecting the rigid accelerating reference frame and the inertial reference frame are derived,and the characteristics of the rigid accelerating reference frame are analysed.
On reversal of centrifugal acceleration in special relativity

Maxim Lyutikov

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.0903.1113

2009-03-06

Abstract:The basic principles of General Theory of Relativity historically have been tested in gedanken experiments in rotating frame of references. One of the key issues, which still evokes a lot of controversy, is the centrifugal acceleration. Machabeli & Rogava (1994) argued that centrifugal acceleration reverse direction for particles moving radially with relativistic velocities within a "bead on a wire" approximation. We show that this result is frame-dependent and reflects a special relativistic dilution of time (as correctly argued by de Felice (1995)) and is analogous to freezing of motion on the black hole horizon as seen by a remote observer. It is a reversal of coordinate acceleration; there is no such effect as measured by a defined set of observers, e.g., proper and/or comoving. Frame-independent velocity of a "bead" with respect to stationary rotating observers increases and formally reaches the speed of light on the light cylinder. In general relativity, centrifugal force does reverse its direction at photon circular orbit, r=3M in Schwarzschild metric, as argued by Abramowicz (1990).

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena
An alternative to the Navier–Stokes equation based on the conservation of acceleration

Jean-Paul Caltagirone

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/jfm.2023.1017

IF: 3.7

2024-01-07

Journal of Fluid Mechanics

Abstract:The derivation of the Navier–Stokes equation in continuum mechanics leads to a number of consequences which are discussed in depth. In spite of its very high representativity of real flows, this equation presents some artefacts due to the whole notion of the continuous medium. An alternative to the Navier–Stokes equation is proposed, based on the conservation of energy per unit mass instead of momentum. The classical inertial frame of reference is replaced by a set of local frames of reference where interactions are treated as cause and effect. Invoking the principle of equivalence between energy and mass, the latter is eliminated from the quantities used in this new formalism. All quantities, variables and physical properties are thus expressed in units of mass. The law of motion is established in the form of the conservation of acceleration, an energy per unit of mass and length. The acceleration is thus written in the form of a Helmholtz–Hodge decomposition, in two terms, the first curl-free and the second divergence-free as a function of two potentials, scalar and vector. Maxwell's idea of federating the laws of electrodynamics and magnetism to establish electromagnetism is taken up here to establish the new law of motion as a nonlinear wave equation. This approach makes it possible to demonstrate that this law is relativistic from the start. The form of the equation of motion in two Lagrangians gives access to symmetries related to the conservation of certain quantities according to Noether's theorem.

mechanics,physics, fluids & plasmas
Numerical calculation of the relativistic acceleration of an electron in curved spacetime using the Dirac equation

J.D. Franson

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1602.02676

2016-02-09

Abstract:The relativistic acceleration of an electron in a uniform gravitational field is calculated numerically using the generalization of the Dirac equation to curved spacetime. Equivalent results are also obtained analytically using an iterative approach that is not based on the WKB approximation, which has been used extensively in the past. The acceleration is found to be proportional to a factor of $(1-3v^2/c^2)$ using Schwarzschild coordinates, which is consistent with the classical geodesic of a particle. These techniques may be useful in resolving the differences between commonly-used approximations.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,Quantum Physics
The illusion of acceleration in the retarded Lienard-Wiechert electromagnetic field

Calin Galeriu

2024-10-13

Abstract:It is generally assumed that the retarded Lienard-Wiechert electromagnetic field produced by a point particle depends on the acceleration of that source particle. This dependence is not real, it is an illusion. The true electromagnetic interaction is time symmetric (half retarded and half advanced) and depends only on the positions and velocities of the electrically charged particles. A different acceleration of the retarded source particle will result in a different position and velocity of the advanced source particle, changing in this way the Lorentz force felt by the test particle.

Classical Physics
Determining the difference between local acceleration and local gravity: applications of the equivalence principle to relativistic trajectories

Steven A. Balbus

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1119/5.0162082

2024-03-05

Abstract:We show by direct calculation that the common Equivalence Principle explanation for why gravity must deflect light is quantitatively incorrect by a factor of three in Schwarzschild geometry. It is therefore possible, at least as a matter of principle, to tell the difference between local acceleration and a true gravitational field by measuring the local deflection of light. We calculate as well the deflection of test particles of arbitrary energy, and construct a leading-order coordinate transformation from Schwarzschild to local inertial coordinates, which shows explicitly how the effects of spatial curvature manifest locally for relativistic trajectories of both finite and vanishing rest mass particles.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology
Relativistic acceleration in noninertial frames of a line of objects

Chris Dobson

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1119/5.0144523

IF: 0.835

2024-04-01

American Journal of Physics

Abstract:A general solution to the problem of relativistic acceleration of point objects in the noninertial frame of any of the objects is given in one spatial dimension. The objects are initially at rest in a common inertial frame and accelerate until they are at rest in a second inertial frame. The starting time and position of each object, the acceleration rate of each object, and the number of objects are arbitrary. The solution gives the position and velocity of each object in the noninertial frame of the host object, and the proper time of each, as functions of the proper time of the host. The method is based on system states for a pair of objects, and it is found that there are nine series of states which cover all cases, including those in which objects are separated from the host by its Rindler horizon. The familiar problems of acceleration of an elastic rod and a (Born) rigid rod are treated, and a number of examples are given of spaceflight sequences for multiple craft in tandem.

physics, multidisciplinary,education, scientific disciplines
Another derivation of Weinberg's formula

Zhi-Yong Wang,Cai-Dong Xiong

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physletb.2007.11.040

IF: 4.95

2008-01-01

Physics Letters B

Abstract:To investigate how quantum effects might modify special relativity, we will study a Lorentz transformation between classical and quantum reference frames and express it in terms of the four-dimensional (4D) momentum of the quantum reference frame. The transition from the classical expression of the Lorentz transformation to a quantum-mechanical one requires us to symmetrize the expression and replace all its dynamical variables with the corresponding operators, from which we can obtain the same conclusion as that from quantum field theory (given by Weinberg's formula): owing to the Heisenberg's uncertainty relation, a particle (as a quantum reference frame) can propagate over a spacelike interval.
Local Inertial Coordinate System and The Principle of Equivalence

Xin Zhang,Bin Xi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.0812.1268

2008-12-06

General Physics

Abstract:In this paper, the local inertial coordinate system is calculated through coordinate transformations from laboratory coordinate system. We derived the same free falling equations as those in General Relativity. However, the definitions of second and higher order covariant derivatives are different. Our results are different from the classic view of the principle of equivalence, and suggest that all the laws of physics in gravitational field can be given by doing coordinate transformations from local inertial coordinate system to lab coordinate system.
The Gravito-Maxwell Equations of General Relativity in the local reference frame of a GR-noninertial observer

Christoph Schmid

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1361-6382/acb3a8

2023-04-16

Abstract:We show that the acceleration-difference of neighboring free-falling particles (= geodesic deviation) measured in the local reference frame of a GR-noninertial observer is not given by the Riemann tensor. With the gravito-electric field of GR defined as the acceleration of free-falling quasistatic particles relative to the observer, the divergence of the gravito-electric field measured in the reference frame of a GR-noninertial observer is different from the Ricci curvature $R^0_{\,\,0}$. We derive our exact, explicit, and simple gravito-Gauss law for the divergence of the gravito-electric field in our new reference frame of a GR-noninertial observer with his LONB (Local Ortho-Normal Basis) and his LONB-connections in his time and 3-directions: the sources of the divergence of the gravito-electric field are contributed by all fields including the GR-gravitational fields, gravito-electric and gravito-magnetic. In the reference frame of a GR-inertial observer our gravito-Gauss law coincides with Einstein's $R^0_{\,\,0}$ equation, which does not have gravitational fields as sources. We derive the gravito-Ampere law, the gravito-Faraday law and the law for the divergence of the gravito-magnetic field. The densities of energy, momentum, and momentum-flow of GR-gravitational fields are local observables, but depend on observer with his local reference frame: these quantities are zero if measured by a GR-inertial observer. For a GR-noninertial observer the sources of gravitational energy, momentum, and momentum-flow densities have the opposite sign from the electromagnetic and matter sources. In the gravito-Gauss law the sources contributed by gravitational energy and momentum-flow densities have a repulsive effect on the gravitational acceleration-difference of particles.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology
Average Lorentz Self-Force From Electric Field Lines

Sandeep Aashish,Asrarul Haque

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/0143-0807/36/5/055012

2014-12-12

Abstract:We generalize the derivation of electromagnetic fields of a charged particle moving with a constant acceleration [1] to a variable acceleration (piecewise constants) over a small finite time interval using Coulomb's law, relativistic transformations of electromagnetic fields and Thomson's construction [2]. We derive the average Lorentz self-force for a charged particle in arbitrary non-relativistic motion via averaging the fields at retarded time.

Classical Physics
Non-relativistic transport from frame-indifferent kinetic theory

Paweł Matus,Rajesh Biswas,Piotr Surówka,Francisco Peña-Benítez

2024-07-12

Abstract:This paper explores the application of Newton-Cartan geometry to the kinetic theory of gases that includes non-relativistic gravitational effects and the principle of general covariance. Starting with an introduction to the basics of Newton-Cartan geometry, we examine the motion of point particles within this framework, leading to a detailed analysis of kinetic theory and the derivation of conservation equations. The equilibrium distribution function is explored, and the example of a rotating gas in a gravitational field is discussed. Further, we develop covariant hydrodynamic equations and extend our analysis through a gradient expansion approach to assess first-order constitutive relations for rotating gases. Finally, we address the frame-dependence paradox, presenting a novel resolution that addresses apparent discrepancies. Our construction resolves a fifty-year-old debate about the frame-indifferent formulation of kinetic theory. The resolution is presented in a modern, symmetry-based approach.

High Energy Physics - Theory,Statistical Mechanics,General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology
Lorentz Transformation and General Covariance Principle

Aleks Kleyn

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.0803.3276

2019-11-18

Abstract:I tell about different mathematical tool that is important in general relativity. The text of the book includes definition of geometrical object, concept of reference frame, geometry of metric-affinne manifold. Using this concept I learn few physical applications: dynamics and Lorentz transformation in gravitational fields, Doppler shift. A reference frame in event space is a smooth field of orthonormal bases. Every reference frame is equipped by anholonomic coordinates. Using anholonomic coordinates allows to find out relative speed of two observers and appropriate Lorentz transformation. Synchronization of a reference frame is an anholonomic time coordinate. Simple calculations show how synchronization influences time measurement in the vicinity of the Earth. Measurement of Doppler shift from the star orbiting the black hole helps to determine mass of the black hole. We call a manifold with torsion and nonmetricity the metric\hyph affine manifold. The nonmetricity leads to a difference between the auto parallel line and the extreme line, and to a change in the expression of the Frenet transport and moving basis. The torsion leads to a change in the Killing equation. We also need to add a similar equation for the connection. The analysis of the Frenet transport leads to the concept of the Cartan transport and an introduction of the connection compatible with the metric tensor. The dynamics of a particle follows to the Cartan transport. We need additional physical constraints to make a nonmetricity observable. Learning how torsion influences on tidal force reveals similarity between tidal equation for geodesic and the Killing equation of second type.

Mathematical Physics
Centrifugal force reversal from the perspective of rigidly rotating observer

Giorgi Dalakishvili

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1110.5504

2011-12-26

Abstract:In previous studies the dynamics of the relativistic particle moving along the rotating pipe was investigated. The simple gedanken experiment was considered. It was shown that at large enough velocities a centrifugal force acting on the bead changes its usual sign and attracts towards the rotation axis. The authors studied motion of the particle along the rotating straight pipe in the frame of the observer located in the center of rotation, also dynamics of centrifugally accelerated relativistic particle was studied in the laboratory frame. In the both cases it was shown that centrifugal force changes sign. Recently the problem was studied in the frame of stationary observers. It was argued that centrifugal acceleration reversal is not frame invariant effect. In the present paper we consider motion of particle along the rotating straight line in the frame of an arbitrary stationary observer located at certain distance form the center of rotation and rigidly rotating with constant angular velocity. It is shown that any stationary observer could detect reversal of centrifugal acceleration.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology
A Note on the Coordinate Freedom in Describing the Motion of Particles in General Relativity

Samuel E. Gralla,Robert M. Wald

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/0264-9381/28/17/177001

2011-04-28

Abstract:Our previous work developed a framework for treating the motion of a small body in general relativity, based on a one-parameter-family of solutions to Einstein's equation. Here we give an analysis of the coordinate freedom allowed within this framework, as is needed to determine the form of the equations of motion when they are expressed in general gauges.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology
Geometrically constrained particle dynamics revisited: Equation of motion in terms of the normal curvature of the constraint manifold

Wei-Han Hsiao

2024-01-05

Abstract:We revisit the problem of the particle dynamics subject to a geometric holonomic constraint of codimension 1 in spatial dimensions d =2 and 3. In the absence of dissipation, we show that by solving the Lagrangian multiplier in a general fashion, the external potential independent part, the net normal force, of the equation of motion corresponds to precisely to the curvature of the trajectory on the constraint space multiplied by twice the kinetic energy. The tangent the trajectory is the instantaneous velocity. In d = 3, this term equals the second fundamental form II of the constraint surface evaluated on the unit tangent vector in the direction of velocity. Using these result we establish the relation between constrained particle dynamics with geodesic equations and derive intriguing kinematic implications using theorems from fundamental differential geometry.

Classical Physics

A different derivation of the acceleration of a particle in a non-inertial reference frame

Intuitive Derivation of the Coriolis Force

A COROTATIONAL UPDATED LAGRANGIAN FORMULATION FOR GEOMETRICALLY NONLINEAR ANALYSIS OF 2D FRAMES

Non-inertial frames that can mimic gravitational fields

Maximal acceleration in a Lorentz invariant non-commutative space-time

The Intrinsic Rigid Reference Frame with Constant Acceleration Moving along a Straight Line

On reversal of centrifugal acceleration in special relativity

An alternative to the Navier–Stokes equation based on the conservation of acceleration

Numerical calculation of the relativistic acceleration of an electron in curved spacetime using the Dirac equation

The illusion of acceleration in the retarded Lienard-Wiechert electromagnetic field

Determining the difference between local acceleration and local gravity: applications of the equivalence principle to relativistic trajectories

Relativistic acceleration in noninertial frames of a line of objects

Another derivation of Weinberg's formula

Local Inertial Coordinate System and The Principle of Equivalence

The Gravito-Maxwell Equations of General Relativity in the local reference frame of a GR-noninertial observer

Average Lorentz Self-Force From Electric Field Lines

Non-relativistic transport from frame-indifferent kinetic theory

Lorentz Transformation and General Covariance Principle

Centrifugal force reversal from the perspective of rigidly rotating observer

A Note on the Coordinate Freedom in Describing the Motion of Particles in General Relativity

Geometrically constrained particle dynamics revisited: Equation of motion in terms of the normal curvature of the constraint manifold