Abstract:Robotic algorithms that augment movement errors have been proposed as promising training strategies to enhance motor learning and neurorehabilitation. However, most research effort has focused on rehabilitation of upper limbs, probably because large movement errors are especially dangerous during gait training, as they might result in stumbling and falling. Furthermore, systematic large movement errors might limit the participants' motivation during training. In this study, we investigated the effect of training with novel error modulating strategies, which guarantee a safe training environment, on motivation and learning of a modified asymmetric gait pattern. Thirty healthy young participants walked in the exoskeletal robotic system Lokomat while performing a foot target-tracking task, which required an increased hip and knee flexion in the dominant leg. Learning the asymmetric gait pattern with three different strategies was evaluated: (i) No disturbance: no robot disturbance/guidance was applied, (ii) haptic error amplification: unsafe and discouraging large errors were limited with haptic guidance, while haptic error amplification enhanced awareness of small errors relevant for learning, and (iii) visual error amplification: visually observed errors were amplified in a virtual reality environment. We also evaluated whether increasing the movement variability during training by adding randomly varying haptic disturbances on top of the other training strategies further enhances learning. We analyzed participants' motor performance and self-reported intrinsic motivation before, during and after training. We found that training with the novel haptic error amplification strategy did not hamper motor adaptation and enhanced transfer of the practiced asymmetric gait pattern to free walking. Training with visual error amplification, on the other hand, increased errors during training and hampered motor learning. Participants who trained with visual error amplification also reported a reduced perceived competence. Adding haptic disturbance increased the movement variability during training, but did not have a significant effect on motor adaptation, probably because training with haptic disturbance on top of visual and haptic error amplification decreased the participants' feelings of competence. The proposed novel haptic error modulating controller that amplifies small task-relevant errors while limiting large errors outperformed visual error augmentation and might provide a promising framework to improve robotic gait training outcomes in neurological patients.

Haptic guidance improves the visuo-manual tracking of trajectories

Tactile Apparent Movement As A Modality For Lower Limb Haptic Feedback

Real-time motion force-feedback system with predictive-vision for improving motor accuracy

A Haptic Shared Control Architecture for Tracking of a Moving Object.

Direct Comparisons of Upper-Limb Motor Learning Performance Among Three Types of Haptic Guidance With Non-Assisted Condition in Spiral Drawing Task

The Effect of Haptic Guidance during Robotic-assisted Motor Training is Modulated by Personality Traits

Haptic human-human interaction does not improve individual visuomotor adaptation

GuidingBand: Evaluating Speed, Precision and Accuracy of a Vibrotactile Hand Guidance System

Learning Effect in Joystick Tactile Guidance

Visual feedbacks influence short-term learning of torque versus motion profile with robotic guidance among young adults

Haptic Guidance and Haptic Error Amplification in a Virtual Surgical Robotic Training Environment

Haptic Error Modulation Outperforms Visual Error Amplification When Learning a Modified Gait Pattern

Haptic gait retraining: Evaluating learning environments for haptic motion training

Enhancing User Performance by Adaptively Changing Haptic Feedback Cues in a Fitts's Law Task

Holdable Haptic Device for 4-DOF Motion Guidance

Multi-Sensory Guidance and Feedback for Simulation-Based Training in Robot Assisted Surgery: A Preliminary Comparison of Visual, Haptic, and Visuo-Haptic

Eye tracking a self-moved target with complex hand-target dynamics

Training Induced Improvement on Human Perception of the Force Feedback Provided by A Soft Robotic Glove

Evaluating tactile feedback in addition to kinesthetic feedback for haptic shape rendering: a pilot study

Visuomotor control of intermittent circular tracking movements with visually guided orbits in 3D VR environment

A haptic guidance system for simulated catheter navigation with different kinaesthetic feedback profiles