The Impact of Indoor Environmental Quality on Occupant Satisfaction in Commercial Buildings: A Comparison of Building Expert Opinions and Residents' Experiences

Fatemeh Mokhtariyan Sorkhan,Soheil Roumi,Mohammad Soltanzadeh Zarandi,Mohammad Ali Ashraf Ganjouei

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/en17061473

IF: 3.2

2024-03-20

Energies

Abstract:This paper investigates the Indoor Environmental Quality (IEQ) factors influencing occupant satisfaction in commercial buildings in Iran, contrasting the views of building experts (architects and engineers) with those of building occupants. Employing the fuzzy analytical hierarchy process (FAHP), this study focuses on the four primary IEQ factors: thermal comfort, indoor air quality, visual comfort, and acoustic comfort. The study aims to bridge the gap between expert evaluations and occupant perceptions of IEQ factors in commercial buildings in Iran. By examining the disparities in prioritising IEQ factors between these two groups, the study sheds light on the complexities of IEQ assessment and highlights the importance of considering diverse perspectives in optimising indoor environments. Our methodology includes a survey conducted among 30 building experts (15 architects and 15 building engineers) and 102 occupants, employing FAHP to derive the relative importance weights of each IEQ factor. The results highlight significant disparities between architects, engineers, and occupants in prioritising these factors. Architects emphasise visual comfort (42%), while engineers and occupants view thermal comfort (53% and 41%) as the most crucial factor for occupant satisfaction. The study underscores the complexity of IEQ in commercial buildings and the diverse perspectives influencing its assessment. It contributes to the broader discourse on optimising IEQ, emphasising the need for a comprehensive approach that encompasses both technical expertise and occupant experience.

energy & fuels

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore the impact of indoor environmental quality (IEQ) on occupant satisfaction in commercial buildings and compare the views of building experts (architects and engineers) with those of occupants. Specifically, the research focuses on four main IEQ factors: thermal comfort, indoor air quality, visual comfort, and acoustic comfort. Through the comparison of these factors, the research aims to reveal the differences between expert evaluations and occupant perceptions, thereby emphasizing the importance of considering different perspectives when optimizing the indoor environment.

The research adopts the Fuzzy Analytic Hierarchy Process (FAHP) to determine the relative importance weights of each IEQ factor by surveying the opinions of 30 building experts (15 architects and 15 engineers) and 102 occupants. The research results show that architects attach more importance to visual comfort (accounting for 42%), while engineers and occupants consider thermal comfort to be the most crucial (accounting for 53% and 41% respectively). This indicates that there are significant perspective differences in the IEQ evaluation of commercial buildings, emphasizing the necessity of integrating technical expertise and occupant experiences.