Abstract:HANK YOU FOR forwarding to us the letter fromPressman and colleagues (2015) and for inviting ourresponse.The role of alcohol and its impact on sleep has been stud-ied for more than a century, and a substantial knowledgebase has been created. The studies, like most scientiﬁc stud-ies, are dependent on the technology available at the timeandtheavailabilityofdata.Thisissomethingwetookintoconsiderationwhenprepar-ing our qualitative review on the impact of alcohol on nor-malsleep.Theissuesraisedcanbesummarizedasfollows:1. The use of percentages to represent the diﬀerence inthe mean values of sleep architecture variables in ourtables,2. Our results and conclusions as they pertain to the impactofalcohol onslowwavesleep(SWS),3. Ourinclusion–exclusioncriteriaforstudies,and4. Alcohol, N3, sleepwalking, and medico-legal conse-quences.1. The use of the mean value as a percentage to representsleeparchitecturevariables:1.1. In our article, we made clear how we have presentedthedata:Valuesforsleep architecturevariablesareprovidedinper-centage terms only. Where the researchers have reportedsleep stage data in minutes we have converted these intopercentages. Some variables, such as sleep onset latencyand rapid eye movement onset latency are reported inminutes only. Only the mean value is displayed for allvariables in the tables to enable a uniform approachthroughout(Ebrahimet al.,2013).1.2. This was accepted by the Journal and the peerreviewers as this review was based on highlighting 2speciﬁcareas:1.2.1. The impact of various alcohol doses and their tim-ing on nocturnal sleep in healthy controls and nor-mal populations.1.2.2. The impact of these alcohol doses on various sleepstages.1.3. Asthis was a qualitative reviewand not a quantitativemeta-analysis, it was our aim to provide a broadunderstanding to the “nonsleep specialist”readershipoftheimpactofalcoholonsleep.1.4. Furthermore, in routine clinical practice, sleepstages are reported both in actual time and as apercentage of total sleep, a simple diﬀerence in themeans between alcohol and placebo nights wasthought to be the best way to demonstrate theeﬀect.2. Alcohol andSWS:2.1. Alcohol andﬁrsthalfofnightSWS(N3):2.1.1. Low dose alcohol studies—Of the 4 studiesreported, 2 showed a signiﬁcant increase in SWS(MacLean and Cairns, 1982; Van Reen et al., 2011)and the other 2 studies failed to ﬁnd a signiﬁcantdiﬀerence;2.1.2. Moderatedose studies—Ofthe 5 studies reported,2studies demonstrated a signiﬁcant increase in SWS(Roehrs et al., 1999; Williams et al., 1983). Theother3 studiesfailedtodemonstrateany signiﬁcantﬁndings;2.1.3. High dose studies—Five of the 9 studies reported astatistically signiﬁcant increase in SWS with alco-hol (Arnedt et al., 2011; Feige et al., 2006;MacLean and Cairns, 1982; Prinz et al., 1980; Wil-liams et al., 1983) and 4 studies did not show anysigniﬁcantdiﬀerences.The direction of evidence conﬁrms that at low and moder-ate doses alcohol is not clearly associated with increased

Fabrication Methods, Structural, Surface Morphology and Biomedical Applications of MXene: A Review

Synthesis and applications of double metal MXenes: A review

MXene/metal and polymer nanocomposites: Preparation, properties, and applications

Recent advances in MXenes: a future of nanotechnologies

Biomedical engineering of two-dimensional MXenes

MXenes Thin Films: From Fabrication to Their Applications

MXene/Polymer Nanocomposites: Preparation, Properties, and Applications

MXene: Evolutions in Chemical Synthesis and Recent Advances in Applications

MXene/0D nanocomposite architectures: Design, properties and emerging applications

Recent advances in MXene: Preparation, properties, and applications

Recent developments in MXene and MXene/carbon composites for use in biomedical applications

MXenes as Emerging Materials: Synthesis, Properties, and Applications

Alcohol and sleep review: sound statistics and valid conclusions.

Synthesis, structure, properties and applications of MXenes: Current status and perspectives

Scope, evaluation and current perspectives of MXene synthesis strategies for state of the art applications

Introduction to 2D MXenes: fundamental aspects, MAX phases and MXene derivatives, current challenges, and future prospects

Several Fundamental Aspects of MXene: Synthesis and Their Applications

MXene in the lens of biomedical engineering: synthesis, applications and future outlook

A comprehensive overview of recent progress in MXene-based polymer composites: Their fabrication processes, advanced applications, and prospects

Beyond Ti-based MXenes: A review of emerging non-Ti based metal-MXene structure, properties, and applications