Grain size from source to sink – modern and ancient fining rates
Tony Reynolds
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.earscirev.2024.104699
IF: 12.038
2024-02-03
Earth-Science Reviews
Abstract:A unique synthesis of grain size-distance data is presented, comparing, for the first time, grain size and fining trends in a wide range of modern and ancient axial sediment dispersal systems, and tracking grain-size from source to sink across several sedimentary basins. In general, grain-size decreases exponentially with distance down system, and modern and ancient examples fine at broadly comparable rates in similar depositional settings. Linear fining rates vary by eight orders of magnitude, being higher in coarser-grained settings. Very few data sets have a median grain size between 1 and 5 mm in diameter, supporting the idea that material of this calibre is rare. Alluvial fans fine at the highest rates, by up to 450 cm/km (216%/km) in modern and 115 cm/km (427%/km) in ancient examples, but more typically by around 1 to 12 mm/km (87 to 1%/km), whereas fluvial gravels fine by 0.8 to 4 mm/km (0.4 to 5%/km). Sand-prone systems fine more slowly, by a few tens of microns per kilometre or less: 1 to 23 μm/km (0.25 to 2.5%/km) in distributive fluvial systems, ~1 to 8 μm/km (~1 to 6%/km) in fluvio-deltaic channels, 0.2 to 44 μm/km (0.08 to 14%/km) in ergs, and from 0.45 to 29 μm/km (0.18 to 7%/km) in basin-plain turbidites. At the basin scale, fining rates increase where gravels pinch out down-system at the fluvial gravel-sand transition, and where sands pinch out at the toe of the shoreface. Modern fluvial gravel-sand transitions are relatively well characterised, with fining rates ranging from 71 to 0.2 mm/km (483 to 2%/km), and lower rates and wider transitions in wider, longer rivers, insights that appear applicable to the rock record. Downstream fining predominantly reflects selective deposition of coarser material and preferential transport of finer grains, with subsidence increasing fining rates as coarser grains are preferentially extracted up-dip to form stratigraphy. Across short segments, grain-size can increase down system as a result of winnowing, bypass, or lateral sediment input. Comminution is largely considered a secondary factor in rivers, but important in ergs, where lateral sediment input can overwhelm downstream fining effects, and grain-size sorting across dunes may obscure longer downwind trends. In deep water, when the slope is bypassed, basin-floor fans can fine at rates comparable to contemporaneous up-dip fluvial channels, by 30 μm/km (5%/km), but if sediment is deposited on the slope, fining rates increase (225 μm/km 75%/km) as distances are shorter. Axial flow lines across basin-plain turbidites with diverse grain-size, and dimension, can be closely comparable on mass-balance plots, suggesting that the properties of one bed could inform predictions of those of another. As yet there are no studies of fining rates in conglomeratic deep-water systems, where the transition from conglomerate to sand-dominated systems is of particular interest, given its importance for fining rates in fluvial systems. The dataset has potential to constrain computer simulation models of sediment calibre, and subsurface models that address, for example, aquifer flow, and petroleum migration.
geosciences, multidisciplinary