Abstract:Statement of problem Rehabilitation of elderly or medically compromised patients with an atrophied unilateral posterior maxillary ridge by an implant-supported prosthesis may be complicated by maxillary sinus pneumatization with insufficient bone for implant placement. Purpose This short-term clinical trial assessed clinical results of closed sinus lift and fixed prosthesis versus implant-assisted overdentures in the management of participants with atrophied distal extension maxillary ridges. Material and methods Forty participants with unilateral atrophying distal extension maxillary ridges were randomly assigned into 2 groups. The CSL group (n=20) participants received fixed prostheses supported by 3 implants following a closed sinus lift. The IOD group (n=20) participants received removable partial overdentures assisted by a single implant that was positioned mesially to the maxillary sinus. The modified plaque index (MPI), modified gingival index (MGI), pocket depth (PD), implant stability (IS), and vertical bone loss (VBL) were measured at prosthesis delivery (T0), and 6 (T6) and 12 months (T12) after delivery. The oral health impact profile (OHIP-14) questionnaire was used to assess oral health-related quality of life (OHRQoL) at T12. Significant differences between observation times were performed using Friedman and Wilcoxon signed-rank tests for MPI and MGI and using repeated measures ANOVA with Bonferroni correction of P values for PD, IS, VBL, and OHIP. Between-group comparison of MPI and MGI the Mann-Whitney test was used, while for PD, IS, VBL, and OHIP comparison was made using independent samples t test (α=.05 for all tests). Results The implant survival rates were 100% for both groups. MPI and PD significantly increased with time for both groups. MGI significantly increased with time for the CSL group only ( P =.049). The IS significantly decreased with time for the IOD group. VBL increased significantly from T6 to T12 for the CSL ( P =.042) and the IOD ( P =.002) groups. The CSL group recorded higher MPI, MGI, PD, and IS values than the IOD group ( P <.05). The IOD group recorded higher VBL than the CSL group ( P <.001 ). The CSL group scored significantly lower OHIP-14 values (better OHRQoL) than the IOD group for all values ( P <.05). Conclusions In comparison with implant-assisted partial overdentures, closed sinus lift with fixed prostheses had higher implant stability, reduced bone loss, and higher participant OHRQoL. However, peri-implant soft tissue health was found to be better with implant overdentures.

Ridge dimensional changes and implant stability utilizing the osseodensification protocol: A randomized clinical trial

Osseodensification effect on implants primary and secondary stability: Multicenter controlled clinical trial

The Effectiveness of Osseodensification Drilling versus the Conventional Surgical Technique on Implant Stability: A Clinical Trial

Changes in implant stability using different site preparation techniques: Osseodensification drills versus piezoelectric surgery. A multi‐center prospective randomized controlled clinical trial

Effect of Densah Burs on Primary and Secondary Stability of Immediately Loaded Implants in Addition to Crestal Bone Loss and Gingival Probing Depth - An Evaluative Study

Alveolar ridge dimensional changes following ridge preservation procedure using SocketKAP(™) : exploratory study of serial cone-beam computed tomography and histologic analysis in canine model

Three-dimensional analysis of bone remodeling following ridge augmentation of compromised extraction sockets in periodontitis patients: A randomized controlled study

An open randomized controlled clinical trial to evaluate ridge preservation and repair using SocketKAP(™) and SocketKAGE(™) : part 2 - three-dimensional alveolar bone volumetric analysis of CBCT imaging

Ridge preservation in maxillary molar extraction sites with severe periodontitis: a prospective observational clinical trial

Alveolar ridge dimensional changes following ridge preservation procedure with novel devices: Part 1--CBCT linear analysis in non-human primate model

[Radiographic Evaluation of Ridge Preservation after Molar Tooth Extraction: a Controlled Clinical Trial].

Histologic and Clinical Evaluation of Ridge Augmentation of Extraction Sockets with Severe Bone Defects: A Clinical Prospective Study

Competence of allogenic demineralized tooth matrix in socket seal surgery for alveolar ridge preservation: a randomized control clinical trial

Evaluation of Alveolar Ridge Dimensions by Socket Preservation Therapy Using a Bone Graft and Platelet-Rich Fibrin: A Randomized Controlled Trial

Long-term preservation of ridge dimension following tooth extraction and ridge preservation: A randomized controlled trial of healing at 4- and 12-month healing time points

Soft tissue contour and radiographic evaluation of ridge preservation in early implant placement: A randomized controlled clinical trial

Short Versus Longer Implants with Osteotome Sinus Floor Elevation for Moderately Atrophic Posterior Maxillae: A 1-Year Randomized Clinical Trial.

The Assessment of Volumetric Changes for Alveolar Ridge Preservation or Reconstruction by Three-dimensional Analysis at Posterior Extraction Sites with Severe Bone Defects Using DBBM-C Collagen Membrane and PRF: A Prospective and Randomized Clinical Trial

Alveolar Ridge Preservation Using a Collagenated Xenograft: A Randomized Clinical Trial

Closed sinus lift and fixed prostheses versus implant-assisted overdentures in management of atrophied distal extension maxillary ridges: A one-year randomized clinical trial

Efficacy of Autogenous Dentin Biomaterial on Alveolar Ridge Preservation: A Randomized Controlled Clinical Trial