Abstract:Despite denials by proponents of intelligent design (ID) that ID is creationism, critical analysis by scientists and scholars, as well as statements by the proponents of ID themselves, has established beyond any doubt ID's true identity as neo-creationism. Despite de-emphasizing elements of earlier creationism such as belief in a young earth and "flood geology," ID bears marks of its descent from "creation science" and is defined by its leading proponents in overtly religious, and specifically Christian, terms. These facts enabled the plaintiffs in the first ID legal case, Kitzmiller et al. v. Dover Area School District (2005), to win a decisive victory over the Dover, PA, school board, which had required that a pro-ID statement be read to biology students at Dover High School. Kitzmiller was also a defeat for ID proponents at the Discovery Institute's Center for Science and Culture (CSC). Yet, although the CSC continues efforts to undermine the teaching of evolution even in the wake of this defeat, their tactics are increasingly stale and transparent. Their current strategy, disguising pro-ID policy proposals with code language to avoid using the term "intelligent design," is yet another tactic used by earlier creationists after consistent legal defeats. Moreover, the ID movement's continued execution of their agenda has enabled ID critics to compile an ever-lengthening list of further congruencies between ID and creation science. Such powerful evidence of ID's identity as neo-creationism, combined with modest but promising demographic changes in the United States, suggest that increased public support for teaching evolution is possible through effective outreach to the relevant demographic groups. Scientists must take advantage of this opportunity to cultivate such support and to counteract ID by engaging in pro-science activism, making use of the many resources available to support their efforts.

An In-Class Discussion Activity on the Nature of Science and Intelligent Design

Using ethological techniques and place-based pedagogy to develop science literacy in Hawaiʻi’s high school students

Teaching evolution: Understanding and applying the nature of science

Primary Physical Science for Student Teachers at Kindergarten and Primary School Levels: Part II—Implementation and Evaluation of a Course

Redesigning a General Education Science Course to Promote Critical Thinking

Teaching and Learning of Nature of Scientific Knowledge and Scientific Inquiry: Building Capacity through Systematic Research-Based Professional Development

Designing and Applying an Argument-Driven Inquiry Instructional Model in the Teaching of History of Science for Pre-Service Science Teachers

Inquiry-Based Teaching in the College Classroom: The Nontraditional Student

Science, Religion and the Teaching of Evolution

Teaching nature of science in introductory biology: Impacts on students’ acceptance of biological evolution

Classroom Discourse and Teacher-Student Interactions during the Enactment of Evolution and Human Genetics Units in a Rural High School: A Case Study of a Biology Teacher

Still creationism after all these years: understanding and counteracting intelligent design

Investigating the Design--Science Connection in a multi-week Engineering Design (ED)-based introductory physics laboratory task

How do we do this: learning how to teach socioscientific issues

Ideas About the Nature of Science Held by Undergraduate Atmospheric Science Students

Teaching the Nature of Science Improves Scientific Literacy Among Students Not Majoring in STEM

Making Science Personal: Inclusivity-Driven Design for General-Education Courses

Curriculum Integration: Challenging the Assumption of School Science as Powerful Knowledge

A Progressive Reading, Writing, and Artistic Module to Support Scientific Literacy

Understanding How Students Use Physical Ideas in Introductory Biology Courses

Teachers’ use of educative curriculum materials to engage students in science practices