Abstract:We reply to the comment by Andreotti and Claudin (submitted to Phys. Rev. E, <a class="link-https" data-arxiv-id="0705.3525" href="https://arxiv.org/abs/0705.3525">arXiv:0705.3525</a>) on our paper ``Minimal Size of a Barchan Dune'' [Phys. Rev. E {\bf{75,}} 011301 (2007)]. We show that the equations of the dune model used in our calculations are self-consistent and effectively lead to a dependence of the minimal dune size on the wind speed through the saturation length. Furthermore, we show that Meridiani Planum ripples are probably not a good reference to estimate the grain size of Martian dune sands: the soil in the ripple troughs at the landing site is covered with nonerodible elements (``blueberries''), which increase the minimal threshold for saltation by a factor of 2.0. We conclude that, in the absence of large fragments as the ones found at the landing site, basaltic grains of diameter $d=500 \pm 100 {\mu}$m that compose the large, typical dark Martian dunes [K. S. Edgett and P. R. Christensen, J. Geophys. Res. {\bf{96,}} 22765 (1991)] probably saltate during the strongest storms on Mars. We also show that the wind friction speed $u_{\ast} \approx 3.0$ m/s that we found from the calculations of Martian dunes is within the values of maximum wind speeds that occur during Martian storms a few times a decade [R. E. Arvidson {\em{et al.}}, Science {\bf{222,}} 463 (1983); H. J. Moore, J. Geophys. Res. {\bf{90,}} 163 (1985); R. Sullivan {\em{et al.}}, Nature {\bf{436,}} 58 (2005); D. J. Jerolmack {\em{et al.}}, J. Geophys. Res. {\bf{111,}} E12S02 (2006)]. In this manner, the dune model predicts that Martian dunes can be formed under present Martian conditions, with no need to assume other conditions of wind and atmosphere that could have prevailed in the past.

Comment on "Minimal size of a barchan dune"

Reply to "Comment on `Minimal size of a barchan dune' "

Corridors of barchan dunes: stability and size selection

Minimal model for aeolian sand dunes

Elongation and stability of a linear dune

Dynamic scaling of desert dunes

Measurements of the aeolian sand transport saturation length

On the shape of barchan dunes

From lab to landscape-scale experiments for the morphodynamics of sand dunes

Orange proteomic fingerprinting: From fruit to commercial juices.

Particle dynamics of a cartoon dune

Modeling the large-scale structure of a barchan dune field

Selection of dune shapes and velocities. Part 1: Dynamics of sand, wind and barchans

Temporal Evolution of Dune Number Density in a Barchan Dune Field

A model of Barchan dunes including lateral shear stress

Size‐dependent asymmetry of barchans indicates dune growth controlled by basal area or bulk volume

Two-fold stratification of aeolian transport and its implication for planetary bedforms

Barchan dune corridors: Field characterization and investigation of control parameters

Reproducing size distributions of swarms of barchan dunes on Mars and Earth using a mean-field model

A Continuum Saltation Model for Sand Dunes

Discrete Element Method simulations of the saturation of aeolian sand transport