Mathematical model of interest matchmaking in electronic social networks

Andreas de Vries

DOI: https://doi.org/10.4236/am.2014.516250

2007-03-24

Abstract:The problem of matchmaking in electronic social networks is formulated as an optimization problem. In particular, a function measuring the matching degree of fields of interest of a search profile with those of an advertising profile is proposed.

Computers and Society,Artificial Intelligence

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

OptMatch

Linxia Gong,Grace Ndeezi,Dezhi Ye,Hao Li,Runze Wu,Jianrong Tao,Changjie Fan,Peng Cui

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1145/3394486.3403279

2020-01-01

Abstract:Matchmaking is a core problem for the e-sports and online games, which determines the player satisfaction and further influences the life cycle of the gaming products. Most of matchmaking systems take the form of grouping the queuing players into two opposing teams by following certain rules. The design and implementation of matchmaking systems are usually product-specific and labor-intensive.
Price of Anarchy in Algorithmic Matching of Romantic Partners

Andrés Abeliuk,Khaled Elbassioni,Talal Rahwan,Manuel Cebrian,Iyad Rahwan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1901.03192

2019-02-16

Abstract:Algorithmic-matching sites offer users access to an unprecedented number of potential mates. However, they also pose a principal-agent problem with a potential moral hazard. The agent's interest is to maximize usage of the Web site, while the principal's interest is to find the best possible romantic partners. This creates a conflict of interest: optimally matching users would lead to stable couples and fewer singles using the site, which is detrimental for the online dating industry. Here, we borrow the notion of Price-of-Anarchy from game theory to quantify the decrease in social efficiency of online dating sites caused by the agent's self-interest. We derive theoretical bounds on the price-of-anarchy, showing it can be bounded by a constant that does not depend on the number of users of the dating site. This suggests that as online dating sites grow, their potential benefits scale up without sacrificing social efficiency. Further, we performed experiments involving human subjects in a matching market, and compared the social welfare achieved by an optimal matching service against a self-interest matching algorithm. We show that by introducing competition among dating sites, the selfish behavior of agents aligns with its users, and social efficiency increases.

Computer Science and Game Theory,Computers and Society,Social and Information Networks
Social Networks and Stable Matchings in the Job Market

Esteban Arcaute,Sergei Vassilvitskii

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.0910.0916

2009-10-06

Computer Science and Game Theory

Abstract:For most people, social contacts play an integral part in finding a new job. As observed by Granovetter's seminal study, the proportion of jobs obtained through social contacts is usually large compared to those obtained through postings or agencies. At the same time, job markets are a natural example of two-sided matching markets. An important solution concept in such markets is that of stable matchings, and the use of the celebrated Gale-Shapley algorithm to compute them. So far, the literature has evolved separately, either focusing on the implications of information flowing through a social network, or on developing a mathematical theory of job markets through the use of two-sided matching techniques. In this paper we provide a model of the job market that brings both aspects of job markets together. To model the social scientists' observations, we assume that workers learn only about positions in firms through social contacts. Given that information structure, we study both static properties of what we call locally stable matchings (i.e., stable matchings subject to informational constraints given by a social network) and dynamic properties through a reinterpretation of Gale-Shapley's algorithm as myopic best response dynamics. We prove that, in general, the set of locally stable matching strictly contains that of stable matchings and it is in fact NP-complete to determine if they are identical. We also show that the lattice structure of stable matchings is in general absent. Finally, we focus on myopic best response dynamics inspired by the Gale-Shapley algorithm. We study the efficiency loss due to the informational constraints, providing both lower and upper bounds.
An ODE Model for Dynamic Matching in Heterogeneous Networks

Xiaowu Dai,Hengzhi He

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2302.09757

2023-03-08

Abstract:We study the problem of dynamic matching in heterogeneous networks, where agents are subject to compatibility restrictions and stochastic arrival and departure times. In particular, we consider networks with one type of easy-to-match agents and multiple types of hard-to-match agents, each subject to its own compatibility constraints. Such a setting arises in many real-world applications, including kidney exchange programs and carpooling platforms. We introduce a novel approach to modeling dynamic matching by establishing the ordinary differential equation (ODE) model, which offers a new perspective for evaluating various matching algorithms. We study two algorithms, namely the Greedy and Patient Algorithms, where both algorithms prioritize matching compatible hard-to-match agents over easy-to-match agents in heterogeneous networks. Our results demonstrate the trade-off between the conflicting goals of matching agents quickly and optimally, offering insights into the design of real-world dynamic matching systems. We provide simulations and a real-world case study using data from the Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network to validate theoretical predictions.

Machine Learning
A Model about Love in Human Dynamics

Bin Zhou,Shujia Qin,Xiao-Pu Han,Bing-Hong Wang

2013-01-01

Abstract:We propose a model of two-way selection system. It appears in the processes like choosing a mate between men and women, making contracts between job hunters and recruiters, and trading between buyers and sellers. In this paper, we propose a model of two-way selection system, and present its analytic solution for the expectation of successful matching total and the regular pattern that the matching rate trends toward an inverse proportion to either the ratio between the two sides or the ratio of the state total to the smaller people number. The proposed model is verified by empirical data of the matchmaking fairs. Results indicate that the model well predicts this typical real-world two- way selection behavior to the bounded error extent, thus it is helpful for understanding the dynamics mechanism of the real-world two-way selection system.
Influence network design via multi-level optimization considering boundedly rational user behaviours in social media networks

Guanxiang Yun,Qipeng P. Zheng,Vladimir Boginski,Eduardo L. Pasiliao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s40649-020-00082-9

2021-02-08

Computational Social Networks

Abstract:Abstract Social media networks have been playing an increasingly more important role for both socialization and information diffusion. Political campaign can gain more supporters by attracting more mass attention and influencing them directly, while commercial campaigns can increase their companies’ profits by expanding social media connection with new users. To build the optimal network structure to influence the whole, this paper studies mathematical models to simulate the users’ behaviours interacting with others in the information provider’s network. The behaviours of concerns include information re-posting and following/unfollowing other users. Linear threshold propagation model is used to determine the re-posting actions, Boundedly Rational User Equilibrium (BRUE) models are used to determine the following or unfollowing actions. Hence, the topology of the network changes and depends on the information provider’s plan to post various kinds of information. A three-level optimization model is proposed to maximize total number of connections, the goal of the top level. The second level simulates user behaviours under BRUE. The third level maximizes the each user’s utility defined in the second level. This paper solves this problem using exact algorithms for a small-scale synthetic network. For a large-scale problem, this paper uses heuristic algorithms based on large neighbourhood search. This paper also discusses possible reasons why the BRUE model may be a more accurate simulation of users’ actions compared to game theory. Comparisons from the BRUE model to game theoretical model show that the BRUE model performs significantly better than game theoretical model.
Exploring Trade-Offs for Online Mental Health Matching: Agent-Based Modeling Study

Yuhan Liu,Anna Fang,Glen Moriarty,Cristopher Firman,Robert E Kraut,Haiyi Zhu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2196/58241

2024-10-01

Abstract:Background: Online mental health communities (OMHCs) are an effective and accessible channel to give and receive social support for individuals with mental and emotional issues. However, a key challenge on these platforms is finding suitable partners to interact with given that mechanisms to match users are currently underdeveloped or highly naive. Objective: In this study, we collaborated with one of the world's largest OMHCs; our contribution is to show the application of agent-based modeling for the design of online community matching algorithms. We developed an agent-based simulation framework and showcased how it can uncover trade-offs in different matching algorithms between people seeking support and volunteer counselors. Methods: We used a comprehensive data set spanning January 2020 to April 2022 to create a simulation framework based on agent-based modeling that replicates the current matching mechanisms of our research site. After validating the accuracy of this simulated replication, we used this simulation framework as a "sandbox" to test different matching algorithms based on the deferred acceptance algorithm. We compared trade-offs among these different matching algorithms based on various metrics of interest, such as chat ratings and matching success rates. Results: Our study suggests that various tensions emerge through different algorithmic choices for these communities. For example, our simulation uncovered that increased waiting time for support seekers was an inherent consequence on these sites when intelligent matching was used to find more suitable matches. Our simulation also verified some intuitive effects, such as that the greatest number of support seeker-counselor matches occurred using a "first come, first served" protocol, whereas relatively fewer matches occurred using a "last come, first served" protocol. We also discuss practical findings regarding matching for vulnerable versus overall populations. Results by demographic group revealed disparities-underaged and gender minority groups had lower average chat ratings and higher blocking rates on the site when compared to their majority counterparts, indicating the potential benefits of algorithmically matching them. We found that some protocols, such as a "filter"-based approach that matched vulnerable support seekers only with a counselor of their same demographic, led to improvements for these groups but resulted in lower satisfaction (-12%) among the overall population. However, this trade-off between minority and majority groups was not observed when using "topic" as a matching criterion. Topic-based matching actually outperformed the filter-based protocol among underaged people and led to significant improvements over the status quo among all minority and majority groups-specifically, a 6% average chat rating improvement and a decrease in blocking incidents from 5.86% to 4.26%. Conclusions: Agent-based modeling can reveal significant design considerations in the OMHC context, including trade-offs in various outcome metrics and the potential benefits of algorithmic matching for marginalized communities.
Mathematical modeling of competition in sponsored search market

Jerry J. Liu,Dah Ming Chiu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1145/1879082.1879096

2010-01-01

Abstract:Sponsored search mechanisms have drawn much attention from both academic community and industry in recent years since the seminal papers of [3] and [4]. However, most of the existing literature concentrates on the mechanism design and analysis within the scope of only one search engine in the market. In this paper we propose a mathematical framework for modeling the interaction of publishers, advertisers and end users in a competitive market. We study the competition between two search engines as a three-stage dynamic game and prove the existence of Nash equilibrium prices when allowing advertisers to participate in both advertising systems simultaneously. To compare the expected revenues and social welfare under competition and monopoly, we carry out extensive simulation under common parameter setting of participants. Our results can provide useful insight in regulating the sponsored search market and protecting the interests of advertisers and end users.
Stable Matchings in Metric Spaces: Modeling Real-World Preferences using Proximity

Hossein Karkeh Abadi,Balaji Prabhakar

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1710.05262

2017-10-15

Abstract:Suppose each of $n$ men and $n$ women is located at a point in a metric space. A woman ranks the men in order of their distance to her from closest to farthest, breaking ties at random. The men rank the women similarly. An interesting problem is to use these ranking lists and find a stable matching in the sense of Gale and Shapley. This problem formulation naturally models preferences in several real world applications; for example, dating sites, room renting/letting, ride hailing and labor markets. Two key questions that arise in this setting are: (a) When is the stable matching unique without resorting to tie breaks? (b) If $X$ is the distance between a randomly chosen stable pair, what is the distribution of $X$ and what is $E(X)$? We study dating sites and ride hailing as prototypical examples of stable matchings in discrete and continuous metric spaces, respectively. In the dating site model, each person is assigned to a point on the $k$-dimensional hypercube based on their answers to a set of binary $k$ questions. We consider two different metrics on the hypercube: Hamming and Weighted Hamming. Under both metrics, there are exponentially many stable matchings when $k = \lfloor\log n\rfloor$. There is a unique stable matching, with high probability, under the Hamming distance when $k = \Omega(n^6)$, and under the Weighted Hamming distance when $k > (2+\epsilon) \log n$ for some $\epsilon>0$. In the ride hailing model, passengers and cabs are modeled as points on the line and matched based on Euclidean distance. Assuming the locations of the passengers and cabs are independent Poisson processes of different intensities, we derive bounds on the distribution of $X$ in terms of busy periods at a last-come-first-served preemptive-resume (LCFS-PR) queue.

Computer Science and Game Theory
When Online Dating Meets Nash Social Welfare: Achieving Efficiency and Fairness.

Yongzheng Jia,Xue Liu,Wei Xu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1145/3178876.3186109

2018-01-01

Abstract:Mobile dating applications such as Coffee Meets Bagel, Tantan, and Tinder, have become significant for young adults to meet new friends and discover romantic relationships. From a system designer's perspective, in order to achieve better user experience in these applications, we should take both the efficiency and fairness of a dating market into consideration, so as to increase the overall satisfaction for all users. Towards this goal, we investigate the nature of diminishing marginal returns for online dating markets (i.e., captured by the submodularity), and trade-off between the efficiency and fairness of the market with Nash social welfare. We further design effective online algorithms to the apps. We verify our models and algorithms through sound theoretical analysis and empirical studies by using real data and show that our algorithms can significantly improve the ecosystems of the online dating applications.
Two-Sided Random Matching Markets: Ex-Ante Equivalence of the Deferred Acceptance Procedures

Simon Mauras

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1145/3391403.3399448

2020-05-18

Abstract:Stable matching in a community consisting of $N$ men and $N$ women is a classical combinatorial problem that has been the subject of intense theoretical and empirical study since its introduction in 1962 in a seminal paper by Gale and Shapley. When the input preference profile is generated from a distribution, we study the output distribution of two stable matching procedures: women-proposing-deferred-acceptance and men-proposing-deferred-acceptance. We show that the two procedures are ex-ante equivalent: that is, under certain conditions on the input distribution, their output distributions are identical. In terms of technical contributions, we generalize (to the non-uniform case) an integral formula, due to Knuth and Pittel, which gives the probability that a fixed matching is stable. Using an inclusion-exclusion principle on the set of rotations, we give a new formula which gives the probability that a fixed matching is the women/men-optimal stable matching. We show that those two probabilities are equal with an integration by substitution.

Computer Science and Game Theory,Discrete Mathematics,Data Structures and Algorithms,Theoretical Economics
Social Networks and the Choices People Make

Jeremy Chen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1402.3138

2014-02-13

Social and Information Networks

Abstract:Social marketing is becoming increasingly important in contemporary business. Central to social marketing is quantifying how consumers choose between alternatives and how they influence each other. This work considers a new but simple multinomial choice model for multiple agents connected in a recommendation network based on the explicit modeling of choice adoption behavior. Efficiently computable closed-form solutions, absent from analyses of threshold/cascade models, are obtained together with insights on how the network affects aggregate decision making. A stylized "brand ambassador" selection problem is posed to model targeting in social marketing. Therein, it is shown that a greedy selection strategy leads to solutions achieving at least $1-1/e$ of the optimal value. In an extended example of imposing exogenous controls, a pricing problem is considered wherein it is shown that the single player profit optimization problem is concave, implying the existence of pure strategy equilibria for the associated pricing game.
Online Elicitation of Necessarily Optimal Matchings

Jannik Peters

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2112.04227

2021-12-08

Abstract:In this paper, we study the problem of eliciting preferences of agents in the house allocation model. For this we build on a recent model of Hosseini et al.[AAAI'21] and focus on the task of eliciting preferences to find matchings which are necessarily optimal, i.e., optimal under all possible completions of the elicited preferences. In particular, we follow the approach of Hosseini et al. and investigate the elicitation of necessarily Pareto optimal (NPO) and necessarily rank-maximal (NRM) matchings. Most importantly, we answer their open question and give an online algorithm for eliciting an NRM matching in the next-best query model which is 3/2-competitive, i.e., it takes at most 3/2 as many queries as an optimal algorithm. Besides this, we extend this field of research by introducing two new natural models of elicitation and by studying both the complexity of determining whether a necessarily optimal matching exists in them, and by giving online algorithms for these models.

Computer Science and Game Theory,Data Structures and Algorithms
Designing Approximately Optimal Search on Matching Platforms

Nicole Immorlica,Brendan Lucier,Vahideh Manshadi,Alexander Wei

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2102.09017

2021-08-19

Abstract:We study the design of a decentralized two-sided matching market in which agents' search is guided by the platform. There are finitely many agent types, each with (potentially random) preferences drawn from known type-specific distributions. Equipped with knowledge of these distributions, the platform guides the search process by determining the meeting rate between each pair of types from the two sides. Focusing on symmetric pairwise preferences in a continuum model, we first characterize the unique stationary equilibrium that arises given a feasible set of meeting rates. We then introduce the platform's optimal directed search problem, which involves optimizing meeting rates to maximize equilibrium social welfare. We first show that incentive issues arising from congestion and cannibalization make the design problem fairly intricate. Nonetheless, we develop an efficiently computable search design whose corresponding equilibrium achieves at least 1/4 the social welfare of the optimal design. In fact, our construction always recovers at least 1/4 the first-best social welfare, where agents' incentives are disregarded. Our directed search design is simple and easy-to-implement, as its corresponding bipartite graph consists of disjoint stars. Furthermore, our design implies the platform can substantially limit choice and yet induce an equilibrium with an approximately optimal welfare. Finally, we show that approximation is likely the best we can hope for by establishing that the problem of designing optimal directed search is NP-hard to even approximate beyond a certain constant factor.

Computer Science and Game Theory
Advertising Competitions in Social Networks

Antonia Masucci,Alonso Silva

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1608.02774

2016-08-09

Abstract:In the present work, we study the advertising competition of several marketing campaigns who need to determine how many resources to allocate to potential customers to advertise their products through direct marketing while taking into account that competing marketing campaigns are trying to do the same. Potential customers rank marketing campaigns according to the offers, promotions or discounts made to them. Taking into account the intrinsic value of potential customers as well as the peer influence that they exert over other potential customers we consider the network value as a measure of their importance in the market and we find an analytical expression for <a class="link-external link-http" href="http://it.We" rel="external noopener nofollow">this http URL</a> analyze the marketing campaigns competition from a game theory point of view, finding a closed form expression of the symmetric equilibrium offer strategy for the marketing campaigns from which no campaign has any incentive to deviate. We also present several scenarios, such as Winner-takes-all and Borda, but not the only possible ones for which our results allow us to retrieve in a simple way the corresponding equilibrium strategy.

Computer Science and Game Theory
Online Algorithms for Matching Platforms with Multi-Channel Traffic

Vahideh Manshadi,Scott Rodilitz,Daniela Saban,Akshaya Suresh

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2203.15037

2023-08-02

Abstract:Two-sided platforms rely on their recommendation algorithms to help visitors successfully find a match. However, on platforms such as VolunteerMatch (VM) -- which has facilitated millions of connections between volunteers and nonprofits -- a sizable fraction of website traffic arrives directly to a nonprofit's volunteering page via an external link, thus bypassing the platform's recommendation algorithm. We study how such platforms should account for this external traffic in the design of their recommendation algorithms, given the goal of maximizing successful matches. We model the platform's problem as a special case of online matching, where (using VM terminology) volunteers arrive sequentially and probabilistically match with one opportunity, each of which has finite need for volunteers. In our framework, external traffic is interested only in their targeted opportunity; by contrast, internal traffic may be interested in many opportunities, and the platform's online algorithm selects which opportunity to recommend. In evaluating different algorithms, we parameterize the competitive ratio based on the amount of external traffic. After demonstrating the shortcomings of a commonly-used algorithm that is optimal in the absence of external traffic, we propose a new algorithm -- Adaptive Capacity (AC) -- which accounts for matches differently based on whether they originate from internal or external traffic. We provide a lower bound on AC's competitive ratio that is increasing in the amount of external traffic and that is close to (and, in some regimes, exactly matches) the parameterized upper bound we establish on the competitive ratio of any online algorithm. We complement our theoretical results with a numerical study motivated by VM data that demonstrates the strong performance of AC and furthers our understanding of the difference between AC and other commonly-used algorithms.

Computer Science and Game Theory
Matching with Trade-offs: Revealed Preferences over Competing Characteristics

Alfred Galichon,Bernard Salanié

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2102.12811

2021-02-25

Abstract:We investigate in this paper the theory and econometrics of optimal matchings with competing criteria. The surplus from a marriage match, for instance, may depend both on the incomes and on the educations of the partners, as well as on characteristics that the analyst does not observe. Even if the surplus is complementary in incomes, and complementary in educations, imperfect correlation between income and education at the individual level implies that the social optimum must trade off matching on incomes and matching on educations. Given a flexible specification of the surplus function, we characterize under mild assumptions the properties of the set of feasible matchings and of the socially optimal matching. Then we show how data on the covariation of the types of the partners in observed matches can be used to test that the observed matches are socially optimal for this specification, and to estimate the parameters that define social preferences over matches.

General Economics
Online Matching in Geometric Random Graphs

Flore Sentenac,Nathan Noiry,Matthieu Lerasle,Laurent Ménard,Vianney Perchet

2024-10-25

Abstract:We investigate online maximum cardinality matching, a central problem in ad allocation. In this problem, users are revealed sequentially, and each new user can be paired with any previously unmatched campaign that it is compatible with. Despite the limited theoretical guarantees, the greedy algorithm, which matches incoming users with any available campaign, exhibits outstanding performance in practice. Some theoretical support for this practical success was established in specific classes of graphs, where the connections between different vertices lack strong correlations - an assumption not always valid. To bridge this gap, we focus on the following model: both users and campaigns are represented as points uniformly distributed in the interval $[0,1]$, and a user is eligible to be paired with a campaign if they are similar enough, i.e. the distance between their respective points is less than $c/N$, with $c>0$ a model parameter. As a benchmark, we determine the size of the optimal offline matching in these bipartite random geometric graphs. In the online setting and investigate the number of matches made by the online algorithm closest, which greedily pairs incoming points with their nearest available neighbors. We demonstrate that the algorithm's performance can be compared to its fluid limit, which is characterized as the solution to a specific partial differential equation (PDE). From this PDE solution, we can compute the competitive ratio of closest, and our computations reveal that it remains significantly better than its worst-case guarantee. This model turns out to be related to the online minimum cost matching problem, and we can extend the results to refine certain findings in that area of research. Specifically, we determine the exact asymptotic cost of closest in the $\epsilon$-excess regime, providing a more accurate estimate than the previously known loose upper bound.

Data Structures and Algorithms
Modeling and Simulation of Network Public Opinion Propagation Model Based on Interest Matching in Social Network

Zhang Deliang,Bin Sheng,Sun Gengxin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-24265-7_35

2019-01-01

Abstract:AbstractBy using a variety of explicit or implicit relationships in social networks, we can reproduce the real propagation process of network public opinion in the social network from the perspective of complex networks. The relation of users and the data of microblog content in Sina microblog was obtained by programming and web crawler, multiple relationships between microblog users were discovered by using big data analysis. On the basis of this, a semi-supervised user interest matching prediction algorithm was proposed in this paper. According to the individual state division method of compartment model, network public opinion propagation model is constructed based on user interest matching through state transition analysis and inference of state transition probability. The results show that the model can well describe the law of public opinion propagation in social networks, and truly reflect the propagation of network public opinion in the Internet.

Mathematical model of interest matchmaking in electronic social networks

OptMatch

Price of Anarchy in Algorithmic Matching of Romantic Partners

Social Networks and Stable Matchings in the Job Market

An ODE Model for Dynamic Matching in Heterogeneous Networks

A Model about Love in Human Dynamics

Influence network design via multi-level optimization considering boundedly rational user behaviours in social media networks

Exploring Trade-Offs for Online Mental Health Matching: Agent-Based Modeling Study

Mathematical modeling of competition in sponsored search market

Stable Matchings in Metric Spaces: Modeling Real-World Preferences using Proximity

When Online Dating Meets Nash Social Welfare: Achieving Efficiency and Fairness.

Two-Sided Random Matching Markets: Ex-Ante Equivalence of the Deferred Acceptance Procedures

Social Networks and the Choices People Make

Online Elicitation of Necessarily Optimal Matchings

Designing Approximately Optimal Search on Matching Platforms

Advertising Competitions in Social Networks

Online Algorithms for Matching Platforms with Multi-Channel Traffic

Matching with Trade-offs: Revealed Preferences over Competing Characteristics

Online Matching in Geometric Random Graphs

Modeling and Simulation of Network Public Opinion Propagation Model Based on Interest Matching in Social Network