GRB 060714: No Clear Dividing Line Between Prompt Emission and X-ray Flares

H. A. Krimm,J. Granot,F. Marshal,M. Perri,S. D. Barthelmy,D. N. Burrows,N. Gehrels,P. Mészáros,D. Morris

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1086/519019

2007-04-16

Abstract:The long gamma-ray burst GRB 060714 was observed to exhibit a series of five X-ray flares beginning ~70 s after the burst trigger T0 and continuing until T0 + ~200 s. The first two flares were detected by the Burst Alert Telescope (BAT) on the Swift satellite, before Swift had slewed to the burst location, while the last three flares were strongly detected by the X-Ray Telescope (XRT) but only weakly detected by the BAT. This burst provides an unusual opportunity to track a complete sequence of flares over a wide energy range. The flares were very similar in their light curve morphology, showing power-law rise and fall components, and in most cases significant sub-structure. The flares also showed strong evolution with time, both spectrally and temporally. The small time scale and large amplitude variability observed are incompatible with an external shock origin for the flares, and support instead late time sporadic activity either of the central source or of localized dissipation events within the outflow. We show that the flares in GRB 060714 cannot be the result of internal shocks in which the contrast in the Lorentz factor of the colliding shells is very small, and that this mechanism faces serious difficulties in most Swift GRBs. The morphological similarity of the flares and the prompt emission and the gradual and continual evolution of the flares with time makes it difficult and arbitrary to draw a dividing line between the prompt emission and the flares.

Astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is the origin of X - ray flares in gamma - ray bursts (GRBs). Specifically, the paper explores whether these flares have the same origin as the initial gamma - ray burst explosion (the so - called "prompt emission"), or whether they are generated by an external shock wave (i.e., afterglow emission). By analyzing in detail the observational data of GRB 060714, especially a series of X - ray flares therein, the authors found that the boundary between these flares and the initial explosion is not clear, and the characteristics of the flares (such as time evolution, spectral changes, etc.) do not support the origin hypothesis of the external shock wave. Instead, these flares are more likely to be the result of late - stage activities of the central source or local dissipation events within the outflow.

### Main research questions
1. **Relationship between flares and initial explosion**: Is there a clear boundary to distinguish the initial explosion (prompt emission) of a gamma - ray burst from the subsequent X - ray flares?
2. **Origin of flares**: Are the flares caused by an external shock wave (afterglow emission) or an internal mechanism (such as late - stage activities of the central source or local dissipation events within the outflow)?

### Research methods
- **Multi - band observation**: Use the Burst Alert Telescope (BAT) and X - Ray Telescope (XRT) on the Swift satellite for multi - band observation, and record the complete process from the initial explosion to subsequent flares.
- **Spectral and temporal analysis**: Conduct a detailed analysis of the spectral characteristics and time evolution of the flares, including the energy - spectrum index of the flares, the peak energy (\(E_{\text{peak}}\)), the total radiated energy (\(E_{\gamma,\text{iso}}\)), and the time structure of the flares (such as the rise time and the fall time).

### Main findings
- **Similarity between flares and initial explosion**: The spectral characteristics and time evolution of the flares are very similar to those of the initial explosion, indicating that they may have a common origin.
- **Changes in the time scale and amplitude of flares**: The flares show rapid rise and fall, and there are significant energy - spectrum changes in a short time, which are inconsistent with the characteristics of the external shock wave.
- **Energy - spectrum evolution**: The energy - spectrum index of the flares softens over time, and the peak energy \(E_{\text{peak}}\) decreases over time. These characteristics support the hypothesis of an internal mechanism.

### Conclusion
The paper concludes that the X - ray flares in GRB 060714 are difficult to be explained by an external shock wave (i.e., afterglow emission), and are more likely to be the result of late - stage activities of the central source or local dissipation events within the outflow. These findings challenge the traditional theory of the origin of gamma - ray burst flares and propose new research directions.