Speculations on the emergence of self-awareness in big-brained organisms

Emmanuel Tannenbaum
DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.q-bio/0701017
2007-06-02
Abstract:This paper argues that self-awareness is a learned behavior that emerges in organisms whose brains have a sufficiently integrated, complex ability for associative learning and memory. Continual sensory input of information related to the organism causes the organism's brain to learn the physical characteristics of the organism, in the sense that neural pathways are produced that are reinforced by, and therefore recognize, various features associated with the organism. This results in the formation of a set of associations that may be termed an organismal self-image, which provides a mechanistic basis for the emergence of various behaviors that are associated with self-awareness, such as self-recognition. In humans, self-awareness includes additional behaviors such as recognition of self-awareness, the concept of I, and various existential and religious questions. This paper shows how associative memory and learning, combined with an organismal self-image and, in the case of humans, language, leads to the emergence of these various behaviors. This paper also discusses various tautologies that invariably emerge when discussing self-awareness, that ultimately prevent an unambiguous resolution to the various existential issues that arise. We continue with various speculations on manipulating self-awareness, and discuss how concepts from set and logic may provide a highly useful set of tools in computational neuroscience for understanding the emergence of higher cognitive functions in complex organisms. The existence of other types of awareness, and the role of mirror neurons in the emergence of self-awareness, are also briefly discussed.
Neurons and Cognition,Populations and Evolution
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### What problems does this paper attempt to solve? This paper explores how self - awareness arises in complex organisms in the brain. Specifically, the author raises the following main questions and hypotheses: 1. **The nature of self - awareness**: - Self - awareness is an ability that organisms acquire through learning behaviors, rather than being innate. - This ability depends on complex associative memory and learning mechanisms in the brain. 2. **The formation of self - image**: - Through continuous sensory input, the brain gradually forms neural pathways related to the organism itself. - These neural pathways define a set of associations, called "self - image", which enables the organism to recognize itself. 3. **Behavioral manifestations of self - awareness**: - The paper discusses several typical behaviors that are usually considered manifestations of self - awareness, such as: - Self - recognition in the mirror - The concept of "I" or "Me" - Awareness of being self - aware 4. **The evolutionary basis of self - awareness**: - It explores why some organisms (such as humans, gorillas, dolphins, and elephants) exhibit self - awareness while others do not. - It analyzes the selection pressure of self - awareness in evolution and how it is related to complex brain structures. 5. **Philosophical and theological backgrounds**: - Self - awareness has long been associated with the concept of "soul" in philosophy and theology, which has led to relatively little research on this phenomenon in the scientific community. - The paper attempts to study self - awareness from a mechanistic perspective, avoiding getting into traditional philosophical debates. 6. **Experimental verification and future directions**: - It proposes some experimental methods to manipulate and test self - awareness to verify the hypotheses proposed in the paper. - It explores how to use tools such as set theory and logical theory to understand high - level cognitive functions in complex organisms. ### Formula examples To ensure the correctness and readability of formulas, the following are some formula examples that may be involved in the paper (if more specific formulas are required, please provide detailed content): - **Probability model of mirror self - recognition**: \[ P(\text{Self - Recognition}) = f(\text{Neural Pathways}, \text{Sensory Inputs}) \] where \( f \) is a function representing the relationship between neural pathways and sensory inputs. - **Mathematical expression of auto - associative learning**: \[ w_{ij} = w_{ij} + \eta (x_i x_j - w_{ij}) \] where \( w_{ij} \) represents the connection weight between neurons \( i \) and \( j \), \( \eta \) is the learning rate, and \( x_i \) and \( x_j \) are the activation states of neurons. Through these questions and hypotheses, the paper aims to provide a new perspective for understanding the origin and development of self - awareness and a theoretical framework for further research.